Schools may not withhold report cards over unpaid fees, parents told - IOL
Parents remain liable for valid school-fee debts, but public schools may not withhold learners’ report cards because of arrears. Parents who cannot afford fees can apply for exemptions or engage schools about payment arrangements.
Parents must still pay or formally address school-fee arrears, but schools may not use learners’ report cards as debt-collection tools, an activist and parent representative say.
Phoenix human rights activist Berlinda Belcher said parents had a legal right to access their children’s academic records, even when schools withheld report cards over unpaid fees.
The advice comes as families prepare for the end of the year school term, when disputes over schools withholding pupils’ report cards due to outstanding fees often resurface.
Belcher said the law wass clear: both public and independent schools in South Africa are prohibited from withholding pupils’ report cards over unpaid school fees.
"In South Africa, schools both public and independent offering the National Curriculum Statement (Grades R to 12) are prohibited from withholding report cards due to outstanding fees or unreturned school property," she said.
She said many parents are unaware that school fee disputes and a pupils' right to their academic record are treated as two completely separate matters under South African law.
"The South African Schools Act: Section 41(7) of the South African Schools Act explicitly forbids public schools from depriving a pupil of their report card, academic records, or transfer certificate because of unpaid fees.
“National Assessment Rules of the National Protocol for Assessment state that parents and guardians have the right to access their children’s reports, and schools may not withhold them for any reason including fee arrears or unreturned textbooks. This rule applies to all public and independent schools offering the National Curriculum Statement from Grades R to 12," said Belcher.
She said the school year was nearing its end, with many parents facing financial pressure.
"Parents should not worry about the school fees, it is a basic human right for their children to learn.
“Besides school fees, parents are forced to spend so much money on uniforms, stationery, lunches, transport and, at times, data for homework," said Belcher.
She said that for parents who have fallen behind on fees, the prospect of a child’s report card being withheld adds to their worries.
"A pupil's education and dignity should never be used as a way to collect a debt. I am asking any parent or guardian who receives a notice saying their child’s report will only be released after outstanding fees are paid to contact me privately.
“This applies to any school, not only Phoenix schools. Please send me a copy of the notice and the school’s name so that we can raise the matter, ask for the report to be released and, if necessary, take the concern to the Department of Education," Belcher said.
She said these issues were particularly concerning as additional barriers placed further strain on families already struggling to make ends meet.
"Children need their reports to understand their progress and prepare for the next school year. Above all, children need parents and human rights activists and educational institutions to protect their right to education," she said.
Last year a Phoenix parent accused their child’s school of withholding their report over unpaid fees.
The parent, who asked to remain anonymous to protect her Grade 10 daughter, told the sundaytribune.co.za that Phoenix school had allegedly refused to release the pupil’s report card until all outstanding school fees were paid in full.
The parent said she approached the school last year to collect her child’s year-end report card but was allegedly told by school officials that it would not be released because of an outstanding balance of R3 000 on the school fee account.
"I spoke with the principal regarding this matter, however he seemed to think the school had grounds to withhold reports. This is unfair because I did sign a concession form and the school management needs to understand that not all parents have enough money to pay school fees," she said.
She said they gave her a report the next day after paying the full amount of the fees.
"This school usually does not give out report cards to pupils or parents if school fees are not fully paid. The Department of Education needs to address this issue because many parents are suffering out there," she said.
She said paying the full school fees was hard because she was the only working person in the family.
Vee Gani, Chairperson of the KZN Parent's Association said it was illegal for a school to withhold a pupil’s report card due to overdue school fees.
"This is something the education department strictly prohibits. There is also a law that protects pupils from this issue. So the school cannot withhold the report card based on that law," he said.
Gani said the school must engage with the parents on a plan to pay the school fees, the pupil should not suffer.
"The school cannot deny a pupil their report. Schools normally tell parents to collect the reports of their children from the school. When a parent comes to the school, they give out the report and engage with the parent on how the fees will be paid," he said.
Gani urged parents who cannot pay the school fees to engage with school management and explain their issues as early as possible to avoid complications.
The KwaZulu-Natal Department of Education did not comment at the time of publication.

