Myanmar genocide ruling beginning of 'the road for justice' for Rohingya, say experts - Anadolu Ajansı

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Anadolu Agency (aa.com.tr). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
The International Court of Justice's (ICJ) historic ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya marks only the beginning of their struggle for long-awaited justice, experts said, stressing the international action and pressure needed to secure compliance.

The International Court of Justice's (ICJ) historic ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya marks only the beginning of their struggle for long-awaited justice, experts said, stressing the international action and pressure needed to secure compliance.

Myanmar genocide scholar Maung Zarni told Anadolu that the ruling was "very, very important" for the Rohingya but would not immediately change the lives of survivors, many of whom remain displaced from their homes.

"It is not the end of the road; it is just the beginning of the road for justice," Zarni said.

He said justice would require more than recognition by the court, including allowing Rohingya refugees to return to their homes and rebuild their lives in safety.

In its judgment on Thursday, the ICJ found Myanmar responsible for genocide committed against the Rohingya during military operations in Rakhine state in 2017.

The ruling followed a case brought by The Gambia in 2019, after military operations forced more than 700,000 Rohingya to flee to neighboring Bangladesh.

Professor Rosa Freedman, an international law expert at the University of Reading, told Anadolu that the ruling was particularly important for the Rohingya, whose ethnic identity has long been denied by Myanmar's authorities.

"The starting point is that Myanmar deny that the Rohingya are even a group of people defined by their ethnicity. They say they're Bengalis, that they're from Bangladesh, and the court has made it very clear that the Rohingya are an ethnic group," she said.

Freedman also pointed to the recognition of the Rohingya's experiences after years of seeking accountability.

"The most important thing to emphasize from today's ruling is that the Rohingya people have waited for years to have this genocide recognized, their suffering recognized on the world's highest court and on the most prominent global stage ...

"The pictures that came in from the internally displaced persons camp and other places where Rohingya live show just how much it means to them to have had their suffering recognized," she said.

The court found that Myanmar had committed acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, including killings, serious bodily or mental harm and measures intended to prevent births within the Rohingya community.

It also found that Myanmar had failed to comply with its earlier order to preserve evidence.

While welcoming the judgment, Zarni questioned whether it would lead to changes for Rohingya survivors without action by governments and international organizations.

He accused Russia and China of supplying weapons to Myanmar's military and providing diplomatic protection to its authorities.

He also accused several governments that intervened in The Gambia's case against Myanmar, including France, Germany and the UK, of double standards over their positions on Israel's military operations in Gaza.

The UK called for an urgent UN Security Council meeting following the ICJ ruling, raising questions about what action the council could take to ensure Myanmar's compliance.

Asked whether such a meeting could lead to concrete measures, Zarni expressed skepticism about the council's ability to act, pointing to the interests of its five permanent members.

"The UN is not representing human beings, human communities in the world. It represents the commercial, strategic, military, diplomatic, and political interest of these states," he said.

Zarni stressed the need to use the ruling to mobilize support from governments while raising awareness and informing public opinion worldwide.

The scholar also raised concerns about the possibility of US sanctions against ICJ judges and their potential impact on the court's independence.

He was referring to the media reports ahead of the Myanmar judgment, on concerns that Washington could impose sanctions against judges, including Nobel peace prize winner Navi Pillay, amid questions about the ruling's possible implications for the Gaza case.

Zarni predicted that the court would reach a similar conclusion in the proceedings concerning Israel.

"I will bet my life that ICJ will reach a similar genocide verdict in the case against Israel," he said.

He argued that the evidence of genocidal intent in Gaza was more explicit than in the Myanmar case, calling it "crystal clear," not only by the scale of the killing and destruction but also by the genocidal intent being expressed openly by Israeli leaders and officials.

Professor Marko Milanovic, an international law expert at the University of Reading, told Anadolu that the judgment would have a significant impact on Rohingya survivors who had waited years for recognition of their suffering.

"I am sure this finding will be enormously impactful on the Rohingya survivors, who will find in this pronouncement a measure of justice that they have long been waiting for," he said.

The ruling, adopted by nine votes to six, also exposed differences among the judges over how to assess evidence of genocidal intent.

Milanovic noted that the court had not fundamentally changed the definition of genocide, but its majority had taken a "more flexible approach" to assessing the evidence compared to the past.

Turning to the possible implications for other genocide cases, including South Africa's case against Israel over Gaza, Milanovic said the disagreement among the judges could also be relevant to those proceedings.

Freedman likewise addressed how the Myanmar judgment could affect the court's examination of evidence in other cases.

"What we can see from this ruling is that there is more scope within the court to look at acts in the totality and to infer a genocidal intent, even where there are maybe other reasonable inferences that could be drawn," she said.

She cautioned, however, against assuming that the court would reach the same conclusion in the Gaza proceedings, explaining that the evidence and circumstances of each case must be examined separately.

Freedman pointed to differences in the evidence available in the Myanmar and Gaza cases, noting that restrictions on information and difficulties conducting investigations in Myanmar had forced the court to rely on second- or third-hand evidence.

"This is materially different to what's happening in Gaza, where we have seen live streaming of the atrocities of the suffering since Israel entered into Gaza," she said.

She noted that significantly more evidence from Gaza had been documented through videos and recordings, although Israel had not allowed the UN or other investigators into the occupied territory to conduct investigations.

Freedman recalled that the ICJ had ordered Israel to preserve evidence in Gaza but cautioned that independent investigations in war zones remained difficult and might only become possible once the war had fully ended.

South Africa filed its case against Israel in December 2023 over violations of the Genocide Convention during the war in Gaza.

The ICJ issued several binding provisional measures in 2024, including orders for Israel to prevent acts of genocide and facilitate humanitarian assistance, but has yet to deliver a final judgment.

The ICJ ordered measures aimed at addressing the consequences of Myanmar's violations, including facilitating the return of displaced Rohingya, family reunification, restitution of property and compensation.

Myanmar must report to the court within two years on the measures taken and compensation proposed, while further proceedings will address the arrangements for compensation.

Freedman said the UN Security Council could play a role in considering how to secure Myanmar's compliance with the judgment and protect Rohingya communities.

She also explained that securing compliance with international law depends on political and economic pressure on governments.

"What we rely on within the international legal system is political and economic pressure and coercion on states to get them to adhere to, to comply with international law," she said.

For Zarni, this "unprecedented" ruling will become "the benchmark for the next case before the court.

"Justice is not confined to just Rohingya," he said.

Original Source
https://www.aa.com.tr/en/world/myanmar-genocide-ruling-beginning-of-the-road-for-justice-for-rohingya-say-experts/4132127
Visit Anadolu Agency ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Defense