Stella Creasy backs Swiss-style relationship with EU - The Telegraph

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Telegraph (telegraph.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Stella Creasy says that ‘security and prosperity start with solidarity, not isolation’ Credit: Getty Images/Leon Neal Nick Gutteridge Chief Political Correspondent. Dominic Penna Senior Political Correspondent Updated 19 November 2026 10:00pm GMT Published 19 November 2026 6:59pm...

Stella Creasy says that ‘security and prosperity start with solidarity, not isolation’ Credit: Getty Images/Leon Neal Nick Gutteridge Chief Political Correspondent. Dominic Penna Senior Political Correspondent Updated 19 November 2026 10:00pm GMT Published 19 November 2026 6:59pm GMT Andy Burnham should seek a Swiss-style deal with the EU rather than trying to rejoin immediately, a Europhile Labour MP has said.

Stella Creasy, who chairs the Labour Movement for Europe group, urged the Prime Minister to pursue a “realistic” approach in talks with Brussels.

Writing for The Telegraph (below) Ms Creasy said she would like to see Britain return to the EU “one day”, but that was unlikely to happen in the short term.

Instead, she said Labour could strike a “much more ambitious partnership” by ditching its manifesto red lines and rejoining the bloc’s single market.

She made the comments in a joint opinion piece with Bernd Lange, the chairman of the European Parliament’s international trade committee.

Switzerland participates in the single market through a web of more than 140 individual deals, which give it access to different economic sectors. In return, it mirrors most EU regulations, accepts free movement of people with the bloc and is indirectly subject to the European Court of Justice.

Ms Creasy’s comments come after Mr Burnham opened a divide within Labour by using his conference speech to float the possibility of rejoining the EU.

His announcement was welcomed by many anti-Brexit Labour backbenchers but also prompted concern among Red Wall MPs.

In recent days, No 10 has attempted to hose down speculation over his intentions after Eurosceptics formed a new campaign to keep Britain out of the bloc.

Ms Creasy, the MP for Walthamstow in north-east London, is one of Labour’s most senior pro-EU backbenchers and has been a staunch advocate of rejoining.

Her backing for a Swiss-style deal, which would involve single market access but not membership, offers a potential option for the Prime Minister as he looks for options for Labour to unite behind.

This week, David Lammy, the former deputy prime minister and foreign secretary, called for Mr Burnham to pledge to take Britain back into the EU at the next election.

Peter Kyle, the former business secretary, backed the call, warning that a “complex halfway option” that would be the “worst of all worlds”.

However, writing alongside Mr Lange, a German MEP, Ms Creasy urged the Prime Minister to take “realistic measures” to move closer to Europe by pursuing a “Swiss-plus” pact.

“Step-by-step improvements in the EU-UK relationship are welcome, but they alone will not meet the scale of the challenges we all face,” the pair wrote.

“We both believe that the UK would be stronger today if it were a member of the European Union, and we hope that the UK will one day return home.

“The path there may not be easy, and history suggests we cannot assume it will be short. Yet when we look ahead, we do not see uncharted territory.”

Ms Creasy and Mr Lange argued that Switzerland benefitted from perks including protections for its “generous benefits system”.

They said EU citizens moving to Switzerland had to prove they had a job or enough money to support themselves, as well as health insurance.

Swiss politicians can also pull an “emergency brake” to temporarily restrict immigration where it is causing “serious economic or social difficulties”.

Pursuing a similar deal would breach two of Labour’s three manifesto red lines which ruled out the single market, customs union or free movement.

Mr Burnham has said the red lines will stay in place until the next election, but has floated the possibility of ditching them in Labour’s future manifesto.

Reform UK and the Tories are opposed to rejoining the single market, which would mean a return to freedom of movement.

A new poll, published on Thursday by More in Common, found that 46 per cent of people backed “making Brexit work better” compared with 38 per cent who wanted to focus on rejoining.

On Friday Mr Burnham will attend the UK-EU summit in Brussels at which he will sign a Brexit “reset” deal largely negotiated by Sir Keir Starmer.

A stalwart of the party’s Left has warned him that rejoining the EU would cause bankruptcies and job losses in his own constituency of Makerfield.

Writing for The Telegraph, Jon Trickett, a former aide to Gordon Brown, set out a list of 12 reasons why he believed returning to the bloc would be a bad idea.

He argued another referendum could tear Britain apart, taking aim at unelected EU officials and “rising tides of dissent” in riot-stricken member states.

Nigel Farage is jubilant at the European Parliament as it approves the Brexit deal, January 2020 Credit: Getty Images/Sean Gallup Mr Farage told The Telegraph: “This would be a costly error for households and the country. This whole project is pushing Andy Burnham’s backward-looking political view.

“The cost of living increase and the tax increases needed to rejoin the EU would total a combined £3,250 per household a year. This would be a complete betrayal and surrender – with hard-working Brits picking up the bill.”

He also warned moving closer to the EU could spark riots, telling The Sun he was “enormously worried” about the impact of Mr Burnham’s plans on democracy.

He said: “I think our democracy’s at a very fragile point, and I think there’s a growing number of young people who think maybe direct action’s the way forward.”

Asked if this could mean people taking to the streets in protest, he said: “I’m sorry to say that I do sense that is growing out there.”

Many had given up hope that the day would come when the damage Brexit is doing to us all could be fixed.

Yet since the Labour Party conference there has been a feeling that something has fundamentally changed – a new openness, a new sense of opportunity and a growing willingness to discuss our common European future.

Together we look with new hope to Andy Burnham and his willingness to say Brexit has done more harm than good, which has opened up a new political opportunity. Recognising the weight of evidence of the past decade is one thing. What to do next is less clear.

Brexit separated the UK from its partners in the EU – yet it never defeated the case for cooperation.

The economic, security and climate concerns that have defined the past decade for us all have shown first-hand that going it alone does not keep you safe or prosperous. It has damaged the British economy and deprived the EU of a valuable partner at the table.

Ten years after the referendum, the case for a closer relationship between the EU and the UK is stronger than ever. The ongoing debate over Made in Europe shows how connected we still are – and how important dialogue between close partners remains.

That is why, as we take up the challenge the Prime Minister sets of asking “what next?”, we should approach this relationship not through the prism of the past pain of Brexit, but with a shared vision of our future as Europeans.

Step-by-step improvements in the EU-UK relationship are welcome, but they alone will not meet the scale of the challenges we all face. In an increasingly fragmented world, our shared interests and values provide a strong foundation for a much more ambitious partnership.

As chairs of the Labour Movement for Europe and the European Parliament’s international trade committee, we encourage parliamentarians on both sides to do all they can to make the upcoming November EU-UK summit a success.

Agreements on food and drink trade, emissions trading, electricity and youth mobility would be important first steps. But the summit should not be seen as the culmination of the reset. It should mark the beginning of a much more ambitious process, as the UK examines all options on the table, including rejoining.

The Prime Minister is right to ask for a dialogue on those options, because the EU has built its relationships in different ways – not least with Switzerland.

At the heart of the updated agreements governing Switzerland’s relationship with the EU is a fair balance of rights and obligations. By moving on from previous red lines, the UK now appears ready to explore such new possibilities.

It is a developed model for integration into large parts of the single European market. Indeed, parts of Switzerland’s new agreements were shaped with an eye on the UK, and the negotiations for November’s summit are already developing Swiss-style mechanisms.

Those in the UK who still fear the spectre of EU freedom of movement can be reassured that Switzerland’s agreement protects the country’s generous benefits system. EU citizens must be registered with the Swiss authorities; they must either have a job or show sufficient funds of their own, along with health insurance.

The new agreement also provides for a safeguard mechanism to restrict immigration in the event of serious economic or social difficulties. As the UK, a key Nato ally, is not constrained by Swiss-style neutrality, we could envisage an even more ambitious partnership, both economically and politically – a model we might call “Swiss plus”.

We both believe that the UK would be stronger today if it were a member of the EU, and we hope that the UK will one day return home. The path there may not be easy, and history suggests we cannot assume it will be short. Yet when we look ahead, we do not see uncharted territory.

Politicians on both sides of the Channel can help to raise the level of ambition in this discussion and encourage a dialogue on what might be possible – through realistic measures that strengthen the EU and the UK together. As European social democrats, we know that security and prosperity start with solidarity, not isolation.

Ten years after the Brexit referendum, a new day is dawning in EU-UK relations. It is now our shared responsibility to turn that opportunity into reality. Morning has broken. The new day is ours. Let us seize it together.

Stella Creasy is the MP for Walthamstow and the chairman of the Labour Movement for Europe. Bernd Lange is a German MEP and the chairman of the European Parliament’s international trade committee.

Original Source
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/19/leading-labour-rejoiner-backs-swiss-style-relationship-eu/
Visit The Telegraph ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Politics