The figures that show Britain is better off without Europe - The Telegraph
Andy Burnham says a closer relationship with the EU could boost GDP by up to 0.4pc Credit: Getty Images/Nadja Wohlleben Szu Ping Chan Economics Editor Show biography Szu Ping Chan is The Telegraph's Economics Editor. She has covered the main events that have shaped the global economy over the past 15 years, from the financial crisis to Europe's debt crisis and the fallout from the pandemic, breaking stories and interviewing many of the key players along the way.
Andy Burnham believes the key to higher growth lies in Brussels.
The Prime Minister signed a “reset” deal with the EU on Friday that swaps freer trade in food and drink for a youth mobility scheme.
It will also pave the way for cheaper tuition fees for EU students who study at British universities.
The deal will bring Britain much closer to Brussels, after Burnham told an audience in the City this week that the UK had “lost more than we gained” since leaving the EU.
He believes these steps towards a closer relationship could boost GDP by up to 0.4pc – or roughly £15bn in today’s money.
Burnham wants this to be just the beginning, pledging to “explore options” for a different long-term relationship with Brussels. He has plenty of cheerleaders.
David Lammy, the former foreign secretary, recently declared that “membership is the greatest growth accelerator the Government has available”.
Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, has also described Europe as the single biggest opportunity to boost incomes, raise money for public services and strengthen Britain’s security.
However, a dramatic revision to Britain’s productivity figures has cast doubt on the idea that reversing Brexit would transform the country’s economic fortunes.
The economy is now thought to be producing more per hour worked than previously estimated, challenging Britain’s previous dire productivity record.
Output per hour is now estimated by the Office for National Statistics to have climbed by 2.5pc in the year to the third quarter of 2026.
That’s even faster than the roughly 2pc average annual growth rate recorded before the financial crisis.
The revised figures also showed that output per hour worked was 8.8pc higher than before the pandemic, with the economy producing 7.9pc more despite people working 0.9pc fewer hours.
With the stroke of a pen, Britain has gone from being one of the worst productivity performers among rich economies to one of the best.
This is important because productivity growth is the single most important factor underpinning higher wages and stronger living standards.
The Treasury will also be hoping that a sustained improvement persuades Britain’s tax and spending watchdog to take a more optimistic view of the economy.
Even a 0.1 percentage point upgrade to annual productivity growth forecasts could increase projected tax revenues and reduce borrowing by roughly £7bn to £8bn a year.
Simon French, the chief economist at Panmure Liberum, says the figures also challenged some of the assumptions that have shaped the economic debate since Brexit.
“Much of the economic commentary since Brexit has been shaped by data on the UK’s poor productivity performance,” he says.
“This fresh data questions key parts of that analysis. In particular, the performance of the UK compared to its European peers where, since 2016, productivity growth has been faster in the UK than in Germany, France and Italy.”
This does not mean Brexit has not had an economic cost. But Martin Beck, of WPI Strategy, adds: “The latest productivity numbers make it increasingly difficult to sustain the argument that leaving the EU seriously damaged the UK economy or rejoining the bloc would deliver some kind of transformative, dynamic growth dividend.”
Economists have questioned how quickly any benefits from rejoining could be realised. Returning would involve years of tortuous negotiations, potentially creating more uncertainty for businesses.
Previous analysis by the think tank UK In A Changing Europe found that accession took an average of four years and 10 months, even before accounting for the time spent applying for membership and securing candidate status.
However, it’s worth remembering that the latest productivity figures come with a caveat.
The revisions show that Britain is producing the same amount of output in fewer hours. That’s not the same as saying the pie itself has suddenly become bigger and the country is more prosperous.
And while the figures suggest that productivity growth has been stronger than previously thought, they do not mean Britain’s long-running economic problems have disappeared.
As Bart van Ark, of the Productivity Institute, puts it: “From a productivity point of view, it’s good news, but from the perspective of the growth of the economy, we have to make sure that we also put more people to work who can then become more productive.”
Part of the improvement could also reflect changes in the composition of the workforce.
Higher employment costs, including Reeves’s £25bn National Insurance raid and inflation-busting minimum wage increases, risk pricing less productive workers out of jobs. That can flatter productivity figures by leaving a smaller pool of more productive workers in employment.
But van Ark warns there is a balance to be struck: “We should be careful not to raise the minimum wage too fast, so that it does allow lower productivity people to come into work. That might slow the productivity growth rate a little bit but it would add to the number of workers in the economy.”
And despite the substantial revisions, van Ark says Britain’s productivity growth remains far below its pre-financial-crisis trend: “Before the financial crisis, labour productivity growth was about 2pc. Since the financial crisis, it’s been about 1pc, so still about half of what it was.”
Yet despite all that, it remains true that the new productivity data challenge the binary view of Europe that Burnham has promoted: being in the EU is good for growth and being out is bad.
“The assumption that closer integration with the EU would automatically unlock significantly faster UK growth looks increasingly questionable when data on actual economic performance tell a rather different story,” says Beck.
“Those advocating rejoining need to demonstrate where this additional growth would come from, rather than simply asserting that it would materialise.”
Van Ark is also sceptical that a new relationship with the EU would deliver the “percentage points” on growth that Burnham is seeking.
“We should not assume that the pace at which we have lost output because of Brexit will be recovered by a rapprochement to the EU,” he insists.
“That might take a lot more time and therefore we should perhaps not expect miracles from joining or re-entering or collaborating with the EU in any sort of way any time soon.”


