John Fetterman Under Threat From Rising Democratic Star - Newsweek
Democratic Senator John Fetterman’s seat is up in 2028, and one rising star in the party has revealed he may be interested in the seat as the list of potential challengers grows.
In an email sent to supporters this week, Representative Chris Deluzio, a progressive Democrat who represents Pennsylvania's 17th Congressional District, said, “I am quite seriously considering running for John Fetterman’s seat, but one of the things I’ll have to know in advance is whether the support is there to take him on.”
He explained that this was because “If we do, we’ll be taking on not only John Fetterman, but AIPAC, Trump, and an overwhelming amount of corporate money spent against us.”
His comments come after Palestinian American writer and businessman Ahmed Moor became the first Democrat to launch a primary challenge against Fetterman last week.
A member of the Democratic Socialists of America, Moor announced that he would run on a progressive platform focusing on issues including free healthcare and affordable housing.
Representative Madeleine Dean has also said that she is weighing a challenge against Fetterman, telling Politico that she was “very disappointed in his activity as a senator and in his votes.”
Newsweek reached out to Deluzio via email for comment.
Fetterman’s relationship with his own party has become increasingly tense in recent months, once viewed as a progressive voice capable of broadening the Democrats’ appeal, now his ongoing support of Israel and relationship with President Trump have fueled speculation that he could be prepared to switch parties.
Earlier this week Senator Ted Cruz said on X: “Sen. John Fetterman is a friend and if he ever decided to become a Republican, we’d welcome him with open arms.”
However, when asked by a reporter on Capitol Hill if he would switch parties he became frustrated. “I’m not going to be a Republican!” he said. But he has previously said that if the Democratic party ever officially removed their support for Israel, he would leave them.
When it comes to challengers for his seat, Deluzio represents a serious potential threat for Fetterman.
Polling analyst Adam Carlson said earlier this week that, “Chris Deluzo is now officially 3x electoral overperformer who has just won re-election in what used to be a swing district by 26 points,” adding, “Godwilling, he will be the next U.S. Senator from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.”
"I'm giving serious thought to running for our Senate seat in '28," Deluzio said during an interview with MeidasTouch. "Fetterman's been a mess and he doesn't take the job seriously. Whatever I decide to do, that guy is not going to be the senator in '28."
Deluzio has demonstrated considerable electoral strength in his western Pennsylvania district, taking 63 percent of the vote against Republican Tony Guy’s 37 percent in the recent midterms House vote.
Split Ticket, an independent election-analysis group, uses a metric called Wins Above Replacement (WAR) to estimate how much a candidate helped or hurt their party’s performance relative to what a replacement-level candidate from the same party would be expected to achieve.
In its analysis of the 2026 elections, the model gave Deluzio a +2.3 WAR, indicating that he performed around 2.3 percentage points better than the model would expect from a replacement-level Democratic candidate in his 2026 House race. Though this does not indicate how Deluzio would perform in a race against Fetterman.
Contact Newsweek editor on this story: Edward Pearcey.
