Brazil ‘special sits’ market stalls amid new court claim restrictions - Valor International
Restrictions on the purchase of court-related claims by credit-receivable funds (FIDCs) announced by the government in late September have virtually brought this market to a standstill. Lawyers and fund managers interviewed by Valor say most investors in the special situations segment have suspended all ongoing negotiations. Legal consultations have also begun on alternative structures to hold these assets, such as private equity funds, which are not subject to the new restrictions.
“In practice, the resolution barred FIDCs from investing in claims subject to legal disputes and severely restricted the market,” said João Sartini, a partner at law firm Felsberg Advogados. “The trend is for the number of buyers to decline and haircuts to widen. On the other hand, eligible assets will attract concentrated demand, meaning the same pool of assets will be sought by a much larger number of players.”
Digimais receives R$1.7bn capital injection from controlling shareholderFinancial system will emerge stronger from Master case, Renato Gomes saysRegulators move to curb conflicts of interest in bank product salesCredit fintechs eye receivables funds to finance growth
Court-related claims were among the main assets used in the Banco Master scheme. A large share consisted of so-called pré-precatórios—claims against the government that have been recognized by the courts but for which a formal payment order has not yet been issued. Estimates indicate that the bank invested between R$14.3 billion and R$16 billion in the purchase of court-ordered payment claims and pré-precatórios at steep haircuts, paying between 10% and 20% of their face value. On the funds’ balance sheets, however, the assets were recorded at their full face value.
Resolution CMN 5,343, adopted by the National Monetary Council (CMN) on September 24 this year, took effect on October 13. It prohibits funds from making new investments, directly or indirectly, in claims or expected claims arising from judicial or arbitration proceedings until the underlying credit is definitively liquid, certain, and enforceable.
Funds that already hold court-related claims in their portfolios will be required, starting January 4, 2027, to adopt a verifiable valuation methodology, reassess assets whenever relevant procedural developments occur, subject their procedures to independent audits, and periodically disclose information about the claims and related transactions.
According to data compiled by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Brazil (CVM), as of July 2026, more than 400 FIDCs held R$35.2 billion in claims related to court cases. The special situations market has grown significantly in Brazil: there are now 57 asset managers dedicated to the strategy in the country, compared with just five in 2015.
Vitor Boari, chairman of the Special Committee on Matters Related to Court-Ordered Payments at the São Paulo chapter of the Brazilian Bar Association (OAB-SP), said creditors are bearing the brunt of the restrictions. “A technical note from the Central Bank says that 95% of transactions involving the purchase and sale of federal court-ordered payment claims involved normal haircuts. They changed everything because of the other 5%,” he said.
He points to a technical note issued by the organization calling for the resolution to be suspended so its effects can be assessed and the matter opened to public debate involving lawyers, the CVM, market participants, and civil society. The organization argues that the measure is unreasonable and lacks sufficient justification. It could also produce the opposite of the regulator’s intended effect by pushing these transactions into “less regulated and more difficult-to-monitor environments.”
Last week, as part of a broader tightening of financial controls, Brazil’s National Council of Justice (CNJ) approved a new resolution establishing a nationwide electronic system to track and register all sales of court-ordered payment claims in the country. The measure requires a public deed detailing the haircut applied to each transaction and prohibits the transfer of claims to lawyers who worked on the underlying case.
Guilherme Setoguti, chairman of the Brazilian Association of Special Situations and Litigation Finance, said the measure is unreasonable. “In trying to crack down on one specific fraud, everyone has been affected,” he said. He emphasized that no public hearing or regulatory impact assessment was conducted. “The CMN issued the rule overnight. We knew the government was looking for a solution, but nobody expected a measure like this.”
The lawyer says the ban is unconstitutional. “This is an asset that belongs to the creditor. They cannot prohibit its sale.” Setoguti has been taking part in meetings with government officials and market participants in search of a solution. Although the second phase of the rule is due to take effect soon, he remains hopeful that the government may reconsider some of the restrictions after the elections. The association is working with the Brazilian Private Equity and Venture Capital Association (ABVCAP) and the National Association of Participants in Receivables Investment Funds (Anfidc).
Sartini questions the measure’s reasonableness, proportionality, and rationale more than its legality. “Was this really the best response the regulator could have given? Does the Master case justify such broad restrictions? If the rule had already been in place, would it have prevented what happened? In my view, the response was excessive. The Master case only reinforced the need for stronger controls.”
Boari, of the OAB, notes that the situation for holders of court-ordered payment claims had already become more complicated following a constitutional amendment that capped annual payments by state and municipal governments at 1% of their net current revenue. According to him, the waiting list for payments owed by the city of São Paulo, which used to pay about R$5 billion a year, had already stretched to 16 years. Following the amendment, annual payments fell to R$2.5 billion. The lawyer said haircuts on the purchase of court-ordered claims had reached 70% under those circumstances and have now climbed to 95%.
According to André Franco Perdiza, a partner in the investment funds practice at law firm Mattos Filho, FIDCs were an important source of liquidity for individuals and companies. “The vast majority of investors and fund managers are serious players. The resolution restricts access to a capital markets channel that is already heavily regulated.”
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

