What Xi, Putin and Trump wanted – and what they got - The Telegraph
Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping clearly regarded their meeting in China as a triumphant personal vindication Credit: Win McNamee/Pool Photo/AP David Blair Chief Foreign Affairs Commentator. Roland Oliphant Chief Foreign Analyst Published 19 November 2026 2:44pm GMT As they gathered before a painting of the Great Wall of China, Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping clearly regarded the Shenzhen meeting as a triumphant personal vindication.
For Trump, this was the apotheosis of his brand of diplomacy, whereby his personal friendship with Xi and Putin might resolve every problem and open a new era of peace, whatever the rest of the world might think.
For Xi, the meeting demonstrated China’s ability to convene the only world leaders whom he regards as peers – or near enough in the case of Putin – and urge them, without apparent irony, to “be good role models” and “make a greater contribution to the progress of humanity”.
As for Putin, the occasion was everything he could have wished for – visible proof that Russia under his leadership occupies the pinnacle of global power, dealing on supposedly equal terms with China and America, and confounding all attempts to punish him with diplomatic isolation for his onslaught against Ukraine.
All this explains the obvious self-satisfaction exuded by each leader in Kylin Villa, an opulent lakeside resort of the kind that Trump himself might have designed. Despite the harmony on the surface, however, each brought clashing objectives to their 90-minute meeting. So who wanted what? And who got what?
For Xi, the meeting demonstrated China’s ability to convene the only world leaders whom he regards as peers Credit: Sergey Bobylev/Sputnik/Kremlin Pool/ EPA /Shutterstock What he wantedXi wanted the prestige of hosting a meeting that will inevitably be presented as the ultimate example of Great Power diplomacy in the Yalta tradition. As he chaired the gathering, Xi took the opportunity to regale a global audience with the finest tropes of Chinese diplomacy – apparently harmless generalisations, with no mention of any specific issue, but laden with hidden meaning.
“History is the best textbook,” announced Xi in his opening remarks, by which he meant that China’s history as a single nation goes back more than 2,000 years, so you should all pay special attention or, better still, treat my pronouncements as your textbook.
“Changes not seen in a century are accelerating across the world,” added Xi, which was his way of saying that China’s power is growing with ever greater speed, while America is heading in the opposite direction.
“The three of us should be good role models,” he concluded, raising the question – which, in Xi’s mind, has one obvious answer – of which of the three is the best role model for the other two, and the rest of the world, to follow.
Xi got the acclaim of being the gracious host and a joint statement with Russia and the US, the first point of which reads: “As permanent members of the United Nations Security Council, China, Russia and the United States are committed to promoting United Nations reform so that it may respond more effectively to global challenges and fulfil its fundamental mission of maintaining international peace and security.”
In China’s eyes, that means the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights must never again reveal inconvenient truths about Xi’s atrocities. In 2022, the UN declared that China’s mass incarceration of millions of people from the Uyghur minority in Xinjiang province “may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity”. China will now claim the US’s support for stopping any repetition of that episode.
As for Trump’s once-vaunted tariffs, loathed by China for their impact on its exports, there was no mention of them either in the opening remarks or the joint statement.
For Trump, the meeting was the apotheosis of his brand of diplomacy Credit: Mandel Ngan/ AFP via Getty Images What he wantedTrump came to the meeting armed with more points of substance than either of his counterparts. He stressed how the countries at the table were the world’s “largest nuclear powers”, making them “uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth”.
He wanted to “cooperate to combat the threat of nuclear proliferation in other countries around the world”, adding: “We’re not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon.” Trump also referred to resolving the war in Ukraine and claimed that “things were moving”.
Trump’s problem is that his friend Xi is busily expanding China’s nuclear arsenal with astonishing speed, more than doubling the stockpile from 200 to over 500 warheads in three years from 2020 to 2023. Nothing is going to stop Xi from churning out even more nuclear weapons, at least until China achieves parity with the United States.
So the fourth point of the joint statement amounts to a meagre bone for Trump. “The three heads of state reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must not be fought,” it declares, echoing familiar language that all three countries have signed up to before. “The three countries will engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation,” it added. But promising “dialogue” alone is almost meaningless, particularly as there was no mention of what Trump wants, which is nuclear arms reduction.
For Putin, the meeting was everything he could have wished for Credit: Sputnik/Sergei Bobylyov/Pool via Reuters What he wantedPutin wanted the symbolic victory of being treated on equal terms by Xi and Trump, even though Russia’s economy is less than a tenth of the size of America’s and barely an eighth of China’s.
Yet Putin was also seeking points of substance. He wanted Trump to agree to a form of words opposing both energy sanctions on Russia, and Ukraine’s long-range strikes on the country’s energy infrastructure. Putin also wanted his counterparts to denounce the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has indicted him for war crimes in Ukraine.
Putin got almost all of the above. China did not shower Putin with flattery. He was greeted at the airport not by Xi himself, but by an underling, who happened to be unusually tall, highlighting Putin’s vertical limitations. In the group photograph on Wednesday, he was directed to stand next to Peng Liyuan, Xi’s wife, rather than the man himself.
Trump, by contrast, obliged Putin (“my friend”) in every respect, as reflected in the joint statement. The second point reads: “The three countries plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations. They reaffirmed the importance of stable energy flows.”
The main barriers to Russia, the world’s third-largest oil producer, from supplying more of those products are international sanctions, along with the fact that Ukraine is busily engaged in destroying its neighbour’s oil refineries. By signing this statement, Trump was implicitly opposing both Ukraine’s actions and the US’s own sanctions on Russia.
The icing on the cake for Putin was the third point of the joint statement: “The three heads of state recognised that the principle of national consent and respect for the immunity of state officials are of paramount importance, and agreed that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.”
The US has always opposed the ICC, but securing Trump’s agreement to this stark condemnation was an obvious victory for the only leader at the meeting who has personally been indicted for war crimes.
As yet another favour for his Russian “friend”, Trump turned on the ICC during his opening remarks, denouncing a “globalist organisation” that has “really strayed beyond its jurisdiction”. Putin, as well he might, nodded and smiled.
Trump, Putin and Xi have less power to impose their will on the rest of the world than they might think Credit: Andres Martinez Casares/Pool/Getty Images Despite being the ultimate practitioners of power politics, Trump, Putin and Xi have less power to impose their will on the rest of the world than they might think. The Big Three who met at Yalta in 1945 – Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin – commanded armies of millions who were, at that moment, in de facto occupation of most of Europe, the continent whose fate they were deciding. Their respective countries and empires jointly comprised about 85 per cent of world GDP, more than twice the 42 per cent represented by the US and China today, with Russia adding a mere 2 per cent.
Trump has so far been unable to compel Ukraine to surrender or prevent Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky from striking targets deep inside Russia. He cannot force Europe to stop arming and funding Ukraine’s struggle against invasion.
Nor can Trump lift the US’s oil and gas sanctions on Russia, since they have been imposed by Congress. The Democrats, soon to be in control of both Houses, are not going to oblige him by repealing the relevant laws, notably the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act of 2017.
“He cannot lift sanctions without Congressional approval, which doesn’t look likely after the mid-terms,” says Alexander Kolyandr, a director at the Eurasia Group, a New York-based think tank. “But he can issue exemptions, special licences and waivers.”
Waiving sanctions, the best that Trump could do, is very different from abolishing them, since they might easily be re-imposed by his successor, meaning that most companies would probably remain deeply reluctant to do business with Russia. In any case, Trump cannot force the EU or Britain to lift their sanctions on Russia.
So all three leaders will be mightily satisfied with their handiwork in Shenzhen. Yet the resurgence of Great Power diplomacy has ironically coincided with Trump losing much of his ability to deliver.
