SC asked to void lowered vote threshold in Sara Duterte impeachment
MANILA, Philippines — Two petitions have been filed before the Supreme Court challenging the lowered voting threshold approved by the Senate impeachment court to convict Vice President Sara Duterte.
Lawyer Ernesto Francisco filed his petition on Friday, September 25, while former Executive Secretary Vic Rodriguez filed his petition on Thursday, September 24.
Both petitioners urged the Supreme Court to intervene immediately rather than wait for the trial's conclusion.
They argued that allowing a potentially unconstitutional voting standard to decide the Vice President's fate could plunge the nation into severe political chaos and instability.
Francisco asked the High Court to declare the September 23 Senate proceedings null and void and issue a Status Quo Ante Order.
Rodriguez similarly prayed for a temporary restraining order to restrain the Senate from conducting or giving effect to any final conviction vote under the reduced denominator, asking the Court to reinstate the July 6 ruling requiring a strict 16-vote threshold.
Both petitioners argue that the Senate has overstepped its constitutional boundaries.
For Francisco, he said that the Senate impeachment court's ruling is a "capricious, arbitrary and whimsical interpretation" that amounts to a constitutional amendment.
"Substituting 'all members of the Senate' with 'those members who... remain legally and factually capable of participating' constitutes a rewriting of the Constitution, which the public respondent Senate Impeachment Court cannot legally do," Francisco said.
He warned that allowing the voting threshold to fluctuate based on individual circumstances threatens the structural integrity of other legislative voting requirements, such as declaring a state of war, overriding presidential vetoes, or passing tax exemptions.
Rodriguez, on his part, argued that the Senate cannot bypass the formal amendment and revision processes mandated under Article XVII of the Constitution.
"The Constitution does not recognize an 'impeachment exception' to its own amendment provisions," Rodriguez said.
The Senate impeachment court on September 22 lowered the voting threshold to convict Duterte, ruling that senators unable to take part in her trial will no longer count toward the two-thirds required by the Constitution.
abtestabtest Senate panel wants Bato to explain prolonged absence By Neil Jayson Servallos | 6 hours ago The Senate ethics committee is set to call a hearing on the complaint filed against Sen. Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa... Headlines President Marcos, Chinese foreign minister discuss West Philippine Sea issues By Helen Flores | 6 hours ago President Marcos is hopeful for “better” and “improved” relations with China, following his recent... Headlines Cale88 had no employees in 2024, only 2 in 2025 — BOI records By Kristine Daguno-Bersamina | 11 hours ago Cale88 Foods Corp., a banana chips exporter co-founded by Vice President Sara Duterte’s husband, Manases Carpio, had... Headlines Marcos signs law expanding vouchers to kindergarten, elementary students 14 hours ago The law, known as the Basic Education Voucher Assistance Act, provides financial assistance to students in areas with “congested”... Headlines Palace, House deny VP camp’s ‘no-el’ scenario By Alexis Romero | 1 day ago Malacañang yesterday likened Vice President Sara Duterte to famous storyteller Lola Basyang after her camp claimed... Headlines Latest More in Headlines PAL firms up first Dreamliner order Philippines, Japan sign emergency loan, water supply grant deals President Marcos: China’s playing of ‘Anak’ a ‘gracious’ gesture Money changer exec in Martin plunder case surrenders to NBI abtest President Marcos expands school voucher program to kinder, elementary By Helen Flores | 6 hours ago President Marcos has signed a law institutionalizing government-funded vouchers for Filipino students from kindergarten to... Headlines 5 ex-staff of Sara Duterte were not held captive — PNP By Ian Laqui | 13 hours ago The Philippine National Police said that no rescue operation took place involving a former household staff member of Vice... Headlines Fact check: Facebook reel twists survey findings on Sara Duterte impeachment By Geraldine Santos | 16 hours ago Facebook page Facts PH misrepresents Momentum Research survey figures to falsely claim most Filipinos believe Sara Duterte... Headlines NBI finds that samples from Cavite crematorium were not pet ashes By Kristine Daguno-Bersamina | 18 hours ago Five pet owners are seeking justice after forensic tests showed that samples given to them as cremated ashes of their pets... Headlines Senate impeachment court summons Sara Duterte's spox over remarks on senator-judges By Ian Laqui | 19 hours ago The Senate impeachment court issued a show-cause order against Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesperson, lawyer Paolo... Headlines Recommended Senate slashes P97.5 billion from 2027 DPWH budget 6 hours ago The Senate has stripped P97.5 billion worth of non-compliant projects from the proposed 2027 budget of the Department of Public... HeadlinesBUDGET ‘Cale88 Foods named after VP spouse, dentist’ 6 hours ago Cale88 Foods Corp., the banana chips exporter co-owned by Vice President Sara Duterte’s husband Manases Carpio and her... HeadlinesTRENDING Impeachment court issues show-cause order to VP spokesman 6 hours ago The Senate impeachment court on Friday issued a show-cause order to Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo... HeadlinesTRENDING Senate panel wants Bato to explain prolonged absence 6 hours ago The Senate ethics committee is set to call a hearing on the complaint filed against Sen. Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa... HeadlinesTRENDING EDITORIAL — Senate sanctions 6 hours ago The House of Representatives has been quick to impose disciplinary sanctions on its members, from reprimand to suspension... HeadlinesTRENDING next Recommended Senate slashes P97.5 billion from 2027 DPWH budget The Senate has stripped P97.5 billion worth of non-compliant projects from the proposed 2027 budget of the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) in the committee report filed on Friday, Senate finance committee chair Sen. JV Ejercito announced. 6 hours ago BUDGET ‘Cale88 Foods named after VP spouse, dentist’ Cale88 Foods Corp., the banana chips exporter co-owned by Vice President Sara Duterte’s husband Manases Carpio and her dentist Lourdes Lebosada, takes its name from the first two letters of their surnames paired with a number symbolizing infinity, a trade official confirmed to the Senate impeachment court on Friday. 6 hours ago TRENDING Impeachment court issues show-cause order to VP spokesman The Senate impeachment court on Friday issued a show-cause order to Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo over statements that allegedly cast doubt on the integrity of senator-judges. 6 hours ago TRENDING Senate panel wants Bato to explain prolonged absence The Senate ethics committee is set to call a hearing on the complaint filed against Sen. Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa over his prolonged absence from official duties in the chamber, committee chairman Senate President Pro Tempore Vicente Sotto III confirmed yesterday. 6 hours ago TRENDING EDITORIAL — Senate sanctions The House of Representatives has been quick to impose disciplinary sanctions on its members, from reprimand to suspension and expulsion, for a wide range of issues including disorderly behavior. 6 hours ago TRENDING OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

