Don’t be so quick to judge Laura Brand - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Laura Brand’s public defence of her disgraced husband raises uncomfortable questions about how far a devoted wife will go Credit: Paul Edwards Rowan Pelling Show biography Rowan Pelling writes expertly on culture, sex, and social mores.. She edited The Erotic Review, founded The ...

Laura Brand’s public defence of her disgraced husband raises uncomfortable questions about how far a devoted wife will go Credit: Paul Edwards Rowan Pelling Show biography Rowan Pelling writes expertly on culture, sex, and social mores.. She edited The Erotic Review, founded The Amorist, and was also a Man Booker Prize judge.

I didn’t want to watch Laura Brand read out her husband’s denial of guilt from prison, with its none-too-subtle undertone of Messianic suffering, which stopped millimetres short of declaring: “They know not what they do.” But, like stopping to gawp at a burning house, it was almost impossible to look away.

The stricken wife’s hair was scraped back and her face wan, while she sported the kind of multi-coloured jumper children’s TV presenters wore in the 1980s, as she dutifully pronounced her spouse’s defiant words: “As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for, so something strange is happening.”

The disgraced comedian was right about one thing – something very strange is happening. Laura appears to be in a surrendered wife scenario so entrenched that it verges on a hostage situation. Why else would she read aloud a statement that could only heap further pain on her husband’s victims and encourage online trolls to rain down hate on them?

Laura appears to be in a surrendered wife scenario so entrenched that it verges on a hostage situation Credit: Pixel8000 The wider question it raises is even more uncomfortable for most women. How would we behave if our own husbands, partners, or sons were convicted of sexual offences and continued to deny any guilt? It’s a question that’s been troubling me for a while now, as someone I know (not well, via professional circles) may find herself in that situation. Her partner stands accused of sexual crimes, and the case seems almost certain to come to court. She is standing staunchly by her man, while those who have worked with him in the past mutter: “He has form.”

It’s all too easy to dismiss such loyalty as gullible idiocy, but – truly – what would any of us do when a man we love, top-to-toe, is beseeching our belief in his innocence? I’ve seen friends of mine who are also mothers defend their sons to the outraged hilt in school-related situations where they’ve been accused by girls of inappropriate conduct. It’s all too easy to protest that your son or husband would never behave with impropriety, and that an over-sensitive or uppity female is overreacting. The grey zone of human sexual interaction means the truth often lies somewhere in the middle. But what if it doesn’t?

The National Theatre’s hugely successful play, Inter Alia, interrogated exactly this subject, with Rosamund Pike playing a barrister whose world implodes when her 18-year-old son stands accused of sexual assault. Sell-out runs at the National Theatre and in the West End, along with filmed cinema screenings, suggest this is a topic that triggers the fears of many bien pensant parents.

On both sides of the Atlantic, we read of men raised by engaged parents, who enjoyed privileged educations and good upbringings, and still become sex offenders. Take Tal, Oren and Alon Alexander, the wealthy US real estate investors who have just been convicted of sex trafficking and related offences by the Manhattan Federal Court. Their wives and mother attended the court regularly, but were notably absent for the men’s sentencing.

The very act of marrying someone is a declaration of loyalty and support through all hardships, “‘til death us do part”. Admitting that a man who shares your bed and hearth could have behaved criminally towards another woman is almost impossible to assimilate, especially if he has changed his ways for you and become a devoted husband and father. I can see why it’s easier and self-soothing to go along with the “women threw themselves at him” narrative, which is often true, but doesn’t mean power wasn’t grossly abused. Far harder if your husband is older, charismatic, manipulative and fast-witted, with the cloak of born-again Christianity if all else fails.

Russell Brand wears the cloak of born-again Christianity to cast himself as a misunderstood martyr Credit: Reuters/Olivia Harris Furthermore, Laura is encircled by her husband’s self-mustered community of Brand believers, who perversely insist on thinking their guru is being punished for his contrarian dogma on geopolitics, rather than for rape. It’s all too easy to see how Laura has become some kind of Mary Magdalene figure in this scenario – the one person from his mainstream celebrity days who has offered steadfast (some would say blind) support, as former friends deny ever being close.

So, I can’t help fearing for the woman I mentioned earlier from my outer circle of acquaintances, who appears to be treading an eerily similar path to Laura. She is standing by her man, despite years of whispers and some more substantial reports noting his inappropriate behaviour towards women.

I have my own small experience of it, which I stored away as “very creepy”. We met in a London members’ club in the early 2000s, ostensibly to discuss professional matters, but within five minutes of sitting down, he leant forward and undid the top two buttons of my blouse while saying: “Do you want to play?” No, nope, never, not even for the last seat on the Titanic’s lifeboats. This does not, of course, make him a rapist (it wasn’t even that unusual for media men back then, while the fact that I edited an erotic magazine made me an easy target), and he is owed a scrupulously fair trial. I even hope, for his other half’s sanity and happiness, he is acquitted.

But what if he isn’t? What does the once loving, trusting wife or partner do then? Only the lucky few can, like “terribly naïve” (her own words) Georgina Chapman, the ex-wife of Harvey Weinstein, disappear from sight and then bob up, still part of the A-list, as the partner of Adrien Brody.

I can see why, for some, it’s almost easier to continue with the narrative that your beloved has been framed. The alternative is almost too grim to contemplate – that the person you love most in the world has lied and manipulated you into being part of a blameless, domestic set-up aimed at whitewashing past crimes.

You would have to accept that every part of your loving closeness has in some way been built on the hurt and humiliation of others. To question if your soulmate really loves you at all, or whether you are just his emergency escape route. It gives me a long, dark night of the soul even imagining all this. Heaven help those women who have to live this particular nightmare.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/19/rowan-pelling-russell-brand-laura-wife/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Entertainment