Angela Rayner’s reforms have been a disaster. I should know - The Telegraph
The Employment Rights Act will condemn hundreds of thousands of young adults to worklessness Credit: Getty Images/Marcin Nowak Luke Johnson Show biography Luke Johnson is a serial entrepreneur and the Chairman of Risk Capital Partners. He is the former Chairman of Pizza Express, Channel 4, and the Royal Society of Arts. A leading commentator on the UK economy, he is the author of several books on business.
Jobs are intrinsic to people’s well-being. In particular, young people need the structure, meaning and income an occupation provides. Without work, they tend to drift into bad habits and suffer much higher levels of ill-health and unhappiness.
So helping the nearly one million 16 to 24-year-olds not in employment, education or training (Neets) should be a core function of the British Government.
But jobs require two parties: employees who want to work, and firms willing to hire them.
And this Labour Government seems quite determined to discourage the roughly 1.5 million private sector employers, who provide about 82 per cent of all jobs, from growing their payrolls. Overall vacancies are at a 12-year low and this trend is particularly pronounced for junior roles.
I believe there are three main reasons why employers are being cautious over hiring younger people.
Firstly, the Government has made it much more expensive – by sharply increasing both the National Living Wage and the scale and scope of National Insurance. The total cost of employing a young person at a basic wage has risen by well over 50 per cent in four years. Inevitably, those starting in the labour market are finding it much harder to obtain their first position.
Secondly, the advent of AI is having a marked impact on companies of all types. It is automating many entry-level roles, allowing businesses to save money which, given the current very tough economic conditions, employers are generally embracing with both arms.
The nature of the British economy is such that we are particularly exposed to the types of administrative and professional services tasks that AI can perform well. I predict that organisations will steadily eliminate more such jobs in the coming months and years.
Finally, employers are correctly concerned about the likely impact of Angela Rayner’s Employment Rights Act. I believe this is a huge engine of job destruction and the most ill-timed piece of legislation I can ever remember. I spoke at a select committee in Parliament asking the MPs present to reconsider some of the many new regulations within the bill.
But the Labour MPs – none of whom had any material private-sector experience – ignored our pleas. This was an ideological law, rammed through because the Labour Party’s paymasters – the unions – wanted onerous new rights to unionise and mobilise workers in businesses.
The new act – which has been implemented in stages this year, and will come into full force in January next year – burdens employers with higher costs, a greater risk of litigation, and reduced flexibility in the workplace. The likelihood of companies facing tribunals has increased, day-one rights and costs have risen, claims are now uncapped, casual working arrangements are now much more complex, and the bureaucratic burden placed on HR departments has grown markedly. God knows how small businesses will cope.
The Government originally estimated the act would cost businesses up to £5bn a year. I fear this is a woeful underestimate of the true cost to society. Every entrepreneur I speak to is taking a more considered approach to recruitment. My inbox is full of terrifying warnings from employment lawyers about the extra paperwork, dangers and expense the legislation imposes. The toll from this foolish legislation in terms of missed opportunities and ruined life chances is impossible to calculate.
In the past, Britain succeeded in having much lower structural youth unemployment than countries like France, Italy and Spain by adopting more flexible and pragmatic employment laws and practices, which were a rational trade-off between the demands of bosses and workers.
We have thrown away that common-sense approach, and now Britain will suffer a generation of disenfranchised young people who cannot get work and build a career. We are witnessing an unfolding tragedy among 20-somethings who seek a place in society. Far too many are on welfare and failing to progress in their lives. They are not acquiring a work ethic or purpose, let alone thriving.
Alan Milburn has produced a long document which attempts to offer some solutions to this grave and growing problem. Unfortunately lockdowns, furlough and working from home, along with overdiagnosis of mental health issues, are compounding these challenges.
But this Government has poured petrol on the fire by passing a profoundly misjudged monster of an act. It will inhibit job creation and help condemn hundreds of thousands of young adults to worklessness and misery.
Only entrepreneurs and businesses can generate the growth and jobs which the country desperately needs: it feels as if Labour is doing everything they can to stop that happening.


