Jamie Sarkonak: Why Māori criminals get racial sentence discounts in Canada - National Post

Photo by Postmodern Studio - Adobe StockArticle contentIt’s official: Canada’s race-based sentencing regime applies to Māori New Zealanders — and it’s so powerful that it can shave what should be a seven-year sentence down to one, and protect offenders from being publicly identified.

We learned this from a B.C. meth-trafficking case that was published Friday. It arose from a bust that happened at the Vancouver International Airport back in February 2025, in which a Māori-Tongan woman was intercepted in her attempt to fly 20 kilograms of methamphetamine back to Auckland in her suitcase. In Canada, if sold by the kilo, it was worth between $80,000 and $90,000; in New Zealand, it was worth at least four times that.

The judge said six years was the “low end” for this type of crime. The Crown prosecutor sought an eight-year sentence.

Columnist Jesse Kline keeps you up to date with what’s happening in Israel and the effects of antisemitism on life here in Canada. Friday mornings.

A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder.

The next issue of Channel Israel will soon be in your inbox.

We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again

But in this case, the judge landed on two years. The smuggler’s personal background played a large role, which made sense — this judge, Diana Vandor, was once the chair of the B.C. Human Rights Commission. The sentence amounted to time served: the offender had already spent a year and a half in jail, and for that received credit of an additional half-year.

What was so compelling about her backstory? It was tragic, similar to many people who get drawn up into organized crime. The woman’s father was absent and her mother was a drug addict. She witnessed meth use from a young age and bounced between homes, living with her mother some years, and aunts other years.

She dropped out of school at 14 and had a baby at 17 with her boyfriend, a drug dealer. He was abusive, and he was also the person who sent the woman to Vancouver to pick up the shipment of meth that landed her in Canadian jail. For the duration of her imprisonment in Canada, she was separated from her infant child, who was three years old by the sentencing hearing.

These details came out in what is called an Impact of Race and Culture Assessment (IRCA) — a report assembled for court by a writer whose job is to interview non-white offenders, and others in the offender’s circle, to gather their personal history particularly in relation to racism. In the case of the Māori-Tongan smuggler, the report writers did indeed blame some of her plight on colonialism and racism.

“The IRCA report documents a childhood of profound deprivation, neglect, and cultural dislocation,” wrote Vandor. “Trauma compounded the neglect. Although her grandparents retained some understanding of Māori genealogy and heritage, she was not raised within the Māori worldview and does not speak the Māori language. She was considered an outsider by her maternal family and called by a racial slur because of her father’s Tongan heritage and left feeling, in her own words, ‘the odd one out.’ ”

Vandor also found it notable that the Māori comprise 20 per cent of the New Zealand population, but make up over 50 per cent of the country’s prisoners. Altogether, the judge found that the woman’s moral culpability was reduced to the point of deserving a “culturally grounded, rehabilitative disposition rather than a lengthy penitentiary term that would only deepen the dislocation of a young Māori mother far from her child and her community.”