Human vs. ChatGPT NFL Week 11 betting picks: A struggling human backs ugly underdogs to stop the slide

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from Fox News (foxnews.com). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
A 4-11 skid leaves the human searching for answers, while ChatGPT enters NFL Week 11 with two straight winning cards and a chance to erase a shrinking deficit.

If I wasn’t officially ice cold entering Week 10, I certainly am entering Week 11. After another losing week (2-3, -1.33 units), I am now 4-11 and down 8.52 units since the start of Week 8.

But there is good news. As someone who publicly posts betting picks on the internet, I’ve often said that you either need to be really good or really bad. If you’re really good, people can follow your picks and make money. If you’re really bad, people can fade your picks and make money. If you’re just average, then you basically just lose the juice and cost everyone money. That’s the worst-case scenario.

ONE WILD WEEK 11 BETTING STAT SHOWS JUST HOW FAR APART THE NFL’S BEST AND WORST TEAMS ARE

Right now, I might be one of the best on the internet at providing fadable NFL picks. And that’s something. It’s not great for me. But it’s good for you. And my No. 1 priority is the audience, so you know what? It’s good for me, too.

Both of us get five selections from the same odds board, with no bet priced worse than -120. Odds were taken from the board supplied Thursday at 4 p.m. ET.

Stakes are adjusted so every winning bet produces one unit of profit. For example, -110 requires risking 1.10 units, while +110 requires approximately 0.91 units. A push returns the stake and counts as zero units.

Washington won outright on Thursday Night Football, and the Dolphins-Colts over got us another winner. I thought I was headed toward a winning week, but Drake Maye suffered a potentially season-ending ankle injury in the first quarter against Detroit (not the first time a team we bet on lost its quarterback in the first 15 minutes of a game).

Then, the Texans had a 17-0 lead and blew it against the CLEVELAND BROWNS. That pretty much sums up my season. Actually, the Steelers falling into a 31-3 hole against the Bengals probably sums it up better.

WHICH NFL TEAMS CAN ACTUALLY WIN THE SUPER BOWL? RANKING ALL 32 AT THE SEASON’S HALFWAY POINT

GPT went 3-2 for the second straight week and picked up another 0.77 units. The Chiefs and Bills covered comfortably, while the Vikings and Packers stayed under the total. The 49ers and Cowboys combined for 86 points, so that was a bad miss.

Then it joined me on Pittsburgh. I was right about one thing: "Theoretically, I should be more confident now, but suddenly I'm worried. That can't be good, right?" That's what I wrote when GPT spit out the same Pittsburgh pick that I had. I guess I was right that I was probably going to be wrong.

DAN: 23-26-1, -5.32 units

GPT: 22-27-1, -6.90 units

I still lead GPT by 1.58 units, although bragging about losing less money than a robot probably tells you everything you need to know about how this season is going.

Dan Z.’s Plug Your Nose and Hit ‘Place Bet’ Bet of the Week: 6-3, +2.83 units

At least the Plug Your Nose bet is making money. Maybe the problem is that I’m only picking one of those per week.

Tennessee Titans at Dallas Cowboys, Sunday at 1 p.m. ET

Dan’s analysis:

Nothing says "let’s turn this season around" like betting on the Tennessee Titans. But this is the kind of ugly underdog I want to be backing. Tennessee has scored at least 23 points in four straight games, while Dallas ranks last in yards allowed and 30th in scoring defense. Changing the defensive play-caller to Mike Pettine shows how desperate the Cowboys are to adjust, but Pettine doesn't magically help the personnel get better.

That makes Tennessee this week’s Dan Z.’s Plug Your Nose and Hit ‘Place Bet’ Bet of the Week. The name continues to do a lot of work.

GPT’s analysis:

We’re on the same side. Tennessee has scored at least 23 points in four straight games, and Dallas allows a league-worst 154.1 rushing yards per game. I paid for +9½ because the Titans can lose 31-23 and still cash. That score pushes your bet, but I like getting better than a touchdown at -108.

Pittsburgh Steelers at Philadelphia Eagles, Sunday at 1 p.m. ET

Dan’s analysis:

The Steelers embarrassed us on Sunday Night Football, and now I’m laying points with them on the road. Apparently, I just hate myself.

But getting blown out by Cincinnati doesn’t suddenly make Pittsburgh a bad team. The Steelers are still 6-3, while Philadelphia is 2-7 and starting Joe Milton III for the second time. I think Pittsburgh’s pass rush can make life difficult for an inexperienced quarterback and create the kind of mistakes that help a road favorite cover. I expect T.J. Watt and company to want to make a statement after the embarrassment on Sunday Night Football.

NFL WEEK 10 SUNDAY TAKEAWAYS: BENGALS LOOK UNBEATABLE, CHIEFS ARE SCARY AGAIN, DEMECO RYANS IS ON THE HOT SEAT

GPT’s analysis:

Pittsburgh was the first side I left off my card. Joe Milton took seven sacks against the Giants, and the Steelers allow just 83.2 rushing yards per game. Philadelphia may have to let him throw. My concern is Pittsburgh averaging only 1.55 points per road drive. I’d pay five cents more for -4 in case this ends 20-16.

New York Jets at Los Angeles Chargers, Sunday at 4:05 p.m. ET

Dan’s analysis:

Of course the Chargers finally won when I stopped betting on them. Another symbol of just how this season has gone.

But one win doesn’t convince me that this offense is fixed, especially since it gained less than 300 yards against the Ravens. Los Angeles still averages just 16 points per game, while the Jets average 19.4. The Chargers are also returning from a Monday night game in Baltimore, leaving them a shorter week to prepare.

Neither defense is airtight, and a couple of turnovers that hand the opponent a short field could ruin this. Still, I’m expecting more stalled drives than fireworks because neither team is great at forcing turnovers (Jets have 12 takeaways this season and the Chargers have 14).

GPT’s analysis:

This was my favorite game to bet under. The Jets have gone two full games without a touchdown, and the Chargers just won with Justin Herbert throwing for 129 yards. I’d still take 41½ at -105. I prefer 42 at -108 because those extra three cents get my money back if this finishes 23-19.

Minnesota Vikings vs. San Francisco 49ers, Sunday Night Football in Mexico City

Dan’s analysis:

San Francisco just scored 46 points against Dallas, but I’m not treating the Cowboys’ defense as a preview of this matchup. Minnesota allows the fewest points per drive in the NFL and ranks second in defensive EPA per play. This defense can make the 49ers work for their points, and I expect them to do just that.

Kirk Cousins immediately improved the Vikings’ offense, and I think Kirko Chainz can keep this within a field goal on Monday Night Football in Mexico City (just don’t look up Cousins’ record in primetime).

GPT’s analysis:

Minnesota allows 14 points per game, and a 23-20 loss in Mexico City would cash this ticket. My hesitation is San Francisco’s offense, which leads the NFL in points per drive and offensive EPA per play. That kept me off the Vikings at -120.

Cincinnati Bengals at Washington Commanders, Monday Night Football

Dan’s analysis:

Yes, I’m fading the Bengals again even though I couldn’t have been more wrong with my approach last week against Pittsburgh. This game perfectly fits my NFL betting approach: Cincinnati looked terrific in a standalone game, and now I’m getting nearly a touchdown with a home underdog that has extra rest after playing on Thursday Night Football. Plus, I’m a Jayden Daniels truther.

GPT’s analysis:

Jayden Daniels’ legs give Washington a way to keep this close, especially with the extra rest after Thursday Night Football. I took Cincinnati because Washington blitzes on 42.1% of dropbacks and Joe Burrow completes 73.4% against the blitz. We can both win this one, though. Bengals 27, Commanders 21 would do it.

For full transparency, I used GPT-6.2 Astra with the thinking effort set to ultra. I supplied the odds board captured Thursday at 4 p.m. ET and gave it the following prompt:

"Pick your five best bets for Week 11 based on the odds provided. No bet can be priced worse than -120. Review every spread, total and moneyline that falls within those parameters and determine whether it belongs among your five picks. Explain exactly why you’re selecting each of the five bets. Also explain exactly why you’re passing on the eligible bets you don’t select. Use at least 10 different sources for each game so you have a broad understanding of everything surrounding each game. Before delivering the results, do a fact-check and ensure that everything is correct."

After 10 minutes of thinking, here is what it came up with:

Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Detroit Lions, Sunday at 1 p.m. ET

GPT’s analysis:

Jahmyr Gibbs just put up 252 yards from scrimmage in Munich. Tampa Bay gives him a tougher draw. The Bucs have held opposing teams below 100 rushing yards in eight straight games, and they lead the league in rushing yards per game themselves. Tampa can take time off the clock and make Detroit do the same.

Detroit has allowed 14.4 points per game during its five-game winning streak. Tampa Bay fails to pick up a first down on 37.1% of its possessions. Even if Baker Mayfield plays, the Lions can win 27-17 and there’s still room under 45½.

GPT’s projected score: Lions 24, Buccaneers 17

Dan’s analysis:

Both teams like to run the ball, so I can see this staying under. But the Lions' defense has taken a big hit in recent weeks, losing Jack Campbell and Aidan Hutchinson and the Bucs can score if Baker Mayfield plays. I'd probably avoid this total.

Tennessee Titans at Dallas Cowboys, Sunday at 1 p.m. ET

GPT’s analysis:

Tennessee has scored at least 23 points in four straight games since picking up the tempo on offense. Dallas just gave up 584 yards to San Francisco and changed defensive play callers. Mike Pettine’s first assignment is fixing a run defense that allows a league-worst 154.1 yards per game.

Dak Prescott could have another big day against a defense that’s allowed 40 or more in back-to-back games. At +7½, a late Dallas field goal that stretches a six-point lead to nine beats me. At +9½, I can live with it.

GPT’s projected score: Cowboys 31, Titans 24

Dan’s analysis:

I'm also on Tennessee, but I elected to take fewer points with less juice. Still, I obviously favor siding with the Titans this week.

New York Jets at Los Angeles Chargers, Sunday at 4:05 p.m. ET

GPT’s analysis:

The Jets got all 24 of their points against the Chiefs and Bills from eight field goals. The Chargers finally won in Baltimore with Justin Herbert throwing for just 129 yards. They ran for 160, and they have every reason to give the ball to Omarion Hampton again against a Jets defense allowing 135.3 rushing yards per game.

The last five Jets games all cleared 42, but Kansas City and Buffalo scored 35 and 31 to get the last two there. The Chargers average 16. I’ll take the under.

GPT’s projected score: Chargers 20, Jets 16

Dan’s analysis:

Well, GPT and I are finding a lot of common ground this week. That's probably bad news for the robot. Sorry, buddy.

Jacksonville Jaguars at New York Giants, Sunday at 4:25 p.m. ET

GPT’s analysis:

Jacksonville has scored at least 30 points in four straight games, and the defense allows just 16 per game. That gives Trevor Lawrence some room for an ordinary afternoon. If Jacksonville scores 24, the Giants need at least 19 against the NFL’s second-ranked scoring defense to cover.

The Giants force a three-and-out on a third of their opponents’ drives, and Jacksonville is starting backup center Jonah Monheim. That’s why I want -5½. If New York forces Lawrence to settle for a late field goal and Jacksonville wins 23-17, I still cash.

GPT’s projected score: Jaguars 27, Giants 20

Dan’s analysis:

I looked at the Giants but couldn't pull the trigger. The Jags have done a good job this season of beating up on bad teams and, yes, the Giants are a bad team. I'm not sold on Jacksonville overall, but I couldn't get there with the Giants in Week 11.

Cincinnati Bengals at Washington Commanders, Monday Night Football

GPT’s analysis:

Washington sends extra rushers on 42.1% of dropbacks. That’s a dangerous way to play Joe Burrow, who completes 73.4% of his passes against the blitz. It gets worse for Washington inside the 20. The Commanders have allowed touchdowns on 23 of 32 red-zone trips, and Cincinnati has scored at least 31 points in five straight wins.

Jayden Daniels’ legs and the extra rest after Thursday Night Football give Washington a chance to hang around. I’ll pay -115 for the half-point so a 27-21 Bengals win still cashes.

GPT’s projected score: Bengals 31, Commanders 24

Dan’s analysis:

Well, GPT and I are opposite here. Based on recent results, that's bad news for me.

OK, that's it for Week 11! Last week, I said I was extremely confident before posting another losing week. This week, I think I'm probably going to go 0-5. Let's see if the reverse jinx can help us turn it around.

Original Source
https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/human-vs-chatgpt-nfl-week-11-betting-picks-struggling-human-backs-ugly-underdogs-stop-slide
Visit Fox News ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in Sports