Police, BMC helpless: High Court weighs Mumbai firecracker ban as pollution worsens
The Bombay High Court on Thursday indicated that it may impose sweeping restrictions, including a possible ban on individual bursting of firecrackers in Mumbai, to tackle worsening air and noise pollution. Observing that citizens continued to violate permissible timings and rules despite repeated warnings, the court said drastic measures were needed in the larger interest of the city's residents.
A bench of Justices GS Kulkarni and Dr Neela Gokhale said the police and municipal authorities had been unable to effectively enforce restrictions during the Diwali festivities, when the city's air quality deteriorated sharply.
The bench made the observations while reserving its order in a suo motu public interest litigation (PIL) on air pollution. The court had earlier described cities as turning into "gas chambers" and prohibited the bursting of firecrackers on public roads.COURT FLAGS 332 FIRE INCIDENTS DURING DIWALI
The bench also referred to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation's (BMC) decision to prohibit aerial firecrackers during Diwali, calling it an important measure to protect people's properties.
"There were 332 fires in the city. If it is the correct figure which is actually being reflected in the news reports, then it is alarming," Justice Kulkarni observed.
The judges expressed concern over the lack of public sensitivity towards the health hazards of pollution, noting that Mumbai's Air Quality Index (AQI) had peaked during the Diwali celebrations.
"They have no possible sensitivity in regard to the pollution and how hazardous it is... The AQI at a particular point of time during the Diwali festival was at the highest. We want to prevent this," the bench said.
The court said it was considering drastic directions to prevent further deterioration in the city's environment, arguing that repeated appeals to citizens had failed to change behaviour.
"We'll have to take some drastic orders now, really, in the larger interest of lakhs of citizens of this city. And unless we have this kind of proactive approach, nothing is going to improve," the bench said.
It also noted that firecrackers continued to be burst well beyond the permissible hours, sometimes until 3 am, causing considerable noise pollution.
"The police and municipal machinery were totally helpless. They did their best, but it was totally beyond their control," the judges remarked.
Stressing that the court would have to "nip it in the bud", the bench said one possible solution was to ban individual bursting of firecrackers across Mumbai.
It suggested allowing only organised community firecracker displays at permitted locations, along the lines of public fireworks shows in other countries, to minimise pollution and exposure to toxic substances.
"There would be only community firecrackers and on permissible grounds where only it would be like in the other countries, which is kind of a fire show with no pollution...only community firecrackers to be used. It is the only solution so that you are relieved of toxicity in the city," the bench said.
The judges also stressed that Mumbai's social fabric and strength lay in its sense of togetherness across communities, adding that the prevailing pollution situation was detrimental to the city's quality of life.- EndsMust Watch
Journalist. Where ever there is news, you will find her there. Covers court, crime and is also part of the India Today Fact Check Team. But her first love remains - Photography.

