The EU is desperate for Britain’s money - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The PM is seen as ‘a new resource’ for the bloc Dominic Lawson Show biography Dominic Lawson is a columnist for the Telegraph, writing on the big political and social issues of our time. He is a former editor of The Sunday Telegraph and The Spectator magazine, and the author of a...

The PM is seen as ‘a new resource’ for the bloc Dominic Lawson Show biography Dominic Lawson is a columnist for the Telegraph, writing on the big political and social issues of our time. He is a former editor of The Sunday Telegraph and The Spectator magazine, and the author of an acclaimed book on world championship chess, ‘The Inner Game’.

Andy Burnham is well on the way to becoming the most popular man in Brussels. As he likes so much to be liked, this will do the Prime Minister’s ego no harm at all. But it is all for the wrong reasons – at least from the point of view of the British taxpayer.

The always well-informed Brussels-based and Belgian-owned publication Rapporteur this week published an account of the current state of negotiations, from their end of the table. It was headlined: “UK seen as new EU budget cash machine”. The current focus is on how London will be made to pay in to the “cohesion funds” for the poorer member nations in exchange for being part of the EU’s electricity market (even though it is supposed to be mutually beneficial).

Someone identified as “an EU diplomat” explained it to Rapporteur as follows: “Burnham needs Europe and we need cash. Burnham is a new resource for us. Win, win.” Funnily enough, in his speech at the Lord Mayor’s banquet this week, Burnham used the same trite phrase about his negotiations with the EU, though without mentioning the money.

Eddy Wax, the author of the Rapporteur’s newsletter, told me: “I don’t think people in the UK are picking up just how much everything here in Brussels is focused on the budget, and how threadbare the coffers are. Everyone is looking at how to get more, by hook or by crook. It’s a brutal fight for resources. It is not a very auspicious time for the UK to make its own demands for access.”

The brutality will become most obvious at the end of this month when EU national leaders meet at a summit to thrash out the 2028-2034 Multiannual Financial Framework. Not the least of its problems is that in 2028 the EU must begin repaying the colossal joint debt (almost €600bn) incurred in the so-called Covid recovery fund.

The business is made especially fraught by the fact that France is on the cusp of a presidential election, in which Madame Le Pen is expected to emerge the victor. And she is campaigning on a pledge to reduce France’s EU budget contributions, à la Margaret Thatcher.

Against this fiscal background, it is astonishing that Burnham is playing footsie with the notion of taking the UK back into the EU. Though the hearts of those who favour Return must have sunk when David Lammy this week set himself up as the figurehead for such a campaign. This is a man who puts his foot in his mouth so frequently and so forcibly, it is a wonder he has any teeth left.

In 2019, from a public platform, he had compared members of the Conservative Party’s European Research Group to Nazis. When challenged on this by the BBC’s then presenter Andrew Marr, Lammy responded that what he said “wasn’t strong enough”. Brexiteers were worse than Nazis, in other words.

On the other hand, Lammy now says that if we were to re-join the EU, we would be showered with almost unimaginable riches. In an interview on the Today programme the former foreign secretary declared “we would get an immediate £150bn boost to the economy.” Just like that, as the late Tommy Cooper would say, when performing one of his farcical magic tricks.

Lammy’s version, I think, must have been based on one of those doppelgänger extrapolations, which attempted to show what the UK’s economic performance would have been had we remained in the EU.

It was another man of the Left, one who, in 2016, had described Brexit as “the worst of all worlds”, but 10 years later delivered the most withering rebuke of such surveys. This is Yanis Varoufakis, the former Greek finance minister, and an economist himself. Varoufakis pointed out how the Remain campaign had disgraced itself with Project Fear.

The then chancellor, George Osborne, had said a vote for Leave would plunge the UK into recession, house prices would collapse, and an emergency Budget would be needed. Now, said Varoufakis, the abject failure of these predictions had been succeeded by Project Smear, which claimed Brexit was still an economic disaster even though none of those earlier warnings were vindicated.

As he noted, these “what might have been had we not left the EU” simulations are widely based on the assumption that we would otherwise have more resembled the US economy than any others (why?), and would have soared above the performance of the bigger EU nations.

Leave aside the fact that the US has benefited from industrial energy prices a quarter of ours, Varoufakis concludes: “With or without Brexit, the UK’s economy, indeed any European economy, could never have come even close to America’s post 2016 growth rate. Project Smear was founded on non-credible data. It cannot, like Project Fear before it, withstand even the most cursory of rational analyses.”

And this week the Office for Budget Responsibility produced revised data which suggest that UK productivity actually accelerated compared with the major EU economies in the 10 years to 2025. This is highly significant, as it was an alleged blow to our productivity from being outside the European single market that led so many in the Remain camp to say we would become again “the sick man of Europe”.

They quite failed to appreciate how much our vital financial services industry and the new one of AI were gaining from being outside the pervasive and protectionist EU acquis.

And how demented it would be to prepare the ground for paying a gross annual membership fee to Brussels of £39bn, or £750m a week, (implied by the projected €2tn budget for 2028-2034, and the fact we would never regain our “Thatcher rebate”).

This, though, explains the remark of the Czech PM Andrej Babiš, when asked by Sky News whether he would welcome the UK re-joining the EU: “Yes, of course. We need more money.”

Well, they do. But since the UK itself has an annual public sector net borrowing requirement of about £135bn, and almost 10p in every pound spent by the Exchequer is borrowed (at ever-increasing rates of interest), what would the PM cut to find that colossal membership fee?

The truth, which Mr Burnham cannot even begin to imagine, is the denizens of Brussels need us more than we need them.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/20/eu-desperate-for-britain-money/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics