Calls for Huang’s return show the absurdity of the AI circus - The Telegraph
Jensen Huang apparently thinks it would be appropriate to ask Nvidia for his job back Credit: Getty Images/Sean Gallup Ben Marlow Associate Editor Show biography Ben Marlow is an Associate Editor and Columnist at The Telegraph. He writes on all aspects of business and was previously Chief City Commentator, having joined from The Sunday Times.
As the Nvidia scandal continues to shake the corporate world, a recap may be in order, particularly for all those who appear to have taken leave of their senses over these extraordinary events.
Jensen Huang, the company’s founder, chief executive, and all-round AI overlord, was alleged to have had not one but three extramarital affairs.
That two of these women were subordinates would be grounds for immediate sacking at most companies. Of course. But it is the other relationship that set off alarm bells so loud they could be heard from Washington to Beijing.
Firstly, the woman in question – Alice Huang (no relation) – was the senior boss and controlling shareholder of Megaspeed, a Singaporean cloud-computing firm that has purchased billions of dollars’ worth of Nvidia chips.
So the lines were already sufficiently blurred for Mr Huang’s conduct to be a matter of the gravest concern.
But secondly, and most importantly, American officials believe Ms Huang is a Chinese spy.
What’s more, American intelligence fears that Megaspeed is supporting the Chinese Communist Party by allowing it to circumvent US export controls and smuggle technology foundational to the AI revolution into China.
Jensen Huang’s relationship with the suspected Chinese spy Alice Huang led to his resignation as Nvidia chief executive Credit: PN/Newscom/Avalon Yet just days after these extraordinary circumstances emerged, and with all the self-awareness of Emperor Nero, Mr Huang is reportedly already eyeing a return to Nvidia.
Yes, you read that right. A man suspected of threatening US national security while leading what is arguably the most strategically important company in the West, apparently thinks it would be appropriate to ask for his job back.
What’s more, the great and good of Silicon Valley have been remarkably quick to throw their weight behind this absurd notion.
The AI boom is awash with red flags but a coordinated campaign for the return of a man who may have put American national interests at risk shows it has become one giant circus.
It is hard to imagine anything like this happening outside the Silicon Valley bubble. The argument for throwing the rule book out of the window and making an exception for Mr Huang is straightforward enough but that doesn’t mean it’s remotely credible.
The 63-year-old, we are supposed to believe, is such a genius that he is irreplaceable, and what’s more, Nvidia will fall apart, taking the entire industry with it, if he isn’t quickly reinstalled at the helm.
Really? Are we mere mortals seriously supposed to believe that the future of the entire global economy now rests upon a man with a leather jacket and loose trousers?
Even by the standards of an American tech industry that has long been detached from reality this is silly in the extreme.
Mr Huang may have achieved godlike status, but it surely says more about the tendency of the California echo-chamber to over-eulogise than whether his qualities are unique or not.
It may take time for Nvidia to recover, and there will no doubt be some bumps in the road along the way, but like every corporate executive he is replaceable and Nvidia isn’t going to suddenly unravel because he’s not there.
It is worth remembering that the company is responsible for an estimated 80pc to 90pc of the global market for AI accelerator and processor chips.
There is no doubt that Mr Huang has been instrumental in the company achieving this astonishing level of dominance. The question everyone, including Nvidia shareholders, is now asking is whether this can be maintained with him gone.
Tech figures such as Elon Musk insist that many of Nvidia’s biggest contracts rest on personal “handshakes” with its unfaithful boss rather than formal written agreements, the implication being that many of its customers will jump ship in his absence.
I have serious doubts about this argument. Surely Nvidia is now at the stage where the quality of its chips is such that they practically sell themselves?
If not, and I suspect it is a significant if, then is it over-simplifying the situation to think that there are other people capable of banging the drum around the world on its behalf?
In August, Colette Kress, Nvidia finance chief, who the company’s board appointed as Mr Huang’s interim successor, said annual turnover was on course to surge by $287bn (£218bn) or 70pc at a company where gross profit margins are of a similar magnitude.
Meanwhile, it continues to behave like an out-of-control money machine generating $261bn of expected free cash flow in 2027, after spitting out $100bn in the last financial year.
And as Janus Henderson, the asset management giant, has pointed out, Microsoft, Google, Apple and Amazon have all gone through similar change at the top over the years, losing leaders with cult-like status, and every one of them has gone on to become more successful than ever.
Yet Silicon Valley continues with this myth that the sky will fall in if it is deprived of some of its most high-profile figures.
Before Mr Huang, it was Sam Altman that humanity couldn’t possibly continue without when he was fired from OpenAI in 2023 for allegedly lying to the board. Yet a mere five days later, Altman was back following heavy pressure from investors and a revolt among much of the OpenAI workforce.
The willingness of so many to overlook serious concerns about corporate governance, whether at Nvidia, OpenAI or many of the other tech giants almost certainly says more about what those individuals stand to lose than wider society.
A report in the Wall Street Journal gets to the heart of what is really happening at Nvidia. Essentially, a tech industry where valuations have reached stratospheric new heights on the back of an AI boom powered by the company’s advanced chips, is absolutely terrified that the music is about to stop without Mr Huang to act as the all-encompassing conductor and choirmaster.
Under his freewheeling leadership, Nvidia has been spending its ballooning cash pile like a drunken sailor, providing tens of billions of dollars in capital, equity investments, credit lines and payment guarantees to AI start-ups, cloud providers and AI labs – who in turn use that same financial backing to purchase Nvidia chips and services.
If one figure epitomises the incestuous nature of the AI boom, it’s the $530bn of circular finance deals and similar commitments that Nvidia is expected to announce for the most recent financial quarter.
Mr Huang had indicated in recent weeks that Nvidia was preparing to scale back its role as the industry’s primary source of financing. But given Kress’s reported attempts to rein in Mr Huang, it is fair to assume the pull-back will be turbocharged in her hands.
That’s the real reason why so many senior figures are desperate for him to return: self-interest and self-preservation. Everything else is just noise.

/file/attachments/3000/CoalitionCafeCOL2000px-2_835186.jpg)
/file/attachments/3000/14091243_361210.jpg)