Stop whining about beer, it has defined Britain for centuries - The Telegraph
Drinkers in a Newcastle pub, January 1961 Credit: Bert Hardy Advertising Archive/Getty Images Jane Shilling Show biography Jane Shilling is a columnist and critic who has written on books, the arts, food and gardening for the Daily and Sunday Telegraph, the Times, Daily Mail, Prospect Magazine and The Oldie. She is the author of two books, including “The Stranger in the Mirror”, a BBC Book of the Week.
As advent approaches, with its welcome promise of conviviality and cheer amid the encircling gloom, a curious counter-movement of anti-celebration seems to be forming. Here, for example, is news of a study from Anglia Ruskin University, which concluded that regular beer and spirit drinkers are at greater risk of acute kidney injury than wine-bibbers. Cheers!
Those of us contemplating the beverages on offer at the office Christmas bash might not wholeheartedly agree with Disraeli’s languid Mr Mountchesney, that: “I rather like bad wine. One gets so bored with good wine.” We might fare better with a tankard of our national drink: beer.
The Celts were brewing ale long before the Romans arrived, and while the Latin invaders planted vineyards, they also developed a taste for home brew: tablets found at the Roman fort of Vindolanda reveal a busy trade in beer for the garrison. And while the Plantagenet monarchs’ French provinces kept England awash with claret, beer remained the ubiquitous beverage, drunk by everyone (not least because quality control by ale-conners meant it was more wholesome than water).
Andy Burnham drinks a pint of beer during a visit to the Hare Inn in Harlow Credit: Richard Pohle/ POOL /AFP Alcohol consumption has always been as much about politics and class as thirst-quenching. Shakespeare’s plays abound in slighting references to beer: Prince Hal reflects that his appetite for small beer was “not princely got”, while Falstaff praises the masculinity-enhancing properties of “a good sherris-sack”.
By the 18th century, opinion had shifted again. While Whigs and Tories conducted a vinous debate on the relative merits of claret (foppish Tory Francophilia) and Spanish red wine (bullish Whig Francophobia), a more urgent debate was being conducted about the social horrors of gin distilling versus the sturdy tradition of brewing.
Beer vs Gin – the merits of the English drink were all too apparent to the 18th century satirist Credit: William Hogarth, 1751 In 1751 the artist William Hogarth published a pair of prints, Gin Lane and Beer Street: haunting depictions of the contrasting effects of the two intoxicants. Amid the unspeakable squalor and depravity of Gin Lane, the sufferings of children are depicted with appalling verisimilitude: in the foreground an infant plummets to its death, dropped by its drunken mother; a woman pours a dram of gin into a baby’s mouth and a child weeps by the naked body of its dead mother. Only the pawnbroker’s shop prospers.
In Beer Street by contrast, all is ale-fuelled cheer and prosperity. Sturdy butchers and fishwives ply their trade grasping foaming tankards; the pawnbroker’s is in ruins and children are nowhere to be seen. A triumphant verse announces: “We quaff Thy balmy juice with Glee/And Water leave to France.”
Hogarth explored the theme of thin pickings for the French in his 1748 painting, The Gate of Calais, inspired by his friend Henry Fielding’s patriotic ballad, The Roast Beef of Old England. In the painting, a chef carries a vast side of beef to an English tavern, the Lion d’Argent, while emaciated French soldiers, nourished on a cauldron of grey gruel, look on hungrily.
A Hogarthian parable: English abundance vs French squalor Credit: William Hogarth, 1748 So while our own Whigs and Tories debate the relative merits of claret and rioja at the office bash, the rest of us (studiously ignoring the fact that the best ever song about beer, La bière, was written by a Belgian, Jacques Brel) can sup our pints of Side Pocket for a Toad and Juice Forsythe in patriotic contentment. After all, as the urbane wit and gastronomic sybarite, the Revd. Sydney Smith, put it: “What two ideas are more inseparable than Beer and Britannia?”


