Analysis: Fiscal package offers limited gains at high political cost - Valor International

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from G1 Globo (globo.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
After difficult negotiations, the government’s fiscal package passed the Senate, with lawmakers rejecting key opposition amendments. Viewed with skepticism by segments of the left and financial markets alike, the bill demanded considerable political effort from President Luiz Iná...

After difficult negotiations, the government’s fiscal package passed the Senate, with lawmakers rejecting key opposition amendments. Viewed with skepticism by segments of the left and financial markets alike, the bill demanded considerable political effort from President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s inner circle at a time when a newly reelected president would typically enjoy substantial political capital.

The package, which now heads to the Lower House, required extensive bargaining despite what economists regard as its limited scope. The measures focus heavily on the 2027 fiscal balance, without introducing structural changes that could deliver lasting improvements and put public debt on a path toward stabilization—a prerequisite for a sustained decline in interest rates.

The package has also drawn criticism for continuing to prioritize additional revenue. The state of Brazil’s public finances has led economists across the spectrum, including those not traditionally associated with fiscal conservatism, to argue that efforts should focus on curbing expenditure.

The government says the measures could generate savings of up to R$60 billion. Economists’ estimates point to more modest gains.

In a preliminary assessment, BTG Pactual economist Fabio Serrano estimated that the package could improve the 2027 fiscal balance by R$27.9 billion. The bank had previously forecast a primary deficit of 0.14% of GDP for next year. With the proposed measures, Brazil could post a primary surplus of 0.05% of GDP.

Serrano estimates that revenue-raising measures could generate R$15 billion, outweighing the R$12.9 billion in projected spending reductions.

It is no coincidence that the government concentrated its efforts in the Senate on defeating an opposition amendment seeking to overturn restrictions on cross-tax offsets involving federal taxes. The government’s leader in the Lower House, Paulo Pimenta (Workers’ Party), described the measure as the “heart of the bill,” as Valor columnist César Felício noted in an analysis.

In BTG’s report, Serrano noted that the government expects the measure to generate approximately R$15 billion in revenue in 2027, within a range of R$12.5 billion to R$18.3 billion estimated by the Ministry of Planning and Budget.

The bank puts the figure at R$7.5 billion. Even so, that accounts for half of BTG’s projected additional revenue and more than a quarter of the package’s overall fiscal impact.

The estimate factors in risks stemming from taxpayers’ responses to the restrictions, including potential litigation. For the government, the measure effectively brings forward tax revenue rather than delivering a structural fiscal gain, Serrano stressed.

For companies, however, the measure means paying taxes earlier than anticipated in their financial plans for next year. With the opposition amendment defeated, the government will be able to restrict cross-tax offsets—the practice of using tax credits to settle liabilities arising from other federal taxes. This would reduce the volume of offsets and increase companies’ tax payments.

The prospect is unwelcome, particularly given uncertainty over the effects of Brazil’s tax reform, which is due to take effect next January and could affect both prices and corporate tax payments.

These changes come amid slowing economic activity, high private-sector indebtedness and elevated interest rates, which make working capital financing more expensive or potentially inaccessible.

Another amendment that required extensive negotiations concerned the postponement of transfers to states and municipalities under the Kandir Law. The dispute highlights another challenge to sustainable fiscal consolidation: securing the cooperation of regional governments in the adjustment effort.

The Kandir Law is not a new source of controversy. It has repeatedly resurfaced over the past three decades in disputes over the allocation of resources among different levels of government.

Enacted near the end of the last century and millennium, Complementary Law 87 of 1996 exempted exports of primary and semi-processed products from ICMS, Brazil’s state-level tax on goods and services.

For companies, the law led to an accumulation of ICMS tax credits, with disputes over offsetting rights fueling tax litigation at the time. Brazil’s tax reform is expected to correct this distortion.

For state governments, the law triggered a dispute over lost ICMS revenue that remains unresolved to this day. The legislation originally provided for compensation through 2002, with a possible extension to 2006.

States argued that their revenue losses had not been fully compensated. Another lengthy round of negotiations eventually prompted intervention by Brazil’s Supreme Court, leading to the agreement currently in force.

One of the commitments was for the federal government to transfer a combined R$4 billion annually to states through 2030, followed by a gradual reduction through 2037.

The fiscal package originally proposed capping annual transfers at R$1 billion through 2030, deferring part of the payments to the period between 2031 and 2037. This would have freed up R$3 billion annually for the federal government through 2030.

Serrano argued, however, that the measure would not improve the primary balance because the additional fiscal space would likely be redirected toward discretionary spending.

During the Senate vote, the bill’s rapporteur, Senator Eduardo Braga (Brazilian Democratic Movement, MDB), proposed raising the transfer cap to R$2 billion from R$1 billion for 2027 alone. Senate opposition leader Rogério Marinho (Liberal Party, PL) accepted the compromise.

Transfers are set to be gradually restored between 2028 and 2030, leaving the federal government with less room to reallocate discretionary spending.

For states, the measure means lower transfer revenues in 2027, the first year in office for governors elected this year. Had the original bill remained unchanged, transfers would have been affected throughout their four-year terms.

Municipal governments also have a stake in the issue, as they receive 25% of state ICMS revenue. Transfers under the Kandir Law are shared with municipalities in the same proportion.

Beyond the unfavorable macroeconomic backdrop, governors face spending commitments arising from investments that accelerated in the run-up to the elections and are expected to reach a record high in 2026.

Many states also took out loans to finance these investments and will have to begin repaying them once grace periods expire. Those that funded infrastructure projects using their own budget surpluses will enter the next term with considerably smaller cash buffers.

The dispute over Kandir Law transfers reveals that even a fiscal package whose impact is considered limited has met with little willingness on the part of some states and municipalities to contribute to the adjustment effort.

Lawmakers from São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro and Minas Gerais, among the states most exposed to a reduction in transfers, were particularly active in opposing the proposal.

More importantly, the episode illustrates how difficult negotiations between federal and regional governments can come at a steep fiscal cost, with consequences that may linger for years.

It remains to be seen how such negotiations will unfold from January 2027, when right-wing parties will predominate among state governors and members of Congress.

This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

Original Source
https://valorinternational.globo.com/politics/news/2026/11/19/fiscal-package-offers-limited-gains-at-high-political-cost.ghtml
Visit G1 Globo ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics