German defense minister apologizes for calling US criticism of Ukraine strikes ‘stupid’
BERLIN — German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius has personally apologized for his earlier remarks lambasting a senior Pentagon official’s criticism of Ukrainian strikes inside Russia as “quite a stupid thing.”
“I apologized for my choice of words,” Pistorius said in a Friday phone interview with POLITICO. He said that he had spoken by phone Wednesday evening with Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon’s top policy official.
However, Pistorius underlined that he has not changed his support for the Ukrainian strikes themselves.
“But I also made clear — and he sees it the same way — that we simply have different views on this.” The two sides “agree to disagree,” Pistorius said.
The apology follows a public clash at Tuesday’s meeting of Ukraine’s military backers in Brussels. Colby questioned the effectiveness of Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian oil infrastructure and other targets, arguing they had done little to end the war or halt Russian advances.
In a joint news conference following the meeting, Pistorius said: “Criticizing strikes like that in Russia to destroy strategic military … targets is quite a stupid thing.”
The minister on Friday acknowledged that his language had been inappropriate, explaining that he had reached for the wrong expression while responding to a question in English. “I shouldn’t have done that,” he said.
During Tuesday's conference, U.K. Defense Secretary Wes Streeting also backed Ukraine, but used less colorful language to show his disagreement with Colby, saying: “It’s not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.”
The exchange highlighted differences between Washington and Berlin over Ukraine’s military strategy at a time when Germany is helping finance the development and production of Ukrainian long-range weapons and is Kyiv's largest financial backer.
The clash with Colby isn't the only sign of a disagreement between the U.S. and Europe on Ukraine. After Thursday's meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, U.S. President Donald Trump called European allies to complain about what he characterized as the waste of billions to support Ukraine in a conflict that is killing so many people, three European officials told POLITICO.
Pistorius insisted that the disagreement with Colby would not damage bilateral defense cooperation, which both countries are seeking to deepen through joint weapons production. The U.S. is also a supplier of key weapons like Patriot air defense systems and F-35 jet fighters.
“We are allies, we are partners. But that doesn’t mean we have to agree on everything,” he said, adding that his remarks would not strain relations.
He called Colby an important interlocutor and praised the close exchanges with him and U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
On Ukraine, Pistorius distinguished between helping Kyiv build long-range weapons and deciding how they are used.
“Those are decisions for the Ukrainians to make,” he said. “We support them in developing and producing weapons systems that make this possible, but not only this.”
He described Ukrainian strikes deep inside Russia as “targeted and strategic” and “not directed against the civilian population,” contrasting them with Moscow’s attacks on Ukraine’s energy, electricity and water infrastructure.
The disagreement comes as the Trump administration pushes European allies to take greater responsibility for their own defense — what the U.S. calls NATO 3.0 — while Germany seeks to preserve American military support and expand industrial cooperation.
“NATO’s European allies need the American armed forces,” Pistorius said. “But conversely, the United States also needs close ties with its European allies and needs its bases in Europe, including in Germany.”
Pistorius backed continued talks under the U.S.-championed Bergen format, an informal smaller group of NATO allies discussing how Europe can shoulder more of the continent’s defense.
Asked whether Germany could host future meetings of that format or seek to take over NATO’s top military command — traditionally an American job — Pistorius said: “That will become clear in the coming weeks.” He added: “What matters is that they continue to make clear that we see NATO 3.0 as a shared mission for the future.”
Pistorius also addressed a U.S. proposal for Ukraine to give up territory in the Donbas in exchange for NATO membership as part of negotiations to end Russia’s war.
“So far, I only know the proposals from media reports,” he said, adding that such options should not be discussed publicly but “with Ukraine and all other parties involved, including the Europeans.”
“You cannot negotiate this over other people’s heads,” Pistorius said. “Every idea deserves to be examined, but not every idea is equally good. As for this particular one, I don’t know which applies,” he added. “We will have to see in the upcoming talks.”

