Workweek overhaul raises questions about productivity, business costs - Valor International
Reducing working hours and the length of the workweek is a legitimate aspiration for workers, but it does not always translate into productivity gains through lower fatigue or more efficient work organization. An analysis of international experiences suggests that the pace of the transition and the mechanisms put in place to help businesses adapt are important factors in determining the economic risks of such changes. Brazil’s proposed reform combines two measures—ending the current six-day-on, one-day-off (6x1) work schedule and reducing the standard workweek from 44 to 40 hours—while allowing for a very short transition period and starting from a weak productivity position. The change also comes at a time of unfavorable macroeconomic conditions for absorbing higher costs.
That is the assessment of ARX Investimentos, which compiled data from studies of similar changes in other countries. “In several countries that reduced weekly working hours, the consensus in the academic literature is that productivity gains were shared with workers,” said Gabriel Leal de Barros, chief economist at ARX. In those cases, he noted, productivity gains had been sustained and recurring before working hours were reduced. In most cases, according to the economist, employment and wage levels remained flat or declined.
Shorter workweek brings costs, hiring challenges and opportunitiesShorter workweek could add 0.3 point to inflation in 2027Supreme Court rejects delay to shorter workweek rollout
South Korea’s experience stands out as an exception, the study points out. The reduction in the country’s workweek from 44 to 40 hours was assessed by the Korea Development Institute, which found a 1.5% increase in output per worker in the manufacturing sector after the change, particularly in industries where working hours had previously been considered excessively long. However, South Korea’s reform was implemented over a longer period, at different paces depending on the sector and company size, said Cléo Olimpio, an economist at ARX. Matheus Caliano and Eric Fernandes also contributed to the study.
In South Korea, the reduction in working hours took seven years, from 2004 to 2011, Olimpio noted. A more gradual transition, she argued, gives companies the means to limit negative effects. “The way the change was proposed in Brazil, without giving companies time to prepare, seems to me to be the worst part of the design.”
In Brazil, Constitutional Amendment 141/26, enacted on October 16, established a reduction in the maximum workweek from 44 to 40 hours. The first cut, to 42 hours, is scheduled to take effect two months after the law passed. Twelve months after that initial reduction, the limit will fall to 40 hours a week. The right to two days off per week is also set to take effect in the first phase, alongside the reduction to 42 hours.
Even in some countries where the transition took longer, the results were not particularly positive, Olimpio said. ARX’s survey cites a study of France’s reduction in the workweek from 39 to 35 hours between 1998 and 2002. The change included adjustment mechanisms such as a phased rollout based on company size, combined with tax relief and collective bargaining. Some studies found higher employee turnover, while evidence of job creation is considered mixed. The report also cites a 2023 study that analyzed five European reforms involving reductions in working hours implemented between 1995 and 2007. According to the study, lowering the maximum number of working hours was accompanied by an increase in hourly wages, but not by significant growth in employment or productivity.
Looking at countries with conditions more comparable to Brazil’s, the ARX report highlighted cases in which working-hour reductions are being phased in over longer periods. Colombia, the firm noted, is implementing a reduction from 48 to 42 hours a week over a five-year transition ending in 2026. Chile is cutting its workweek from 45 to 40 hours over a similar five-year period, running through 2028. In both cases, according to ARX, there is either no conclusive evidence of the overall effects or no consensus among assessments. In Mexico, the reduction from 48 to 40 hours a week is scheduled to begin in 2027, with a transition period of nearly four years.
Barros highlighted Brazil’s low productivity. The report cites data from the International Labour Organization showing that labor productivity in Brazil, measured as output per hour worked, stands at just over $21 in 2021 purchasing power parity terms. That is virtually in line with the Latin American average, but below levels in comparable countries such as Chile, Argentina, and Mexico, and well below those recorded in developed economies, the report points out. In the United States, each hour worked generates about $80 in output, while productivity in countries such as France, Germany, and Japan is more than twice Brazil’s level. Brazil ranks just 85th among the 174 countries assessed. “The starting point is weak, and we have no productivity gains to share because there haven’t been any. What we can do is try to mitigate the negative effects, given that the change has already been decided,” Barros said.
The economist noted that small and midsize businesses are likely to face the greatest difficulties in adapting. He cited a government survey based on data from December last year, which shows that approximately 14.8 million workers follow the 6x1 schedule, equivalent to about one-third of the employment relationships analyzed. Of those 14.8 million workers, around 5.5 million are employed by micro and small businesses. Smaller companies, according to Barros, have less capacity to absorb shocks because of their limited financial resources and the difficulty of reorganizing work schedules at short notice. The current environment is already challenging, Barros added, given high levels of debt across the private sector, among both companies and households. He pointed out that corporate delinquency rates have risen significantly again since the pandemic, but the situation is particularly concerning among micro, small, and midsize businesses, where the rate has doubled from 3% at the end of 2022 to 6% in March this year.
In Barros’s view, the implementation of shorter working hours and fewer working days needs to allow for more flexible arrangements in the sectors most affected.
Olimpio also suggested that granting exemptions to certain industries. “The 40-hour workweek would remain in place, but companies would not necessarily have to adopt a five-day-on, two-day-off (5x2) schedule, depending on the needs of the sector.” The most important measure, she emphasized, although it is a long-term agenda, is a plan to boost productivity.
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.


