Mark Carney says he’s open to Canada building Chinese cars. This is the risk we’re ignoring - Toronto Star

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Toronto Star (thestar.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Canada needs stronger protections for its know-how.

Canada needs stronger protections for its know-how.

Prime Minister Mark Carney’s overtures to China need to be backed up by a way to protect Canadian know-how, writes Barry Appleton.

Barry Appleton is Interim Director of the Balsillie Legal Advisory Centre at the Balsillie School of International Affairs and Co-Director of the Center for International Law at New York Law School.

This week in Shenzhen, Prime Minister Mark Carney and China’s President Xi Jinping struck a $400-million deal that restores tariff relief for Canadian pork and seafood. Carney also left a door open. If talks with Washington fail, he says, Canada could turn to Chinese automakers to build cars here.

Diversification of our trade can make sense. But it works only if Canada protects what its firms know.

We have just seen what is at stake. As the Star has reported, the Trump administration had intelligence that a Chinese businesswoman close to Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang could be a spy for Beijing seeking information about U.S. microchips. Beijing calls the claims ”entirely groundless,” and Nvidia’s board says it has no reason to believe its secrets were compromised. Huang was ousted last week, the world’s most valuable company has lost more than a trillion dollars in market value, and Ottawa, mindful of the fact that many Canadian data centres run on Nvidia hardware, says it is ”following the situation closely.”

Nothing has been proven. Markets did not wait for proof.

A modern company’s value lives in its designs, code, data and processes, and that knowledge goes home every night with the people who hold it. Suspicion alone can erase value in hours.

If Carney’s suggestion of greater Canada-China co-operation comes to pass, imagine a battery or auto joint venture in southwestern Ontario, where engineers from two countries share a plant floor, production software and supplier lists for years. Suppose a Canadian supplier’s process and knowledge walks out the door. What can it do?

Trade secret theft is a one-way ticket to a brain drain. Ottawa’s west end has seen it before. Hackers reportedly roamed Nortel’s networks for nearly a decade before the company collapsed in 2009, and its engineers scattered. In 2020, Erin O’Toole, then Leader of the Opposition, told the House of Commons that Huawei theft “may have led to the downfall of Nortel,” citing press reports; Huawei denies it. Theft of know-how is an economic, trade and national security issue at once.

Canada has a criminal offence for trade secret theft, but a prosecution depends on police and Crown attorneys who set their own priorities and must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; neither acts for the company. A firm can sue for breach of confidence (a judge-made doctrine that is slow, uncertain, and expensive), and any such action would struggle to reach the third party who knowingly profits from what was taken.

Canada is the only G7 country without a dedicated civil trade secrets statute, even though we promised in CUSMA Art 20.70(a) to protect trade secrets through civil procedures, and we rely on judge-made law to keep that promise.

Canadians see the risk. An Angus Reid poll released this week found 59 per cent would allow or encourage Chinese investment in electric vehicle and battery plants, and 42 per cent want data security made a priority.

The Prime Minister speaks of ”clear guardrails.” Guardrails need law behind them.

Parliament cannot write that law alone. Civil remedies for misappropriation fall under “property and civil rights in the province,” which section 92(13) of the Constitution Act, 1867 gives to the provinces. Ontario, home to the auto sector and the largest share of Canada’s technology firms, holds the key.

The drafting is already done. In 1989, the Uniform Law Conference of Canada adopted a Uniform Trade Secrets Act. Thirty-seven years later, no province has passed it.

It should define a trade secret clearly, let courts act fast, seal confidential filings, and award real damages. It must also protect employees who change jobs, and whistleblowers who report wrongdoing in good faith.

Law is half the answer. Ottawa should also brief the executives most likely to be targeted and give firms a trusted channel to report suspicious approaches.

The target is theft, whoever commits it. None of this should cast suspicion on Chinese Canadians or on ordinary trade, and the same rule must apply in Shenzhen or Washington.

On Nov. 24, the Balsillie Legal Advisory Centre will bring business, security, legal and government leaders to Waterloo to put the 1989 act back on the provincial agenda. Provincial attorneys general should take it off the shelf, modernize it together, and pass it, and Ontario should go first, before the first Chinese auto plant breaks ground.

Canada needs to get its own act together. It is opening its door wider; it should lock the vault first.

Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request.

There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again.

You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply.

Barry Appleton is Interim Director of the Balsillie Legal Advisory Centre at the Balsillie School of International Affairs and Co-Director of the Center for International Law at New York Law School.

Opinion articles are based on the author’s interpretations and judgments of facts, data and events. More details

Original Source
https://www.thestar.com/opinion/contributors/mark-carney-says-he-s-open-to-canada-building-chinese-cars-this-is-the-risk-we-re-ignoring/article_e66ad45d-a2a8-48e3-90fe-435135a3aaac.html
Visit Toronto Star ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Technology