Oral arguments on BSKE postponement urged anew
MANILA, Philippines — Election lawyer Romulo Macalintal has again asked the Supreme Court (SC) to hear oral arguments on his pending motion for partial reconsideration challenging the constitutionality of the law postponing the November 2026 barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan elections (BSKE).
In a manifestation with motion for clarification and reiterative motion for oral arguments filed on Nov. 18, Macalintal disputed the position of Commission on Elections (Comelec) Chairman George Garcia that Congress would have to pass a new law setting the election date should the SC reverse its earlier ruling upholding Republic Act 12326.
Macalintal argued that the Comelec already has the authority to reschedule and conduct the postponed elections without waiting for another legislative enactment.
He said Sections 5 and 6 of the Omnibus Election Code, read alongside the poll body’s constitutional mandate to administer election laws, require the Comelec to schedule a postponed or failed election within 30 days after the cause of the postponement ceases to exist.
Under this interpretation, a final SC ruling invalidating RA 12326 or its election-deferral provisions would remove the legal obstacle preventing the elections from proceeding, triggering the 30-day period for the Comelec to set the polls.
Macalintal said the poll body would therefore be mandated to act once the reversal becomes final and executory. He cited a hypothetical scenario in which the SC decision becomes final on Jan. 1, 2027, arguing that the Comelec would have 30 days from that date to hold the elections.
He also warned that requiring Congress to pass another law after the SC invalidates the postponement measure would undermine judicial review and allow the legislature to exercise continuing control over the election schedule.
Requiring another legislative enactment, he said, would effectively allow Congress to repeatedly postpone the BSKE even after the Supreme Court had ruled against the legality of its previous action.
“Indeed, under such a posture, Congress would become a super-powerful agency: even if its actions are declared invalid, it would still be the very body to enact a law implementing the election it sought to postpone in its invalid legislation,” Macalintal said in his pleading.
He added that subjecting an election ordered by the court to congressional approval could leave voters without recourse, particularly if a postponement measure is enacted only days before the scheduled polls.
Macalintal also cited the 2025 Supreme Court ruling in Hagedorn v. House of Representatives, which held that the Comelec need not wait for a resolution from the House of Representatives before calling a special election to fill a legislative vacancy.
In that case, the SC recognized that conducting a special election within 60 days of a vacancy is a primary power and duty of the Comelec, and that waiting for a formal legislative declaration could cause unnecessary delays.
Macalintal said the same principle should apply to the BSKE, arguing that the Comelec could immediately schedule and conduct the elections once the statutory basis for their postponement is struck down.
abtestabtest VP Sara’s camp: House discussing no-el in 2028 By Evelyn Macairan | 1 day ago Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo said yesterday that he had received confirmation about ongoing... Headlines Fact check: Viral 'Duterte ASEAN vs. BBM ASEAN' post recycles 2019 SEA Games footage By Geraldine Santos | 1 day ago A viral Duterte vs BBM ASEAN hosting comparison has one problem: The footage is from 2019 Headlines ‘Very clear’ evidence sought in VP trial By Marc Jayson Cayabyab | 1 day ago Senate Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano hopes for clear evidence to help them decide whether to convict or acquit Vice... Headlines Sara Duterte impeachment trial should be more than halfway done, says prosecution By Alyana Uy | 1 day ago The House prosecution panel estimates that Vice President Sara Duterte's defense team is nearing the end of its presentation,... Headlines What Trump said and did in his first hours in Manila 1 day ago The US president used his stop in manila to set the agenda for China and the Quad while reassuring Southeast Asian leade... Headlines Latest More in Headlines 10 areas experience danger-level heat index US eyes $2 billion financing for Philippines defense, West Philippine Sea deterrence Trial by fire: Senate bureau apologizes for video glitch VP’s ex-staff never held captive – lawyer abtest Lawyers question ICC limits on victim participation By Janvic Mateo | 36 minutes ago The legal representatives of victims in the crimes against humanity case against former president Rodrigo Duterte have opposed... Headlines Philippines, Japan envoys sign notes for emergency loan By Pia Lee-Brago | 36 minutes ago The Philippines and Japan signed and exchanged notes for an “Emergency Support Loan” of up to 70 billion yen for... Headlines DOH to distribute free condoms on World AIDS Day By Rhodina Villanueva | 36 minutes ago In line with the observance of World AIDS Day next month, the Department of Health will distribute condoms free of charge... Headlines ASEAN energy solutions must go beyond oil — experts By Alyana Uy | 10 hours ago The calls follow Japan's proposal of an oil stockpiling program to insulate the region against global supply shocks.... Headlines Recommended VP Sara’s camp: House discussing no-el in 2028 1 day ago Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo said yesterday that he had received confirmation about ongoing... HeadlinesNO-ELECTIONSSARA DUTERTE ‘Very clear’ evidence sought in VP trial 1 day ago Senate Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano hopes for clear evidence to help them decide whether to convict or acquit Vice... HeadlinesALAN PETER CAYETANOSARA DUTERTE Sara Duterte impeachment trial should be more than halfway done, says prosecution 1 day ago The House prosecution panel estimates that Vice President Sara Duterte's defense team is nearing the end of its presentation,... HeadlinesACE BARBERSHOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVESHOUSE PROSECUTION PANEL WATCH: Donald Trump describes Sandro Marcos as ‘beautiful young man’ 1 day ago Trump praised both Marcos father and son at the US-ASEAN dinner on Tuesday. HeadlinesASEAN 2026BONGBONG MARCOS JR.DONALD TRUMP Fact check: Viral 'Duterte ASEAN vs. BBM ASEAN' post recycles 2019 SEA Games footage 1 day ago A viral Duterte vs BBM ASEAN hosting comparison has one problem: The footage is from 2019 HeadlinesASEANASEAN 2026BONGBONG MARCOS next Recommended VP Sara’s camp: House discussing no-el in 2028 Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo said yesterday that he had received confirmation about ongoing discussions at the House of Representatives about a no-elections scenario in 2028. 1 day ago NO-ELECTIONS SARA DUTERTE ‘Very clear’ evidence sought in VP trial Senate Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano hopes for clear evidence to help them decide whether to convict or acquit Vice President Sara Duterte, whose impeachment trial resumes today after a break due to the ASEAN Summit hosting. 1 day ago ALAN PETER CAYETANO SARA DUTERTE Sara Duterte impeachment trial should be more than halfway done, says prosecution The House prosecution panel estimates that Vice President Sara Duterte's defense team is nearing the end of its presentation, with the impeachment trial set to resume this week. 1 day ago ACE BARBERS HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES HOUSE PROSECUTION PANEL WATCH: Donald Trump describes Sandro Marcos as ‘beautiful young man’ Trump praised both Marcos father and son at the US-ASEAN dinner on Tuesday. 1 day ago ASEAN 2026 BONGBONG MARCOS JR. DONALD TRUMP Fact check: Viral 'Duterte ASEAN vs. BBM ASEAN' post recycles 2019 SEA Games footage A viral Duterte vs BBM ASEAN hosting comparison has one problem: The footage is from 2019 1 day ago ASEAN ASEAN 2026 BONGBONG MARCOS OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
/https://i.s3.glbimg.com/v1/AUTH_37554604729d4b2f9f3eb9ad8a691345/internal_photos/bs/2026/9/1/06KfnUS9Orb1bBlkYpiw/114385952-27mar2026-ministromaurovieiraconversoucomosecretariodeestadonorte-americano.jpg)
