Experts expect progress on early-childhood policies - Valor International
President Lula’s reelection is viewed by early-childhood development experts as positive for the continuity of a public policy established during the current federal administration, but it still faces obstacles to getting off the ground and achieving its intended impact on families with children from birth through age 6.
Although the initiatives are not expected to encounter substantial political resistance, civil-society representatives who helped design the Integrated National Early Childhood Policy (PNIPI) had concerns about defeated candidate Flávio Bolsonaro’s position on the issue. They now express optimism that progress will accelerate after two years spent overcoming government bureaucracy and data-management challenges.
“PNIPI is still stuck in the gerund—that phase of ‘we are doing, preparing, consolidating.’ But progress is occurring within an appropriate timeframe,” said Priscila Cruz, executive president of the NGO Todos Pela Educação. “Organizing the data was a genuinely complex challenge, and that component is now in place. The administration’s continuity therefore tends to prevent setbacks or a loss of focus.”
Cruz recalled that the decree formally creating PNIPI was issued in August 2025 and that the main challenge in its first year was developing Govinho, a platform integrated into Gov.br that links children’s data through their tax ID. Policymakers knew that integrating information from different areas and programs would be difficult, requiring leadership from the Ministry of Management and Innovation in Public Services, even though the newly created Undersecretariat for Early Childhood was placed within the Ministry of Education (MEC).
With the platform recently launched, public administrators are gaining greater capacity to identify, for example, children covered by the Bolsa Família income-transfer program who are not enrolled in daycare, children with overdue vaccinations, and children with disabilities who are not receiving adequate clinical care.
Cooperation among ministries is considered essential to PNIPI’s practical development. Cruz therefore believes that the possibility of former Education Minister Camilo Santana becoming chief of staff in the next administration could benefit the policy.
The second governance challenge facing PNIPI concerns relations with states and municipalities. Municipal governments implement policies that provide services directly to the population, such as daycare slots and primary healthcare. Although public calls have brought thousands of local administrators into leadership networks, PNIPI must still make progress toward an intergovernmental agreement similar to the arrangements used within the Unified Healthcare System (SUS).
“Governance is still heavily focused on dialogue among ministries. But intergovernmental governance—how states and municipalities are engaged in implementing the policy—is less mature,” said Marina Fragata, public-policy director at the Maria Cecilia Souto Vidigal Foundation.
According to Fragata, without a formal coordination mechanism connecting the federal government with state and municipal governments, PNIPI could remain confined to institutions in Brasília and not become part of municipal governments’ daily operations.
The federal government is focusing attention on this issue, according to Alexandro Santos, undersecretary for the Integrated National Early Childhood Policy. He emphasized that delivering the Govinho platform was the first step toward such an intergovernmental agreement. The MEC undersecretariat is now considering creating a system of paid fellowships for the network of local administrators to serve as PNIPI’s “hybrid implementation agents.” Under the proposal, approximately 7,000 professionals would follow federal guidelines while working within state and municipal structures to accelerate implementation.
Santos noted that another plan the undersecretariat intends to begin implementing in 2027 is to encourage the creation and strengthening of dedicated early-childhood administrative structures in states and the most populous municipalities.
To achieve these goals, the experts interviewed by Valor believe the Undersecretariat for Early Childhood will need a larger dedicated budget, whether it remains within the MEC or is transferred to the Chief of Staff’s Office. Santos acknowledged the need for a larger budget, given that the undersecretariat receives only R$10 million a year, exclusively for personnel and certain direct initiatives, such as management training courses and support for academic chairs connected to its work. He stressed, however, that because the policy cuts across several areas, the ministries involved will account for the largest shares of PNIPI funding.
In this context, Santos argues that the undersecretariat should gradually begin influencing each ministry’s sector-specific budgets so that it can calculate how much is being invested to promote children’s development during early childhood. He estimates that the federal budget for the policy is approximately R$120 billion a year.
That amount, however, would not represent new federal spending. The idea is to restructure established sector-specific policies when necessary and begin tracking their impact on early childhood. For that reason, economist Naercio Menezes Filho, a professor at Insper and researcher at the Brazilian Center for Applied Research in Early Childhood (CPAPI), believes future announcements of increased PNIPI funding should not alarm financial markets, despite pervasive fiscal concerns in Brazil’s economic debate. “PNIPI’s primary goal is to plan and coordinate the federal government’s early-childhood activities. Many of these policies aim to increase the effectiveness of existing programs and do not require a substantial increase in resources,” he explained.
Looking ahead to 2030, when Brazil’s next federal election will be held, experts believe PNIPI will be sufficiently consolidated and producing practical results, preventing renewed concerns that the national early-childhood policy will be discontinued. One factor reinforcing that expectation is the prospect of approval for Bill 1924 of 2025, which has already passed the Chamber of Deputies (Brazil’s Lower House) and is now before the Senate. The bill amends the Legal Framework on Early Childhood—a 2016 law covering children from birth through age 6—to enshrine PNIPI in law.
Fragata expects these coordination efforts and the development of foundational systems—including establishing PNIPI in law and organizing all its data—to reach families with children up to age 6 by then.


