Which airline has the best premium economy? - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
From British Airways to Emirates, our writer unpacks whether the upgrade actually delivers Credit: British Airways John Arlidge Show biography John Arlidge is an aviation expert who has flown more miles, on more airlines, on more routes than any other UK writer. He has been highl...

From British Airways to Emirates, our writer unpacks whether the upgrade actually delivers Credit: British Airways John Arlidge Show biography John Arlidge is an aviation expert who has flown more miles, on more airlines, on more routes than any other UK writer. He has been highly commended six times as Feature Writer of the year and Business Journalist of the year in the British Press Awards. Follow him on LinkedIn.

We have all ordered the second-cheapest bottle of wine on the menu. But what about the second-cheapest cabin on the aircraft? Is premium economy worth the 50 to 100 per cent bump on economy fares?

The world’s largest airlines would like us to think so. They’re installing bigger and better cabins faster than you can say “upgrade”. The number of premium-economy seats on major airlines has quadrupled in the past decade, analysts at Cirium Ascend Consultancy calculate.

British Airways will have the biggest cabin of all, with 84 premium-economy seats, on its new A380 superjumbos. Qatar Airways has announced that it will soon introduce what promises to be one of the best new cabins. Emirates now offers food and drink that is as good as the business-class offering on some of its rivals.

The interior of BA’s new World Traveller Plus cabin Credit: British Airways It’s not all carrot. Carriers are also using the stick to persuade passengers to upgrade. Economy-class seats on many airlines are more cramped than ever. A meagre 17in in width and 31in of pitch – the distance between seats – is the best most offer. On the latest Boeing 777X jets economy seats will be 10 across the cabin, arranged 3-4-3. It’s a far cry from the days when passengers at the back of the bus got 34-36in of legroom on the Boeing 747 in the 1970s and 1980s.

The downgrade in economy means that many travellers are paying the premium for premium. You don’t get 50-100 per cent more space, but the extra cost per square inch calculation looks better if you are travelling in a pair. Grab the window and aisle seat pair and you and your companion have your own row. Premium seats are arranged 2-4-2 or 2-3-2, compared with 3-3-3 or 3-4-3 in economy cabins.

Snag the front row and no-one can recline their seat into your face, and you can get up to stretch your legs or go to the loo without disturbing your companion. Throw in the fact that some premium cabins have as few as 21 seats, compared with the 200-plus in economy, and the price bump suddenly appears to be much better value.

Most airlines allow premium-economy passengers to check in using a dedicated desk or two, and to board just after business-class passengers. Check-in baggage allowance is more generous than economy and some airlines – Emirates, for example – let you take larger carry-on bags. Others – such as United – let premium-economy passengers use fast-track security screening lanes.

Writer John Arlidge gets comfy in the Emirates premium-economy seat, which features a six-way adjustable head rest The seats are larger than economy, but don’t recline anywhere near enough to create a proper bed. Amenities tend to be basic. You will get earplugs, a toothbrush, a flimsy eye shade, a slightly less cheap-feeling blanket and pillow than in economy, and over-ear headphones.

The food and wine are better than in economy and usually served in proper crockery and glassware, not plastic, but the quality varies wildly. Boarding and getting off is quicker and easier since the premium-economy cabin is in front of economy.

Here is my round up of the best of the best based on recent flights.

Emirates prioritises comfort and style, with cream upholstery and adjustable head rests Credit: Emirates The airline offers premium economy on most flights between the UK and its Dubai hub, has the snazziest cabin, with cream leather and wood veneer. The 19.5in-wide seats offer 40in of pitch and have lumbar support and padded leg rests. The latest seats have a super-adjustable head rest to help you find the most comfortable position to sleep and a motorised privacy divider between seats for extra privacy. The TV is 13.3in on the diagonal.

A dedicated team of cabin crew serves premium-economy passengers. On the A350, Emirates has the most exclusive cabin – only 21 seats. That’s smaller than business class on the jet. The Airbus A380 offers the best loo-to-passenger ratio in premium – three lavatories for 56 passengers.

Emirates also has the best food and wine by miles. There are a Chablis Premier Cru and 2012 Chandon sparkling wines, and dishes include Thai pepper beef with jasmine rice and pak choi.

Virgin Atlantic’s Premium legroom is a major perk Credit: Virgin Atlantic The UK carrier was the first major global airline to introduce premium economy, which it now calls simply Premium (which is way better than BA’s word salad of World Traveller Plus). Virgin’s leather seats, which are up to 21in wide and offer 38in of legroom, softer lighting and more attentive service make its Premium feel more, er, premium than BA’s. On Virgin’s new A330Neo jet the seats have wireless phone charging and there is a self-serve snack bar called the Wander Wall. The TV screen is 13.3in on the diagonal.

Qantas is creating a purpose-made pillow to elevate its premium-economy seats Credit: Qantas The Aussie airline is raising the bar on its new Airbus A350 jets, which will soon start flying the 21 hours non-stop from London and New York to Sydney. “We’re redesigning the headrest to create a more pronounced wing-back chair to give more visual seclusion, which is great if you’re travelling alone,” says Qantas’s designer David Caon. Caon is also refining “a new special pillow that integrates with the headrest and becomes part of the seat”.

The new seat will “recline better, less because the seat back goes back more, and more because the bottom of the seat tracks forward and juts up, that gives you more of a ‘slung’ position”, he adds. “Combined with the footrest, it’s more like the old cradle seats that airlines used to have in business class.”

The wing-backs give passengers more privacy Credit: British Airways Members of the BA Club loyalty programme can earn generous tier points in World Traveller Plus, so it is a good cabin to book if you want to move up from Bronze status to Silver. Its new seats are about the same size as Virgin Atlantic’s and have the same legroom but feature wing-backs at head height to give each passenger a bit more privacy. There’s new bedding but, alas, evidence that BA is still skimping on perks. The seat-back TV screen on the new seats is not the largest one available for the seat.

Other carriers popular with British travellers include Finnair, which has an elegant cabin of only 21 seats on its long-haul Airbus A330s and 26 seats on its Airbus A350s. It offers some of the best value fares to Asia, provided you don’t mind stopping in Helsinki on the way.

Japan Airlines (JAL) offers a huge 42in of seat pitch and uses a fixed-shell seat design which means it slides forward within its own housing rather than reclining, which keeps everyone happier. Up to 36 hours before departure, premium economy passengers can submit cash bids for unsold business class suites.

JAL’s Japanese rival ANA offers premium-economy passengers lounge access at its major hubs, including Tokyo’s Haneda and Narita airports, Osaka’s Kansai, and Honolulu. On board you get a whopping 40 inches of pitch, a 15.6in TV screen, drinks from the business-class menu, including champagne, and snacks such as petit fours or cup-style noodles usually reserved for business class.

The premium-economy seats on Singapore Airlines leave much to be desired Credit: Singapore Airlines Its new seats on its forthcoming Boeing 777X are six years old and the grey colour scheme is drab.

The lack of tier and Avios points passengers earn lets Cathay Pacific down Credit: Cathay Pacific Under the new BA Club rules you earn a tiny fraction of the tier points and Avios on Cathay compared with BA. This is irritating because Cathay’s premium economy is otherwise excellent.

Lufthansa fails to differentiate between economy and premium-economy seats Credit: Lufthansa The premium-economy seats in its new jets are in the same cabin as economy, which betrays a tragic misunderstanding of the class system at 39,000ft.

Shop around. There’s more choice than ever. Find the right carrier for your needs, snag the best seats and premium economy can be money very well spent.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/advice/which-airline-has-best-premium-economy/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Travel