Israeli experts warn Myanmar genocide ruling could strengthen Gaza case at ICJ - Middle East Eye
Thursday's landmark ruling by the International Court of Justice (ICJ), holding Myanmar responsible for genocide against its Rohingya minority, has raised alarm among Israeli officials and legal experts over its potential implications for the genocide case against Israel over Gaza.
"This is a dangerous precedent," a senior Israeli official told Ynet, referring to the ruling, which marked the first time the ICJ had found a state responsible for committing genocide.
"This sets parameters and standards that, admittedly, you can't apply one-to-one to Israel, but it opens the door," the official added. While Israel's case in Gaza is "more complicated", the ruling "certainly doesn't do us any good".
Another Israeli official told the public broadcaster Kan 11 that the decision reflected "worrying trends" at the top UN court, but insisted Israel could avoid a similar ruling in the case brought by South Africa in December 2023.
The official said Israel could withstand "any legal test", insisting that "we did not commit a genocide". They estimated that a final judgment in the Gaza genocide case would not be delivered before 2030.
Since October 2023, when Israel launched its military onslaught on the Gaza Strip following the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October, UN officials, genocide experts and humanitarian organisations have accused Israel of committing genocide in the besieged enclave.
Since then, the Israeli army has killed more than 74,000 Palestinians, most of them children, women and elderly people. Israel has also used starvation as a weapon, depriving Palestinians of basic necessities, while air strikes and bulldozers have devastated much of Gaza's built environment.
Israeli legal experts who spoke to Ynet echoed officials' concerns about the potential implications of Thursday's ruling for Israel.
Yuval Shany, an international law expert at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, told the outlet that the ICJ ruling "should worry Israel", arguing that the court had changed "the method by which acts of genocide are proven".
Shany said the decision signalled a shift towards "a holistic examination of all the circumstances and the only reasonable conclusion that can be drawn from them".
"There is also a greater willingness to view harm that does not involve loss of life as part of the elements of the offence," he added.
Alan Baker, director of the Institute for Diplomatic Affairs at the Jerusalem Centre for Security and Foreign Affairs, an Israeli research group, dismissed South Africa's genocide accusations against Israel but said the ruling was nevertheless concerning.
"Political considerations and the atmosphere in the international arena could influence how the case against Israel is examined in the future," Baker said, adding that "Israel must prepare for this legally and diplomatically".
Tammy Caner, head of the Law and National Security Programme at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), told Ynet that the court's decision could have far-reaching consequences for Israel.
"For the first time, the International Court of Justice has determined that a state bears direct responsibility for committing genocide," she said, adding that "for Israel, the central issue is how the court examined the specific intent required for genocide".
The practical implication for Israel, Caner said, was that presenting its military objective of eliminating Hamas would not, in itself, be enough to rule out genocidal intent.
The INSS expert also noted that ICJ judges had emphasised states' obligations to prevent genocide, including investigating reported crimes and holding those responsible accountable.
"From Israel's perspective," she said, the ruling underscored "the importance of taking effective preventive and enforcement measures and documenting them".

