EU forever chemicals ‘ban’ should include sweeping exemptions, watchdog says

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from POLITICO Europe (politico.eu). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
BRUSSELS — The European Union's chemical safety watchdog is proposing a long list of temporary exemptions to an upcoming EU-wide ban on PFAS chemicals, in a bid to protect key manufacturing sectors, according to a draft document obtained by POLITICO.

BRUSSELS — The European Union's chemical safety watchdog is proposing a long list of temporary exemptions to an upcoming EU-wide ban on PFAS chemicals, in a bid to protect key manufacturing sectors, according to a draft document obtained by POLITICO.

Products including cars, clothing, electrical devices, medical implants and personal protective equipment could continue using the dangerous chemicals for up to 13.5 years under the European Chemicals Agency's proposed carve-outs.

If the European Commission accepts the agency's advice, it would mean PFAS — which have been linked to health problems including cancer and reduced fertility — would remain in use in Europe for well over a decade.

The advice follows intense lobbying from many European industries which fear an immediate outright ban would leave them with no alternative ways to manufacture their products. PFAS chemicals are robust and highly resistant to water, heat, grease and corrosion, and have become indispensable to a wide range of sectors.

ECHA's advice, due to be delivered to the European Commission shortly, will give the EU executive official grounds to write multiple exemptions for up to 13.5 years into its promised PFAS ban. The Commission has already said it wants to exempt PFAS use in some "critical" sectors.

The proposal comes at an awkward time, coinciding with fresh warnings that the EU is failing to adequately regulate PFAS use.

In a report published Wednesday, the European Court of Auditors argues that "the procedures to regulate PFAS in the EU were complex and lengthy, and not well-adapted to dealing with this issue," and that the EU's rules have "not led to sufficient information being collected to assess the hazards related to most PFAS."

The auditors warned that existing EU restrictions on PFAS had often been more relaxed than ECHA had advised, allowing for more exemptions and longer transition periods.

ECHA's opinion, due to be finalized pending any last-minute changes, supports temporary exemptions lasting 18 months to 13.5 years. Solar panels, for instance, could continue to contain PFAS for 6.5 years, while cars and semiconductors could use them for 13.5 years.

ECHA also maintained its opposition to full exemptions for PFAS used as active substances in pesticides, biocides and human and veterinary medicines, saying they have not been justified.

For eight sectors, including military applications, industrial machinery and certain medical uses, ECHA did not carry out detailed evaluations. It recommends allowing those uses to continue temporarily until further assessment can establish whether exemptions are justified.

ECHA said it could not reach a firm position on many PFAS uses, reflecting wider criticism that the EU's chemical safety framework, known as REACH, is not fit to regulate more than 10,000 different PFAS chemicals in use.

A Commission spokesperson said that REACH had been "effective" in regulating microplastics, tattoo inks and PFAS in firefighting foams.

"While recognizing the urgent need to address PFAS pollution, a rigorous assessment of all PFAS uses is essential to ensure a high-quality process and reliable outcome. The complexity of this task requires a measured pace," said the spokesperson.

Member countries such as France and Denmark have already taken action to ban PFAS at the national level in certain products. Additionally, the bloc is on track to pay at least €440 billion to address the pollution and health impacts of toxic PFAS chemicals by mid-century, according to a study the Commission released earlier this year.

Original Source
https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-forever-chemicals-pfas-ban-sweeping-exemptions/
Visit POLITICO Europe ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Health