Peter FitzSimons: Australian cricket needs a hero to heal the wounds of Sandpapergate. I know just the man
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.
What a bloody week! As TFF commented on Thursday, I’ve seen prettier train-smashes, even ones with less likelihood of survivors.
And yes, it’s a funny game, cricket. This time last week, skipper Pat Cummins was riding high after his seemingly flawless press conference the day before. He’d taken on all comers, and seemed to have belted them to the far pavilions whence they came.
And yet a week later, the share price of the original villainous trio from the Sandpapergate scandal – Cameron Bancroft, David Warner and Steve Smith – has risen, while the share price of everyone else, led by Cummins, has fallen. Somehow, Cummins, the bloke who had rightly been designated as the bright new face of the game after Cape Town – and who did seriously well in the role – now seems to be travelling worse in public esteem than those who owned up and copped the bans for sandpaper.
Simon Longstaff, the head of the Ethics Centre and the man who led the review into Australian cricket in 2018 post-Cape Town, suggests there is. I interviewed him on Thursday for my weekly Q&A in the Sun-Herald, and his key plea is that Cricket Australia does not go down the legal route as the issue is a problem of culture, not legality. He suggests an ethics commission, whereby you bring all concerned parties into the one room at the one time to search for common ground and resolution.
Dennis Lillee in his playing days.Getty Images“For it to work,” I said to him, “you’d need someone universally respected in the cricket world, who might be able to bring them together for the sake of the game. I have the number of – the great man! – Dennis Lillee. He might be a very good start?”
“Look,” he replied. “I would have a couple of people. You’d need someone with the independence and forensic capacity to look into such matters and to facilitate the necessary conversations. That person should be joined by at least deeply experienced and well-respected individual who understands the world of elite cricket. DK Lillee would be perfect.”
What do you think? One more time from the Randwick end for Dennis, for Australia and Australian cricket. He really is the most universally respected figure in the game. He understands all the nuances of the game, of bowling, of reverse swing, and all the rest. He’d be a reminder to all parties of what the Baggy Green is about, and what is at stake. And who would lie to DK? I reckon it’s worth a try!
Here at TFF, we are ever and always reluctant to acknowledge the existence of other sports writers (sniff), let alone commend them, but allow me – just this once, and extremely reluctantly – to throw bouquets at the work of two colleagues.
The first is Malcolm Knox. Of the million words written and broadcast in the fallout from Bancroft’s bomb, Malcolm’s were the wisest:
“Among the many stunning details in his confession, the most significant is his apology for lying and participating in the cover-up. His motivation for lying was the same as his motivation for cheating: he wanted to fit into the Australian team. Think about that for a moment. Cheating, and then lying about the cheating, were how a young man sought to find his place in the Australian men’s Test cricket team. After sessions when he illegally tampered with the ball in South Africa, Bancroft says he was applauded by his teammates. What a bunch.”
Cameron Bancroft and Pat Cummins.AdvertisementNailed it. Something was crook in Tallarook, down in Cape Town, and by the account of Bancroft there was only one in the whole mob to speak up against it, the hero media manager, Kate Hutchison. Simply gobsmacking.
The other bit of writing I commend to you is from Darren Kane, who warned that the rest of us in the media were too widely reporting anything and everything in the case of the Pullman Five, and that, as the headline said: Presumption of innocence the first casualty in Pullman Five’s trial by media.
“What the past fortnight’s coverage has actually comprised: claims from unnamed and unauthorised sources, which are untested but nonetheless repeated ad nauseam. A lawyer’s assertion that more men were present in the room was reported at face value. Another lawyer said that his instructions reflected a scenario that appalled him more than anything else he’d seen in 28 years of professional practice.”
The column gave me pause at the time, and moreso since. The last lawyer referred to was John Karantzis, who was representing two of the women involved. He told 3AW’s Tom Elliott on August 21: “With what has been alleged, these women were subjected to the most disgusting actions and behaviour I have ever heard about in my 28 years as a lawyer.”
I make no comment on what did or didn’t happen in that hotel room. Like you, I just don’t know. But I do say that now that the police have cleared the Swans players, Karantzis has a case to answer. The “most disgusting actions” you’ve heard of in three decades, Mr Karantzis? I, for one, read that quote and thought the behaviour must have been truly shocking.
And yet when the flames died down and the smoke cleared, the players were free to go. Kane was right. The rest of us should have been far more careful in even reporting such a comment, when he provided not a scintilla of evidence to support it.
You know the drill from Vitas Gerulaitis. Let that be a lesson to you all. NO-ONE beats Wales 35 times in a row!
And what a game it was, the exemplar of my long-held theorem that while nothing is as dull as a dull game of rugby, there’s nothing better than a great one. And here is Wales, with 15 minutes to go against New Zealand, holding on to a 35-28 lead in Cardiff. The delirious fans are singing Land Of My Fathers, and hardly daring to believe that a first Welsh win over the All Blacks in 73 years might be at hand.
But is it? The raging, ravenous New Zealanders are swarming like demented demons from the bowels of very hell, pounding the Welsh line in endless black waves. Surely the men of the dragon will wilt, or break?
But you’ve never seen tackling like it. All up, the hosts make a post-war record of 346 tackles in the match, against New Zealand’s 136. Three times in that 15 minutes, the All Blacks are held up over the try line. The first time is when hooker Asafo Aumua drives over, only to be so completely wrapped up by the Welsh back-rower that he might as well have put a ribbon and a card on top reading, “Return to Sender, Address unknown”.
James Botham poses with the man of the match trophy after helping Wales down the All Blacks at Cardiff.Getty Images Europe But hang on! Is there something familiar about this back-rower who continues to cut the Kiwis down like a whirling dervish, committing his body and very soul to every tackle in such stunning fashion he will shortly be judged as the unanimous Man of the Match? There should be. James Botham is the grandson of no less than Ian “Beefy” Botham, and is putting in a performance credited with turning the entire result.
He made no fewer than 30 tackles in all, including in the lead-up to the final big play of the game, which saw Welsh winger Louis Rees-Zammit tackle All Blacks fly-half Richie Mo’unga into touch near halfway. The stadium erupts as if Wales have scored another try. The ref blows his whistle shortly thereafter, and the Welsh have won.
Ian Botham will be remembered for many things, but none more than the heroics he conjured in the staggering English victory over Australia at Headingley in the third Ashes Test in 1981. No less than 45 years later, his grandson matched him in the rugby stakes, guiding Wales to its most famous victory in generations. Ain’t sport grand without sandpaper?
Couldn’t fit it in last week, but it still needs to be said. That so-called “fight” between Paul Gallen and Nelson Asofa-Solomona at the beginning of the month was as ludicrous as it was disgusting. What is the point in having a boxing authority if they sign off on a contest between a 45-year-old and a 30-year-old, where the older man is giving away 32 kilograms in weight and 20 centimetres in height?
The result? It didn’t even last three minutes, and the “action” was barbarous. At end, Asofa-Solomona’s right hand sent Gallen staggering backwards into the ropes, clearly stunned. Asofa-Solomona then hit him with a left and a right, compounding the damage, before unleashing four vicious uppercuts as he was sinking to the canvas before the ref finally stepped in.
The whole thing was sickening from first to last.
“I’m all right,” Gallen told this masthead afterwards. “I’m fine ... I got paid … I slept fine, gotten up, I’ve eaten. I don’t have a headache, I’m talking OK.”
No, Paul, you’re not fine. What you suffered was yet more irreversible brain damage, and what you’re doing to yourself is – as I told you nigh on a decade ago in the Channel Nine studios – madness.
A pox on the house of all those who enabled you to do it on the way through.
Cameron Bancroft, dropping his truth bomb, on Wednesday: “It was not just the three of us – Steve Smith, David Warner and I – who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team.”
Bancroft: “The final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference. It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone. What I saw, experienced and lived with – not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa – is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time.”
Bancroft again: “The last 24 hours have been special, it shows the Australian spirit is truly living on. I didn’t do this to point fingers or punish or implicate people. I did this for my own peace of mind and for the love and respect of Australian cricket ... I feel really freed and really happy to be able to do that.”
Neil Maxwell, Pat Cummins’ agent, in reply: “There is currently an hysteria unfounded in reality. When you go through it all calmly and in detail, Pat’s 8-year long position and 68-minute Q&A stands up. There is no serious case he was an architect of ball tampering or knew sandpaper was going on the field. It’s also true that the players who were suspended paid far too high a price.”
Welsh rugby player Dewi Lake after Wales broke a 73-year drought against New Zealand: “It’s nice to sit in this room and not be disappointed. We’re a group that trusts each other a lot, and to put on the field what we did today, to make history, it’s tough to put it into words really. But it is nothing this group doesn’t deserve for the work they put in for the last year, year and a half.”
The 81-year-old, respected rugby commentator Huw Llywelyn Davies attended the 1953 game as an eight-year-old with his father: “I never thought I would see it happen again, not unless I lived to 100.”
Reece Walsh on Australians cheering for the Kangaroos to lose: “I can see the culture and I can feel it. I have seen it multiple times on social media, people disrespecting us and saying, ‘I hope Australia loses just to make the game better’. No. If you are an Aussie you need to support and be proud of that. You would never see … a Tongan fan saying, ‘I hope Tonga loses’.” You would if Tonga completely dominated every competition it entered and there was a sham “World Cup” in a sport that Tonga so loved it wanted it to be genuinely global.
Wallabies coach Les Kiss after his team’s loss to Scotland: “Full of fight, that’s for sure. But you want to win those ones.”
Cristiano Ronaldo’s mother, Dolores Aveiro, after Portugal lost 4-1 to Denmark following her son’s retirement from the national team: “They deceived him. And I’m sad, too. The defeat was well-deserved. I was actually glad.” Charmed, they’re sure.
Portugal manager Jorge Jesus dealing with their version of Sandpapergate: “Now I have to respond to Cristiano Ronaldo’s mother? She is a lady I greatly respect – she suffered a lot to raise her children.”
Steffie Waters on the invasion of privacy she has suffered since breaking up with her former fiancé, Isaac Heeney: “The intrusion has been nothing short of disgusting. More generally, I hope that men in the public eye can learn from this and take their responsibility as role models more seriously.”
Builder Gregg Jowett, who found the cadaver of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are in a skip, and posted the video on social media: “I’m at the tip. They’ve tipped a horse in the f---ing bin. You’re f---ing kidding me. That can’t be normal. Does anyone know if that’s legal? I’m disgusted by that. That’s not normal. Please let me know if I’m wrong.”
Cameron Bancroft. Dropped a truth-bomb, eight years in the making, on Australian cricket. Very few are left standing untouched. See rant.
Kate Hutchison. By the account of Bancroft, the media manager of the Australian cricket team at Cape Town in 2018 was the only one to speak up against the use of sandpaper, “making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it.”
Wales. Posted their first win over the All Blacks since 1953, snapping a 34-match losing streak. Wales won the first three – in 1905, 1935 and 1953 – but had to wait more than seven decades for the next. Still, let that be a lesson to you all. NO-ONE beats Wales 35 times in a row!
Australia. Won both the men’s and women’s Rugby League World Cups.
Leihani Zoric. The 14-year-old Australian surfer won the ISA World Surfing Games!
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.