“Convening a Cabinet meeting is a legitimate duty” vs “Granting legitimacy to a loyalist coup”···Inside the en banc ruling on Han Duck-soo - 경향신문

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Kyunghyang Shinmun (khan.co.kr). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
“Convening a Cabinet meeting is a legitimate duty” vs “Granting legitimacy to a loyalist coup”···Inside the en banc ruling on Han Duck-soo  경향신문

This article was translated by an AI tool. Feedback Here.

On the 19th, at the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, a sentencing session of the en banc panel is being held to deliver rulings in cases including alleged violations of the Act on the Capital Market and Financial Investment Business related to First Lady Kim Keon-hee, and charges including aiding the ringleader of insurrection related to former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo. Joint Press Corps

Behind the Supreme Court en banc decision to reverse and remand in part, with an acquittal indication, the case against former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo for engaging in important duties of insurrection was the determination that, at the time of the 12.3 emergency-martial-law proclamation, the ‘proposal to convene a Cabinet meeting’ by Han did not have the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order. Nine justices viewed the proposal by Han as the performance of a legitimate duty and deemed him not guilty on this point. In contrast, three justices dissented, arguing that the proposal for a Cabinet meeting should be regarded as an act intended to confer procedural legitimacy on the emergency martial law.

The Supreme Court en banc panel (presiding justice Oh Kyung-mi) on the 19th heard the appeal in the case of former Prime Minister Han, who had been sentenced to 15 years in prison on charges including engaging in important duties of insurrection, and reversed and remanded the lower judgment in part with an acquittal indication.

The individual acts constituting Han's insurrection charges are threefold: ▲ before the proclamation of martial law, the act of proposing Cabinet deliberation; ▲ after the proclamation, the act of trying to obtain countersignatures from Cabinet members to confer procedural legitimacy; ▲ the act of discussing how to carry out orders to blockade key institutions such as the National Assembly and to cut power and water to media outlets such as the Kyunghyang Shinmun.

The en banc Supreme Court first added the legal principle that, for the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order to be recognized for the crime of insurrection, “it is not enough merely to be aware, even at a minimal level, of the possibility; there must be an intention that aims at realization and is prepared to accept the result.” This sets the scope of punishment for insurrection more strictly.

At the same time, the nine justices in the majority held that, to judge engagement in important duties of insurrection, it is necessary to examine for each individual act whether there was a ‘purpose of disrupting the constitutional order’. Accordingly, they determined that the countersignature act and the discussions on power and water cutoffs matched participation in the insurrection. However, as to the proposal for Cabinet deliberation, they concluded with an acquittal indication, stating, “based solely on the special counsel's indictment, the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order has not been proven.”

The majority stated, “A prime minister proposing to the president that the Cabinet deliberate is a legitimate official act that requests compliance with constitutional and martial-law procedures,” and “it is difficult to conclude that the defendant (Han Duck-soo) proposed Cabinet deliberation merely to meet a quorum as a formality for the purpose of contributing to an insurrection.” They added that it is difficult to find that, at the time, Han knew specific execution plans such as the deployment of troops or the blockade of the National Assembly and the National Election Commission, and that there is also the fact that he urged former President Yoon to refrain from declaring martial law.

The Court stated, “the mere recognition of the unconstitutionality or illegality of martial law does not by itself show an intention to pursue realization and to accept the outcome,” adding, “an overly ready recognition would provide a wrong behavioral guideline that, to avoid liability for insurrection in the future, one should refrain from proposing Cabinet deliberation.” It also pointed out that, once the quorum for Cabinet deliberation was met, former President Yoon immediately distributed the proclamation of martial law before the remainder had arrived, unilaterally notified the members, and then declared emergency martial law. The implication was that whether the Cabinet deliberated could not have prevented the emergency martial law.

By contrast, three justices, Oh Kyung-mi·Shin Sook-hee·Kim Sung-soo, issued a dissent, saying this part also should be found guilty. They characterized the 12·3 martial law as “a loyalist coup in which the incumbent ruler uses state power to neutralize constitutional controls over himself.” They further argued that “in a loyalist coup by a president, acts that destroy constitutional governance appear under the guise of normal and official constitutional acts,” and that the mere fact of following legal procedures cannot, by itself, distinguish legitimate performance of duty from participation in insurrection.

Justice Oh and others found that, before the proclamation of martial law, Han had been provided with the proclamation and related orders and was fully aware of their unconstitutionality and illegality. Justice Oh stated, “in a desperate situation where unconstitutional martial law was sweeping in, the defendant, despite foreseeing the inevitable risk, pressed ahead with a Cabinet meeting that would be reduced to a mere tool,” adding, “he focused only on making up the quorum for the meeting and took no action to stop the proclamation of martial law.”

They also criticized the majority for treating the conduct before the proclamation as acquittal-leaning and the conduct after the proclamation as guilty-leaning. They argued it is unacceptable to distinguish the presence or absence of a purpose to disrupt the constitutional order based on the timing of the proclamation, when the three acts shared the same objective and were carried out in a continuous sequence of time and place.

The en banc panel also affirmed guilty verdicts on other counts: after the lifting of martial law, Han signed an ex post proclamation intended to cure legal defects in the initial proclamation and then discarded it, and in the Constitutional Court proceedings on the impeachment of former President Yoon he committed perjury to the effect that he “had not recognized the proclamation of martial law.” He was acquitted on the count of exercising the ex post proclamation (use of a falsely prepared official document).

Han had his sentence reduced from 23 years at first instance to 15 years on appeal on charges including engaging in important duties of insurrection. With the Supreme Court partially reversing and remanding with an acquittal indication, the sentence may be reduced further in the remand proceedings.

The en banc decision is likely to affect the cases of other Cabinet members charged with engaging in important duties of insurrection. The case of former Minister of the Interior and Safety Lee Sang-min, which was referred to the en banc panel together with Han, is also awaiting an en banc ruling. He was sentenced to seven years at first instance and nine years on appeal on charges that, after receiving from former President Yoon orders to cut power and water to media outlets, he directed the then National Fire Agency Commissioner to cooperate with police requests. Both the first and second instances found that these orders constituted engagement in important duties of insurrection carried out with the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order.

Former Minister of Justice Park Sung-jae is also awaiting a decision on appeal. Park received a 25-year sentence at first instance on charges that, after the proclamation of martial law, he ordered attendance by staff in charge of exit bans, inspections of capacity at correctional facilities, and a review of dispatching prosecutors to the Martial Law Command Joint Investigation Headquarters. However, the appellate court reduced the sentence to nine years, finding that some instructions related to the dispatch of prosecutors were not proven or remained at the level of a general review. The directions to have exit-ban personnel on standby and to examine capacity at correctional facilities were recognized as engagement in important duties of insurrection.

Original Source
https://www.khan.co.kr/en/article/202611192313037/?utm_source\u003dkhan_rss\u0026utm_medium\u003drss\u0026utm_campaign\u003denglish_news
Visit Kyunghyang Shinmun ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Crime