Two men convicted in the murder of a Canadian animation pioneer to be sentenced in Dominica - Toronto Star
Americans Jonathan Lehrer, 60 and Robert Snyder Jr., 66, were both found guilty of murder by a jury in the High Court of Justice in Roseau, the capital city of Dominica, in July.
Robert Snyder, left, and Jonathan Lehrer arrive at a courthouse in Roseau, Dominica. They have been convicted of murder in the December 2023 killings of Canadian businessman Daniel Langlois, 66, and his partner Dominique Marchand, 58.
The prosecutor in the case of two American men convicted for the 2023 murder of Canadian entrepreneur Daniel Langlois and his partner Dominique Marchand is asking the courts in the Caribbean island nation of Dominica to sentence both offenders to life in prison.
The prosecution’s request that both men spend the remainder of their “whole life,” in prison comes after the Crown opted not to seek the death penalty due to a special agreement it made with the French government in order to get access to Norville Williams, a key witness in the prosecution’s case, special prosecutor Keith Scotland told the Star.
“Although the state is not asking for the death sentence to be applied it submits that this matter is appropriate for a whole life sentence,” Scotland wrote in his sentencing submissions obtained by the Star in advance of Monday’s sentencing.
American entrepreneur Jonathan Lehrer, 60 and fellow American Robert Snyder Jr., 66, were both found guilty of murder by a jury in the High Court of Justice in Roseau, the capital city of Dominica, in July. Both men are to be sentenced Monday.
Court documents revealed that both victims were known for their charitable work in their adopted home and just a month before their murder Langlois had received a meritorious service award from the president of Dominica for his contributions to business, sustainable development, research and hospitality.
Robert Snyder and Jonathan Lehrer have been convicted of murder in the December 2023 killings of Canadian businessman Daniel Langlois, 66, and his partner Dominique Marchand, 58, who are pictured.
A statement from the families of the victims says they are relieved by the guilty verdict and “given the needs of the investigation, the ashes have just been repatriated to Canada, which prevented the families from organizing the funerals.”
The families expressed thanks to those who “showed their support throughout this heartbreaking tragedy.”
“It is still very difficult for me to believe that my son is gone, but the fact that the criminals were found guilty and that the ashes have just been repatriated, will finally allow me to bury my son with dignity,” Langlois’ mother said in the statement released Friday.
Scotland argued the “callousness” of the offenders makes it the “worst of the worst,” and that it was particularly aggravating that the men ambushed two victims, shot and burned them before attempting to conceal the bodies.
“It was planned and cold-blooded,” Scotland told the Star.
Lawyer for the convicted men Ravi Rajcoomar said Dominican law doesn’t provide the defence any wiggle room to challenge the sentence in a murder with those aggravating features. His clients have appealed the conviction.
“Because two persons were killed violently and there was an attempt to conceal the body, under Dominican law, you can only have a whole life sentence,” Rajcoomar said. “The law doesn’t allow us to do anything else. Whether or not that is constitutional is another issue.”
He added, “my clients maintain their innocence.”
Rajcoomar argued that “detaining someone with no chance of ever regaining freedom is also incompatible with human dignity.”
Langlois, a Canadian computer animation pioneer, and Marchand were found dead in a burnt-out SUV not far from the off-grid mountaintop resort they owned on the island on Dec. 1, 2023. Four days later Lehrer and Snyder Jr., who was purportedly working for Lehrer as a mechanic were arrested.
The state’s case was premised on the allegation that it was a “contract killing,” and that Lehrer hired Snyder to kill them, according to court filings.
Snyder was said to be a hit man who, armed with a licensed firearm belonging to Lehrer, who shot Langlois and Marchand as they returned to their home.
The police discovered five spent casings that were linked to Lehrer’s licensed firearm. They also obtained bullet fragments which were linked as having been fired from a barrel owned by Lehrer, and which fitted his licensed firearm. Snyder had burns along his right leg the state argued to the jury were due to the fire, court documents show.
“The State’s case therefore was that this was a premeditated contract killing,” Rajcoomar wrote, adding that the prosecutor argued that Lehrer had procured Snyder “as a hit man and then assisted Snyder to incinerate the evidence.”
Langlois and Marchand built a 285-acre, 14-suite eco-resort that opened in 2022; Lehrer oversaw Bois Cotlette Estate, a historic cocoa plantation next door.
Prior to the killings, Langlois and Lehrer had been locked in a protracted legal battle over the use of a road, known as the Morne Rouge Public Road, that connects their properties, according to court records.
The road crossed through the Lehrer estate, sparking the conflict.
Evidence called at trial proved that Langlois, 66, and Marchand, 58, were ambushed on a remote trail near Soufriere, a village in the southern part of the island, as they returned to their upscale resort.
The prosecutor’s sentencing filings indicate that the couple would often use the road through Bois Cotlette to get to Soufriere for their meals and “on numerous occasions they encountered confrontations with Jonathan, his wife Victoria,” and their employees, including Norville Williams, who “repeatedly engaged in verbal abuse and threats.”
The couple was making that routine return trip in their Nissan X-Trail on Nov. 30, 2023, when they were attacked and shot by Snyder, the court heard. The accused then transported the victims to an isolated road about two kilometres from the ambush site. The vehicle was riddled with bullets before it was set on fire with Langlois and Marchand inside.
“They were burnt beyond recognition,” Scotland said.
Scotland said Williams was in France at the time of the trial and in exchange for the co-operation of the French government to facilitate his testimony, the prosecutor agreed that it wouldn’t seek the death penalty for the accused.
“He was a main witness for the state,” Scotland said. Although Williams did not see the shooting, he heard the shooting and heard Marchand cry out, “oh my God, oh my God.”
The court also heard evidence from a German hiker, who testified to hearing the shots and identified one of the accused leaving the scene where the car was burned.
The guilty verdict was returned on July 28 after two hours of deliberation by the jury. The murder trial ran for four weeks and featured more than 40 witnesses.
Langlois made his fortune in the 1990s selling his Montreal-based company, Softimage, which produced software used in Hollywood blockbusters such as “Jurassic Park,” the “Harry Potter” franchise and “Titanic.” He and Marchand moved to Dominica in 1997.
The maximum penalty for murder in Dominica is the death penalty, according to the government website. The island is categorized internationally as an “abolitionist in practice” or “de facto abolitionist” state, which reflects a distinct constitutional compromise: while the Dominican state actively defends its sovereign right to maintain capital punishment within its criminal codes, it has maintained an unbroken, self-imposed moratorium on executions for the past four decades.
Jason Miller is a Toronto-based reporter for the Star covering crime and justice. Reach him on email: jasonmiller@thestar.ca or follow him on X: @millermotionpic.

