The myth of the ‘perfect victim’
In the month leading to International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women, which we commemorate on Nov. 25, an allegation of sexual assault at a prestigious university has re-ignited discussion about the safety of women, the requirements of consent and the rape myths that create the idea of the “perfect victim.” The incident concerning the so-called “Cornell 7” reached international news upon the filing of a civil case by the alleged victim, who claimed that seven fraternity members allegedly drugged and sexually assaulted her over several hours in October 2024. The civil lawsuit, coupled with other reports as well as statements from Cornell – which had conducted its own investigation after the events, which is also currently under scrutiny – allows a timeline to be created that shows the nature of the circumstances as we know it surrounding the incident in October 2024:
The woman who filed the suit, referred to as Jane Doe, drank alcohol at her sorority house and at the bar where the fraternity party was taking place, where she was allegedly served alcohol despite saying she was underage. Later that night she arrived at the fraternity house “visibly intoxicated” and says that she was pressured into taking ketamine by two fraternity brothers who then propositioned a threesome. Afterwards, one of the men allegedly sends a message to the fraternity’s Snapchat group of more than 50 men, suggesting that she was available for “free” sex; another member later asked “Shop still open?” and received the response, “Yea.”
Multiple fraternity members allegedly show up and rape her over several hours, even “pouring lines of Ketamine all over her body and snorting them,” before the woman loses consciousness. The woman sent some apparently friendly texts to members of the fraternity for a few days after, but that quickly changes and around two weeks later she reports the incident to the campus police, where she states that “I can say with 100 percent confidence I was raped” – but it is now known that the campus police omitted this in the report they sent to the prosecutor.
Cornell University commenced what is known as a Title IX investigation, holding multiple hearings over a four-week period, and eventually two of the accused were expelled, two suspended for at least two semesters, one had already graduated before any punishment could be handed down and two were found not to be responsible for sexual misconduct. Allegedly, at least some of the accused were directed to undergo training and “write reflective essays” and none of the accused are criminally prosecuted. However, Jane Doe was not informed of the results of the investigation. She filed her civil lawsuit in September this year.
The allegations made by Jane Doe and the failure of institutional action that followed is horrific to me and to many others, and yet while much of the reaction to the case was of condemnation and calls for action, the circumstances attendant to the event and all that surrounded it provided, unfortunately, fertile ground for victim blaming and a regurgitation of myths and misconceptions about rape and consent.
Those who would excuse the assault point to Jane Doe’s initial willing consumption of alcohol as somehow disqualifying her claim to have been mentally incapacitated by drugs or drink – a position that has been codified into law in certain places, including New York where the alleged assault took place.
As happens all too frequently, there was also no shortage of people that went after the character of Jane Doe herself – the differing tenor of her accounts of what happened, or her choice to drink or attend the party in the first place, such as an opinion piece in USA Today which ended with the line: “Regretting one’s bad decisions is a far cry from rape.” The persistence and prevalence of these opinions – and the belief that something is not “real rape” unless it adheres to strict conditions, which include the pristine virtue of the victim – show how much work still has to be done to explain the concept of consent and the inherent and equal dignity of women.
A woman is not property, to be passed around or offered to others like a bag of chips. A woman’s refusal is not of less value than a man’s request, nor can it be presumed to encompass more than anything explicitly said. A woman’s right to her body is in no way lessened by what she wears, by whom she has chosen to sleep with in the past, by her looks, job, social class or disposition.
A helpful acronym that has been used to understand the nature of consents is that of F-R-I-E-S. Consent must be:
• Enthusiastic; uncertainty is not consent, nor is acquiescence because of expectation or peer pressure – it must come from a genuine desire to say yes.
• Specific; there is no room for hidden meanings – a yes to a date is not a yes to sex, a yes to sex is not a yes to film it.
What makes the Cornell 7 case resonate with so many is not because it is rare, it is because that such treatment of women and the manner by which these acts are defended is all too common, and a sign of the underlying misogyny that must be rooted out.
The attitude that allows men in private groups to talk about women like property is the same that leads to men trafficking Filipino women as “mail-order-brides,” then forcing them to work as prostitutes. These attitudes are not harmless, or traditional, or something that can be excused by “boys will be boys.”
Boys, and girls, will be how we raise them to be. It is our job to raise them to understand consent, women’s equality and basic human dignity. Or else acts of violence against women will remain commonplace, and that is unacceptable.
Consent and sexual education must be a priority of our schools, and schools and workplaces both must have zero tolerance for cultures of misogyny.
abtestabtest Dignity in dying By SKETCHES | By Ana Marie Pamintuan | 1 day ago This year I lost my mother. It was heart-wrenching to watch the vivacious woman I knew wither away before my eyes, physically and mentally, her memories so degraded she could no longer recognize her children. Opinion Lucrative laundering business By CTALK | By Cito Beltran | 1 day ago The laundry shop business is certainly booming. But recently another kind of laundry service has been booming too – it is money laundering with impunity. Opinion Project Airbag By VIRTUAL REALITY | By Tony Lopez | 3 days ago Taipan Henry “Big Boy” Sy Jr. hosted a rare impromptu Chinese lunch for senior business journalists at upscale China Blue restaurant in the family’s five-star Conrad Hotel Thursday. He... Opinion Stronger Asean for a more secure Philippines By BABE’S EYE VIEW FROM WASHINGTON D.C. | By Ambassador B. Romualdez | 2 days ago For an archipelagic country like the Philippines, security at sea is inseparable from the daily lives of our people. Opinion EDITORIAL — Budget accountability 7 days ago As the Senate continued deliberations on the proposed national budget for 2027, watchdogs upped their tally of insertions and discretionary funds prone to political patronage in the version of the outlay passed by... Opinion Latest More in Opinion EDITORIAL – Dearly departed pets Symbiosis Big Boy’s hot pitch: A nationwide solar/RE ‘power bank’ One strait, one tank, one drought abtest EDITORIAL — Day of the (tokhang) dead 1 day ago The nation remembers departed souls today as thousands of bereaved families wait for justice for the loved ones they have lost. Opinion How we serve the smallest must be our measure of success By GO NEGOSYO PILIPINAS ANGAT LAHAT! | By Joey Concepcion | 1 day ago When the sun rises, it rises for everyone. Opinion SGV: Eight decades of excellence By QWERTYMAN | By Jose Dalisay | 1 day ago I’m not an accountant and never took an accounting subject – I couldn’t tell you the difference between “book value” and “equity” if my life depended on it – but as... Opinion Delicadeza, anyone? By COMMONSENSE | By Marichu A. Villanueva | 1 day ago An old Filipino word delicadeza is a borrowed Spanish word referring to a sense of propriety, moral integrity, discretion and decency. Opinion Recommended 2027 budget ‘pupurgahin’ - Lacson November 2, 2026 - 12:00am Buo ang suporta ng mayorya ng Senado sa hakbang ni Senate Finance Committee Chairman Sen. JV Ejercito na linisin ang panukalang 2027 national budget sa pamamagitan ng pagtanggal sa mga kuwestiyonable, hindi kinakailangan...r OpinionDPWH VP Sara trial posibleng matapos ngayong Nobyembre November 2, 2026 - 12:00am Posibleng matapos ngayong Nobyembre ang impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte kung maipiprisinta ng depensa ang ebidensya nito para sa natitirang artikulo ng impeachment sa loob ng 10 araw ng...r OpinionSARA Phal-UAE Oil Hub, isinusulong ni Tulfo November 2, 2026 - 12:00am Isinusulong ni Senador Erwin Tulfo, chairman ng Senate Energy Committee, ang pakikipagtulungan sa United Arab Emirates (UAE) para sa pagtatayo ng malaking oil storage facility na magsisilbing regional oil hub ng...r OpinionERWIN TULFO Class suspensions sa El Niño, iwasan – Win November 2, 2026 - 12:00am Hinimok ni Senate President Win Gatchalian ang Department of Education na tiyaking naipatutupad ang mga El Niño protocol nang hindi nalalagay sa alanganin ang pagkatuto ng mga mag-aaral. OpinionDEPED Loans, account transfers hindi isinama sa kita ni VP Sara – Adiong November 1, 2026 - 12:00am Nilinaw ni House prosecution spokesperson at Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong na hindi ibinilang bilang personal na kita nina Vice President Sara Duterte at asawang si Atty. Mans Carpio ang kanilang...r OpinionBANK next Recommended 2027 budget ‘pupurgahin’ - Lacson Buo ang suporta ng mayorya ng Senado sa hakbang ni Senate Finance Committee Chairman Sen. JV Ejercito na linisin ang panukalang 2027 national budget sa pamamagitan ng pagtanggal sa mga kuwestiyonable, hindi kinakailangan at posibleng pagmulan ng korapsyon na mga alokasyon, ayon kay Sen. Panfilo “Ping” Lacson. 1 day ago DPWH VP Sara trial posibleng matapos ngayong Nobyembre Posibleng matapos ngayong Nobyembre ang impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte kung maipiprisinta ng depensa ang ebidensya nito para sa natitirang artikulo ng impeachment sa loob ng 10 araw ng paglilitis, ayon kay Batangas 2nd District Rep. Gerville Luistro, lead House prosecutor. 1 day ago SARA Phal-UAE Oil Hub, isinusulong ni Tulfo Isinusulong ni Senador Erwin Tulfo, chairman ng Senate Energy Committee, ang pakikipagtulungan sa United Arab Emirates (UAE) para sa pagtatayo ng malaking oil storage facility na magsisilbing regional oil hub ng Pilipinas. 1 day ago ERWIN TULFO Class suspensions sa El Niño, iwasan – Win Hinimok ni Senate President Win Gatchalian ang Department of Education na tiyaking naipatutupad ang mga El Niño protocol nang hindi nalalagay sa alanganin ang pagkatuto ng mga mag-aaral. 1 day ago DEPED Loans, account transfers hindi isinama sa kita ni VP Sara – Adiong Nilinaw ni House prosecution spokesperson at Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong na hindi ibinilang bilang personal na kita nina Vice President Sara Duterte at asawang si Atty. Mans Carpio ang kanilang mga utang, time deposits, investments at paglilipat ng pera sa mga bank account. 2 days ago BANK OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
