‘Pingdemic’ damaged economy, Covid Inquiry finds - The Telegraph
A traveller arrives at Heathrow in January 2021 Credit: Hollie Adams/Getty Images Neil Johnston Senior news reporter. Fiona Parker Senior News Reporter Published 19 November 2026 12:01pm GMT The “pingdemic” caused by the Covid-19 contact tracing app had a “direct impact on the economy”, the Covid Inquiry has found.
A report into the “test and trace” strategy found that for one week, some 7 per cent of UK adults – around 4.5 million people – were self-isolating and unable to work.
Baroness Hallett, the chairman of the inquiry, concluded that the economic impact of this was “greater than initially predicted”.
Elsewhere the report found the UK’s lack of border control strategy left the country in an “extremely vulnerable position” at the start of the pandemic and that the country was “woefully ill-prepared” to deliver the £25bn test, trace and isolate systems at the scale or speed required.
The NHS Test and Trace system, designed to locate and track those infected with Covid and their close contacts, was launched in England on May 28, 2020.
Millions downloaded the Test and Trace digital app, but its functionality was criticised, with the report stating: “A lack of confidence in the app’s effectiveness was a key reason for not downloading or retaining it.”
On the “pingdemic” – referring to how the Covid-19 app “pinged” to alert a user they had been in close contact with an infected person, advising them to self-isolate – the report states: “In the summer of 2021, concerns about its effectiveness were exacerbated when a large number of people began receiving such notifications.
“This resulted in high levels of self-isolation, a phenomenon that became commonly known as the ‘pingdemic’.
“At its peak in July 2021, 7 per cent of UK adults – approximately 4.5 million people – were self-isolating within a seven-day period.
“This had a significant impact on labour supply as large numbers of people were temporarily unable to attend work.”
The report continued: “There was also a direct impact on the economy. A Treasury briefing for the Covid-19 Operations Committee… reported that, in part due to the ‘pingdemic’, gross domestic product in the UK fell by 0.2 per cent in July 2021.
“The initial estimate was for 0.1 per cent growth that month, indicating that the economic effects of the ‘pingdemic’ were greater than initially predicted.”
Lady Hallett said there was a “widespread influx” of the virus because of the UK’s inability to deliver the Test and Trace system.
As a result, ministers were “effectively blind” to the scale of the virus, which came into the country and spread “virtually unchecked” for the first few months of the pandemic.
The NHS app used as part of the ‘Test and Trace’ service in 2021 Credit: Christopher Furlong/Getty Images Lady Hallett made the comments in her seventh of 10 reports, which examined the “Test, Trace and Isolate” system.
She said other countries such as Germany, Australia and Singapore were “comparatively better prepared” to respond to the pandemic.
Outlining her findings on Thursday, Lady Hallett said: “There was no strategy for international border control measures – a first and obvious line of defence during the early stages of a novel pandemic.”
She also found digital tracing “failed to take adequate account of language barriers or the challenges some people would face in having access to a phone or digital device”.
Contact tracing was carried out manually and digitally and those at risk of being infected were instructed to isolate.
The inquiry, which is the most expensive in British history, also noted that many of those advised to isolate felt “forgotten and let down by the lack of practical or financial support when trying to follow the rules”.
“I heard distressing accounts from individuals who were faced with the unenviable choice of self-isolating and losing income or going to work and risking spreading the virus,” Lady Hallett added.
The report said that the UK’s test and trace system came “too late” because it had to be built “from the ground up” as the pandemic unfolded.
The inquiry said that the cost of test and trace could have been reduced had the country been better prepared.
In the 245-page report, Lady Hallett noted that by April 2020, 93 per cent of countries had put measures in place to restrict the virus from spreading internationally, including flight suspensions, border closures and travel restrictions.
“By contrast, the UK government only requested (rather than directed) travellers from Wuhan, China, to self-isolate in February 2020,” the report read.
“This did not prevent a coachload of tourists from Wuhan entering the UK and travelling from England to Scotland and then to Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland in February 2020.”
No further border control measures would be implemented in the UK until June 2020.
The report continued: “The Chair also concludes that the UK lacked a strategy for international border controls at the outset of the pandemic. This left the nation in an ‘extremely vulnerable position’ until systematic border control measures were introduced in the summer of 2020.”
Lady Hallett also noted that relations between the government and devolved administrations “broke down at times” and Nicola Sturgeon, the then first minister of Scotland, imposed border controls for travellers from England without consulting Westminster.
She said that in February 2020 the Cabinet had discussed cancelling all flights from China but did not do this. She said that at that time there were only nine cases of Covid and this “would have been an ideal time to implement at least some travel restrictions”.
The inquiry said that community transmission then increased after the “widespread influx” of Covid from several countries.
Lady Hallett also said that the government had hired too many contact tracers and noted headlines from the time about contact tracers being paid to watch Netflix. She said Matt Hancock, the then health secretary, had been “unable to explain” initial decisions on the number of contact tracers.
Lady Hallett made nine recommendations in her report, which included developing a UK-wide digital contact tracing tool, producing a single UK-wide system for testing, tracing and isolation and planning for the use of international border control measures.
In total, 41 witnesses gave oral evidence as part of the module hearings, held in May 2025.
Before publication of the report, a spokesman for the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice UK group said: “The UK’s test and trace system was an abject failure that cost lives.
“Thursday’s report must be honest about those failures and give bereaved families the truth about why their loved ones were left unprotected.
“It must hold those responsible to account and set out what needs to change so we are prepared for the next crisis.”
/https://i.s3.glbimg.com/v1/AUTH_37554604729d4b2f9f3eb9ad8a691345/internal_photos/bs/2026/Z/E/37imQ5RyiBh5JU7NiyBQ/foto11emp-101-medias-b4.jpg)
/https://i.s3.glbimg.com/v1/AUTH_37554604729d4b2f9f3eb9ad8a691345/internal_photos/bs/2022/G/2/dpESlOTpWU4r9AbvuRmA/22esp-100-indus-a18-img02.jpg)
