Makro manager wins Labour Court battle after dismissal for buying pies worth R283 for R7 - IOL

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from IOL News (iol.co.za). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Makro manager reinstated after dismissal for buying pies at R7 each.

Makro manager reinstated after dismissal for buying pies at R7 each.

A Makro manager who was dismissed after buying three pies for R7 each, despite the bulk case carrying a price tag of R283.95, has won his Labour Court battle, with the retailer ordered to reinstate him with immediate effect.

The Labour Court in Johannesburg found that Makro had failed to prove that Sello Daniel Mashabela knowingly took advantage of an incorrect pricing system when he purchased the pies at its Alberton store in April 2023.

Acting Judge M H Mhambi set aside a Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) arbitration award that had upheld Mashabela’s dismissal for gross dishonesty.

The court declared his dismissal substantively unfair and ordered Masstores (Pty) Ltd, trading as Makro, to reinstate him to his former position as Sales Manager: General Merchandise, or a substantially similar position, on terms and conditions no less favourable than those that applied before his dismissal.

The dispute arose on April 10, 2023, when several employees at the Alberton store bought Pieman’s Fresh Baked pies for R7 each.

The pies were normally sold in bulk cases of 12, with a shelf price of R283.95 per case. However, individual pies scanned at R7 at the tills because a single-unit product code remained active on Makro’s system.

Mashabela, who had been employed by Makro since August 2012, testified that assistant front-end manager Sibongile Radebe had informed him that the pies were on markdown.

He, Radebe and another employee, Katisi Mashele, went to the bulk freezer, where a case of pies was taken out and opened.

Mashabela bought three pies for R21 in total, using a colleague's staff card. He received an invoice, left the store and ate the pies with colleagues.

He was subsequently charged with dishonesty for purchasing the pies at R7 each despite the case price of R283.95.

He was found guilty at a disciplinary hearing on July 25, 2023, dismissed on July 28, and unsuccessful in his internal appeal.

He challenged his dismissal at the CCMA alongside two colleagues, Mooki and Matlala. However, commissioner Dumisani Johannes Ngwenya found that the three employees had participated in a concerted effort to defraud Makro.

The commissioner reasoned that their senior positions made it unlikely that they would have been unaware that the pies were sold in bulk and that they should have verified the alleged markdown before purchasing them.

However, Judge Mhambi found that the commissioner had failed to assess Mashabela's individual circumstances and whether he knew the R7 price was incorrect.

The judge said dishonesty required proof that an employee appreciated that the price was wrong, or probably wrong, and deliberately sought to take advantage of it.

"An employee who fails to verify a price before buying an item may be careless, even foolish. That failure is not, without more, dishonest," the judgment stated.

The court found that the three employees had been in materially different positions and that the commissioner had incorrectly attributed the same knowledge and intention to all of them.

It also found that the evidence did not establish that Mashabela had opened the box or removed the pies from it.

Radebe testified that Mashele had opened the box before Mashabela arrived. Makro's own witnesses confirmed that Mashabela only became involved after the box had been taken out of the freezer.

The judge further noted that Mashabela was a general merchandise manager and was not responsible for the food section or its pricing.

The information about the markdown had come from Radebe, who was the assistant front-end manager and also bought six pies at the same till shortly after Mashabela.

Radebe testified that she did not know the price was wrong and did not consider the purchase dishonest.

The court also heard that individual sales of the same product at R7 had been taking place at the Alberton store since at least November 2022.

Makro's own witnesses differed on how the pricing problem had occurred. One described it as an error loaded by head office, while another said head office may have loaded the price incorrectly.

The judge said that if Makro's own witnesses could not agree on how the price had appeared on the system, it was difficult to conclude that an employee outside the food department would have appreciated that it was incorrect.

The court also considered that Mashabela had paid openly at a till, received an invoice and passed through security.

He had informed colleagues about the pies and reserved some for them.

"That some colleagues were more cautious, and checked the price, shows that they were more prudent than the applicant. It does not show that those who did not check were dishonest," the judgment stated.

However, the court acknowledged that Mashabela's conduct after the purchase had raised concerns.

Evidence showed that he was later informed that the pies had been incorrectly priced but did not approach management to resolve the matter.

He also declined to apologise or pay the difference when the issue was raised with him.

Judge Mhambi described his response as obstinate, saying a manager who learns that he has bought stock at an incorrect price would be expected to raise the matter himself.

However, the judge pointed out that Mashabela had not been charged with failing to disclose the pricing problem, return the pies or pay the difference.

His charge related specifically to dishonesty in purchasing the pies.

The judge said an employee was entitled to be judged on the charge he had been called upon to answer.

The court further noted that Makro management had never formally asked Mashabela to refund the pies or pay the difference.

The judge concluded that although Mashabela had failed to exercise the care expected of a manager and had responded poorly after learning about the pricing problem, this did not prove that he knowingly took advantage of the error when purchasing the pies.

"Makro bore the onus of proving dishonesty, and it did not discharge it," the judgment stated.

The court found that the CCMA commissioner had committed a gross irregularity by failing to properly assess the evidence relating to Mashabela individually.

In deciding against sending the matter back to the CCMA for another arbitration, Judge Mhambi said the Labour Court was in as good a position to determine the dispute because the full transcript of the four-day arbitration was available.

The judge also noted that Mashabela had been dismissed in July 2023 and that further proceedings would cause additional delays.

The court found no sufficient evidence that the employment relationship had broken down to an extent that would make reinstatement impracticable.

Makro was ordered to reinstate Mashabela with immediate effect into his former position or a substantially similar position, on terms and conditions no less favourable than those that applied before his dismissal.

He must report for duty within seven days of the November 12 order.

The court did not award back pay, as this had not been sought in the application, and made no order as to costs.

Original Source
https://iol.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2026-11-19-makro-manager-wins-labour-court-battle-after-dismissal-for-buying-pies-worth-r283-for-r7/
Visit IOL News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime