‘Comelec can set new BSKE date without new law’

MANILA, Philippines — Election lawyer Romulo Macalintal has disputed Commission on Elections (Comelec) Chairman George Garcia’s position that Congress must pass a new law to set the date of the barangay and Sangguniang Kabataan Elections (BSKE) if the Supreme Court reverses its ruling upholding the postponement of the polls to 2028.

In a statement, Macalintal said the poll body could independently schedule the elections under Sections 5 and 6 of the Omnibus Election Code, which provide for the conduct of postponed or failed elections within 30 days after the cause of postponement ceases to exist.

He argued that a reversal of the high court’s ruling would remove the legal impediment to holding the elections, allowing Comelec to set a new date without waiting for congressional action.

“Thus, if the Supreme Court reverses its decision and allows the postponed election to proceed, Comelec will have 30 days from the date of that final ruling to set the poll. This is so because on that date, the impediment or cause of postponement ceases to exist legally,” Macalintal said.

Garcia, however, maintained that the Comelec’s authority to postpone elections applies only before the scheduled election day.

“If the scheduled date for the actual conduct of the elections has not yet passed, that is why it is called a postponement. How can you postpone an activity if its scheduled date has already passed? That is the authority of Comelec,” Garcia told The STAR.

Garcia also cited the Bangsamoro region, where Congress set the date of the elections following their postponement.

Macalintal, however, argued that requiring Congress to set another election date following a Supreme Court reversal would undermine the effect of a judicial ruling invalidating the postponement.

“This grants the legislature unchecked power over election scheduling. For instance, if a postponement law is enacted just days before the scheduled polls, leaving virtually no time to question its constitutionality, the public is left without recourse. Subjecting a court-ordered election back to congressional approval would ensure that no such election ever proceeds,” he said.

The election lawyer also cited the Supreme Court’s 2025 ruling in Hagerdon v. House of Representatives, which he said recognized Comelec’s authority to conduct special elections without waiting for a House resolution.

According to Macalintal, the high court affirmed Comelec’s duty to conduct a special election within 60 days of a legislative vacancy.

He said that the same principle should apply to the BSKE, with the poll body able to schedule the elections without congressional intervention if the court reverses its earlier ruling.

The dispute stems from Republic Act 12326, which moved the BSKE from November 2026 to November 2028.

abtestabtest OCTA Research rejects bias claims over Leni-Sara surveys, cites Duterte's lead 7 hours ago OCTA Research has rejected claims that its hypothetical 2028 election surveys were rigged to favor Naga City Mayor Leni ... Headlines Sara Duterte's GenCorp declaration may be 'Freudian slip,' says lawyer By Alyana Uy | 12 hours ago If the vice president wasn't a GenCorp stockholder, why did she receive P2.14 million? Headlines Donald Trump's late arrival won't delay ASEAN summit closing — spox By Cristina Chi | 14 hours ago United States President Donald Trump's late arrival to the 49th ASEAN summit next week will not push back its closing,... Headlines Makati court issues extradition warrant on Quiboloy, co-accused in U.S. charges By Ian Laqui | 12 hours ago Makati court finds probable cause, also issues hold departure orders against 3. Headlines Sara Duterte's defense drops all 16 bank witnesses in trial By Kristine Daguno-Bersamina | 14 hours ago All 16 bank officials initially lined up as Sara Duterte defense witnesses are now off the list. Headlines Latest More in Headlines President Marcos to hold bilateral meet with UN chief, world leaders COA chair named SC justice Meralco rates rise in November Corruption crackdown, digitalization among new BIR chief’s top agenda abtest Trump’s late arrival won’t delay Asean closing ceremony By Rudy Santos | 40 minutes ago The closing ceremony of the 49th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Summit on Nov. 17 will proceed as scheduled despite the late arrival of United States President Donald Trump, the Department of Foreign... Headlines President Marcos to new Navy chief: Boost territorial defense By Helen Flores | 40 minutes ago President Marcos ordered yesterday newly appointed Navy chief Vice Admiral Alan Javier to boost territorial defense and deepen... Headlines Swift passage of national cyber law urged By Louella Desiderio | 40 minutes ago Amid rising cybersecurity attacks, the Cybersecurity Council of the Philippines (CSCP) yesterday pushed for the swift passage of a national cybersecurity law and urged both the government and private sector to review... Headlines Private sector opens immersion slots for senior high school By Bella Cariaso | 40 minutes ago More than 61,000 work immersion slots were pledged by the private sector to boost the employability of senior high school... Headlines WATCH: Brazil's Lula lands in Manila for talks with Marcos, ASEAN Summit 7 hours ago The visit is expected to further strengthen ties between the Philippines and Brazil, including cooperation on issues of mutual... Headlines Recommended VP Sara may dollar accounts - prosecution 1 day ago Ibinunyag ng House prosecution nitong Huwebes ang pagkakatuklas sa mga dollar account na pag-aari umano ni Vice President... HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE Impeachment itutuloy tapos ng ASEAN November 13, 2026 - 12:00am Pansamantalang ititigil ang impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte habang isinasagawa ang Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit. HeadlinesASEAN Escudero sa senator-judges: ‘Huwag pagbantaan, insultuhin mga testigo’ November 13, 2026 - 12:00am Pinaalalahanan ni Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero ang mga kapwa senator-judge na pairalin ang pagpipigil sa sarili at iwasang pagbantaan o insultuhin ang mga testigo...r HeadlinesCHIZ ESCUDERO BBM huwag sana tuyain maghimagsik ang madla November 13, 2026 - 12:00am Umayon sana si President Bongbong Marcos sa pasya ng Korte Suprema nu’ng Oct. 7. Aayos ang takbo ng bansa. HeadlinesFERDINAND MARCOS JR. PANOORIN: Chiz, pinaalalahanan ang mga senador: Ingat sa pag-contempt! 1 day ago Chiz Escudero, pinaalalahanan ang mga senador na huwag basta gumamit ng contempt laban sa mga testigo at pairalin ang pasensiya... HeadlinesIMPEACHMENT TRIALSARA DUTERTE next Recommended VP Sara may dollar accounts - prosecution Ibinunyag ng House prosecution nitong Huwebes ang pagkakatuklas sa mga dollar account na pag-aari umano ni Vice President Sara Duterte matapos magdesisyon ang kanyang kampo na hindi na iharap ang isang opisyal ng Bank of the Philippine Islands na maaari sanang tanungin tungkol sa mga naturang account. 1 day ago SARA DUTERTE Impeachment itutuloy tapos ng ASEAN Pansamantalang ititigil ang impeachment trial ni Vice President Sara Duterte habang isinasagawa ang Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit. 1 day ago ASEAN Escudero sa senator-judges: ‘Huwag pagbantaan, insultuhin mga testigo’ Pinaalalahanan ni Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero ang mga kapwa senator-judge na pairalin ang pagpipigil sa sarili at iwasang pagbantaan o insultuhin ang mga testigo sa impeachment trial. 1 day ago CHIZ ESCUDERO BBM huwag sana tuyain maghimagsik ang madla Umayon sana si President Bongbong Marcos sa pasya ng Korte Suprema nu’ng Oct. 7. Aayos ang takbo ng bansa. 1 day ago FERDINAND MARCOS JR. PANOORIN: Chiz, pinaalalahanan ang mga senador: Ingat sa pag-contempt! Chiz Escudero, pinaalalahanan ang mga senador na huwag basta gumamit ng contempt laban sa mga testigo at pairalin ang pasensiya at paggalang sa impeachment trial. 1 day ago IMPEACHMENT TRIAL SARA DUTERTE OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!