Joe Biden’s Book Called Out Over Lack of Accountability - Newsweek
Former President Joe Biden has used his new memoir, Promise Me, America, to make the case for his presidential legacy.
But book reviewers have largely made the same criticism—that Biden fails offer any meaningful reflection on the contentious aspects of his presidency. Instead, he offers a defensive, and largely self-congratulatory, account of his time in office.
"Enumerating the wins is easy. The true test of a book like this is whether its author will own his losses, too. Biden, for his part, does not," Jennifer Szalai wrote for The New York Times.
"He is so preoccupied with burnishing his legacy that he gets awkward and defensive when addressing the two issues many readers will be most curious about: his handling of the war in Gaza, and his decision to run for a second term," she said.
Many reviewers expressed incredulity at Biden’s continued insistence in the memoir that he was the best person to run against Donald Trump in 2024. This was despite growing questions about his age and fitness for office.
"Mr. Biden’s account of his unwilling exit from the 2024 election is surely among the most gratingly self-pitying recitals ever penned by an American president," Barton Swaim wrote for The Wall Street Journal.
Biden is "neither reflective nor repentant. He does not concede mistakes, and seems to regret almost nothing," Matt Viser wrote for The Atlantic.
When addressing his disastrous debate performance, which proved to be his campaign’s death knell, reviewers noted that Biden takes little responsibility. Instead, he primarily seems to take umbrage with unfair media coverage and Democratic top brass pressuring him to step aside.
Amy Davidson Sorkin wrote in The New Yorker that, although concerns about his fitness for office ended his reelection bid, in his memoir, Biden "treats all such inquiries as extraneous and gratuitous."
"Biden is as stubbornly in denial as ever," she said.
The New York Times review described Biden’s reaction to the debate critiques as "sulking." Katie Stallard, writing for the New Statesman, called his tone "self-pitying."
The Telegraph’s Zoe Strimpel, meanwhile, said the book comes across as "arrogant and defensive."
Many reviewers noted that Biden offered similarly limited assessments of some of the major foreign-policy issues that have come to define his legacy.
On the war in Gaza, for which Biden was criticized for his continued support of Israel despite mounting civilian casualties, The New Statesman said that Biden "portrays himself as remarkably helpless in his attempts to restrain Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu." The New York Times described his account of the subject as "defensive."
Similarly, on the topic of the chaotic withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan, The Wall Street Journal review said Biden "exhibits not the slightest capacity for self-criticism."
Meanwhile, the Democrat’s memoir devotes a fair amount of space to recounting his perceived achievements as president—as any presidential memoir would. But several reviewers took issue with the self-congratulatory tone in which he does so.
The New Statesman review said that, if the book had been written by someone else, it might be considered "fawning and obsequious."
"That it was written by the former president himself displays a remarkable lack of self-reflection and humility for a man he likes to refer to himself—including in this book—as "Amtrak Joe," the review continued.
The Telegraph review said: "Biden takes an unapologetically grand view of himself, not just in describing his 2021 ascent to the Oval Office, but in situating himself in history."
"Joe Biden wants you to know that he is proud of himself," the New York Times review added.
"One thing is clear from Promise Me, America: there will be no apology from him. He is sticking to his guns. Whatever else has been shaken and stirred in Trump’s America, Biden’s rock-solid self-belief stands firm," Justin Webb wrote for The Times of London.
While the reviews were not critical in their totality, they largely concluded that the memoir failed to offer an honest account of the decisions and controversies that shaped Biden's presidency.
"Mr. Biden made a terrible decision when he tried to run for reelection. He made another when he published this book," The Wall Street Journal concluded its review.

