Enel resists sale as Brazil weighs forfeiture of power concession - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The Brazilian Electricity Regulatory Agency’s (Aneel) decision to postpone its ruling on whether to recommend forfeiture of Enel São Paulo’s concession was seen by analysts as an attempt to facilitate a transfer of the utility’s operations to another company, rather than have the...

The Brazilian Electricity Regulatory Agency’s (Aneel) decision to postpone its ruling on whether to recommend forfeiture of Enel São Paulo’s concession was seen by analysts as an attempt to facilitate a transfer of the utility’s operations to another company, rather than have the concession forfeited. The Italian group, however, is reluctant to sell an asset considered one of the country’s most profitable electricity distribution businesses, which has attracted interest from several potential buyers.

On Tuesday (17), Aneel suspended its review of the concession case after the agency’s director-general, Sandoval Feitosa, requested more time to study the matter. The other four board members had already voted in favor of recommending that the concession be terminated, giving the proposal a majority. On Wednesday (18), Feitosa told reporters that he had requested more time after the company approached him directly and presented new arguments, which still need to be reviewed. Enel had already been allowed to submit its final arguments at earlier stages of the proceedings.

Companies began exploring a possible purchase of Enel São Paulo around the middle of this year, as the regulatory proceedings at Aneel advanced. Sources said discussions have since cooled, partly because of the Italian group’s resistance. There is now an expectation that potential buyers will take another look at the asset.

Companies identified as potential buyers include China’s State Grid, which owns CPFL and already operates electricity distributors in São Paulo; Equatorial; Spain’s Iberdrola, owner of Neoenergia, which engaged in a fierce battle with Enel in 2018 to acquire what was then AES Eletropaulo; J&F; and Energisa. Copel had also been assessing the asset, but sources say the company has little appetite for the deal.

In a statement, CPFL said it monitors “potential growth opportunities” and that “if the asset is formally made available for sale in the private market, CPFL will assess the opportunity based on its strategic fit.”

Equatorial said it is “always attentive to opportunities in the markets where it operates.” Neoenergia and Energisa said they do not comment on market rumors. J&F declined to comment. Copel CEO Daniel Slaviero said that “if this does happen [the sale], we will be attentive and assess and study the opportunity, but always with great discipline.”

Asked about the matter, Enel said that “Aneel has not made a decision on the concession termination proceedings” and that the postponement “provides another opportunity for the data and arguments presented by the company to be technically assessed.” The company said it “is fully complying with the obligations under its concession agreement and the recovery plan submitted to the agency.”

In the view of one industry analyst, Aneel wants to recommend forfeiture of the concession but needs to find a solution for the São Paulo operation and avoid a disruption in service. The source expects strong pressure on Enel to sell. Other experts, however, say the company’s resistance will be a major obstacle, including in negotiations over the price. Enel has made substantial investments in the operation and will certainly seek compensation for them, one expert noted.

Selling the concession would be a less complex and less disruptive solution than terminating the contract, which would entail a difficult transition, said Fernando Vernalha, a partner at Vernalha Pereira Advogados. “The transfer of control would have to be combined with an extension of the contract, which expires in 2028, as well as an update of the concession terms. Much of the current controversy stems from a poorly designed risk allocation framework. The contract needs to be updated.”

Gesner Oliveira, a professor at Fundação Getulio Vargas (FGV) and a partner at GO Associados, also sees a transfer of control as a solution to the problems at Enel, which has lost its “social license” to operate.

He also cautioned, however, that a sale alone would not resolve all the issues. “It is an old, fragile contract. It is important to review it, introduce an updated set of performance indicators, establish faster dispute-resolution mechanisms, strengthen oversight, and put in place an action plan with the municipalities served—for example, to manage tree pruning,” he said.

Analysts also consider legal action between Enel and Aneel virtually inevitable, both over the forfeiture recommendation and over the compensation the company would be entitled to receive for investments made but not yet repaid. “The main issue whenever a concession comes to an end is always compensation. There will be a dispute,” Vernalha said.

It remains unclear when Aneel’s deliberations will resume. Feitosa pointed to the 60-day deadline for resuming the vote and said the case could return to the agenda at any time during that period, possibly even later this year. “It is up to 60 days. It could be on the 60th day or earlier. It could even be next week.”

Under Aneel’s rules, a request for more time to study a case suspends deliberations for up to 60 calendar days. The countdown, however, is paused between the board’s last regular public meeting of the year, scheduled for December 8, and its first meeting in 2027. Since next year’s meeting schedule has not yet been set, it is not possible to determine the final deadline for resuming the vote. Aneel’s rules also prohibit any other board member from requesting additional time to review the case.

Feitosa’s request to postpone the vote contrasts with his previous position in February, when, even though the merits of the case were not yet under review, he proposed that the board approve a recommendation to terminate Enel São Paulo’s concession and argued that the agency should objectively assess the possibility of intervening in the utility’s operations.

Asked whether he still holds that view, Feitosa said his earlier position was based on the information available at the time and that he needs to assess the new evidence before deciding whether to maintain it. “If I told you that I wouldn’t change anything, then I wouldn’t be a regulator. I wouldn’t be listening to the company, the government, or any institution that brings forward information considered relevant.”

If the forfeiture recommendation is approved, the final decision on terminating the contract will rest with the Ministry of Mines and Energy, after Aneel concludes the proceedings, including the review of any appeals.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/business/news/2026/11/19/enel-resists-sale-as-brazil-weighs-forfeiture-of-power-concession.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Business