China gloats over Apec summit where Xi got everything he could have hoped for – thanks to Trump - The Independent

Direct Source Verification: This story is aggregated from The Independent (independent.co.uk). Full reporting rights and copyright belong to the primary publisher.
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.

As the unprecedented trilateral talks between the leaders of China, Russia, and America concluded with all the pomp and spectacle, there was little doubt about who was claiming victory.

China could hardly contain its glee over the meeting between Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, and Donald Trump, with Beijing celebrating what it saw as a diplomatic triumph for the Chinese president.

The engagement at the Apec summit in Shenzhen yielded little in the way of concrete breakthroughs, but for Xi, bringing the leaders of the US and Russia to the same table was an achievement in itself. The Chinese leader was at the centre, facing a cluster of cameras directly, playing convener, and calling on Putin and Trump to speak in turn.

From triumphant headlines in state media to glowing assessments of Xi’s diplomatic prowess, Beijing promptly seized on the meeting to present China as the centre of global diplomacy, a stabilising force capable of bringing together rival powers embroiled in seemingly intractable conflicts.

The meeting in Shenzhen lasted over an hour and saw the three leaders read pre-written statements.

The main outcome was a four-point joint statement calling for reform of the UN, increased supplies of refined petroleum products for all countries, and respect for the immunity enjoyed by state officials in international courts.

There was no actionable strategic plan, though, and no mention of Russia’s conflict with Ukraine and the US-Israeli war on Iran.

“The Shenzhen summit was big on spectacle and short on deliverables. The final statement contained four points – platitudes, really – drawn from a lowest common denominator between the three sides,” Kevork Oskanian, lecturer in International Relations at the University of Exeter, told The Independent.

“But actual results weren't the point, symbolism was. Bolstered by his position as the host, Xi was able to present himself as the facilitator of a ‘historic’ event; Putin was afforded the opportunity to act as a respectable statesman welcomed as an equal by fellow great powers; Trump could act as the dealmaker even after the Republican defeat in the midterms.”

Global Times, the mouthpiece of the Communist Party of China, on the other hand, hailed the president for “charting a new blueprint for Asia-Pacific development” and portrayed him as the indispensable host and statesman who made the first-ever trilateral meeting possible.

Chinese analysts praised Beijing’s role as a stabilising force injecting “much-needed” stability into an increasingly chaotic world, and the event as a diplomatic success that advanced China’s preferences.

China seeks to distinguish itself from the US and Russia by projecting an image of a superpower that stays out of wars and champions the interests of smaller nations, according to Ruby Osman, a senior policy adviser at the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change in London.

So, its priority was to steer the meeting away from specific issues and focus on the broader diplomatic spectacle, she argued. “Beijing wanted to be seen as the adult in the room.”

The Shenzhen talks drew parallels with the Yalta Conference of 1945, when the leaders of the three dominant military powers at the time – the US, UK, and Soviet Union – met to discuss the end of the World War and the post-war future.

But unlike Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin, Xi, Trump and Putin aren’t united by a common enemy or a shared objective. Nor do they wield the same influence over the fate of other nations.

“Rather than a Yalta 2.0, this seems to have been a more grandiose reiteration of Trump’s much-hyped – but swiftly forgotten – meeting with North Korea’s Kim Jong Un in 2018: rich in symbolism, lacking any substance,” Oskanian said.

Leif-Eric Easley from Ewha Womans University in Seoul also cautioned against comparisons with Yalta, calling them “misleading and even dangerous”.

“The Shenzhen summit came nowhere near the significance of shaping a new international order, yet it was more than symbolic because when these leaders gather in person, they don’t just read a script,” he told The Independent. “In principle, meeting face to face can help avoid escalation.”

Easley also pointed to who was missing from the room. In the absence of European or Indo-Pacific allies of the US, he warned, China and Russia could press their agendas with an unconventional American president without pushback. Ukraine, which went unmentioned in the joint statement, was a case in point.

When Xi hosted then-president Barack Obama in 2014, he noted, the meeting became significant for brokering a historic climate change agreement. More than a decade later, Trump was unable to secure any substantial agreement on nuclear non-proliferation or a breakthrough on the conflict in Ukraine.

Trump arrived at a turbulent moment in his presidency, soon after his Republican party suffered a crushing defeat in the midterm elections, widespread tech outages unsettled Americans, and Iran escalated its attacks on US assets and allies in the Middle East. Trump heralded the meeting as “really making history”, suggesting the three leaders were shaking things up by ditching the “old school” way adversaries engaged.

Reporters were barred from Trump’s meeting with Putin, although an American television crew was allowed inside. Unlike previous US presidents, Trump made no provision for questions from the press, leaving the two leaders to control the images and messaging emerging from their talks.

“Despite the build-up to this rare trilateral summit, the result was a major disappointment,” Jonathan Fritz, a senior fellow specialising in China at the Center for American Progress, told The Independent.

“Trump failed to extract an agreement from his counterparts to enter nuclear arms control negotiations. This was no surprise given the total lack of preparation for such an ambitious undertaking.”

Trump reiterated on Thursday that he and Xi agreed Iran needed to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, a critical waterway for the world’s energy supplies that became a chokepoint after the US and Israel attacked Iran in February. He said they also agreed that Iran could not obtain a nuclear weapon.

But there was no sign that Trump had secured any agreements from Xi or Putin to help resolve the Iran conflict.

“Putin has done nothing to earn sanctions relief, but Trump and Xi have an interest in better implementing the trade truce they reached on the sidelines of Apec last year,” Easley noted.

For Putin, the meeting marked a return to the high table of global diplomacy and offered a chance to shake off the image of isolation that followed Russia’s invasion of Ukraine without making any major concessions.

Ukraine featured prominently in Russian state media coverage even as the joint declaration avoided any mention of the conflict.

The war dominated Putin’s talks with Trump, which lasted 35-40 minutes, according to Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov. Trump left the Russian leader in an “excellent mood”.

Fritz, however, argued that the summit was “little more than a photo op that allowed Xi Jinping to bolster his stature and give Vladimir Putin a break from his image as a global pariah”.

The trilateral summit may have changed the picture of who sits at the high table. Whether it changes anything on Ukraine, Iran, or nuclear arms control remains to be seen.

Original Source
https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/china/xi-trump-putin-china-apec-trilateral-summit-b3088393.html
Visit The Independent ↗
SHARE STORY:
𝕏 f in

Related Coverage in International Relations