Britons digitally stranded in Europe as EES nightmare persists - The Telegraph
Travellers queue to get through passport control with the new Entry-Exit System in Franjo Tuđman Zagreb International Airport Credit: Alamy Stock Photo/Pixsell Simon Calder Travel Correspondent Show biography Simon co-hosts The Travel Expert podcast at The Telegraph. He has spent three decades as a travel correspondent, covering every significant development in travel and transport from the launch of Eurostar and easyJet to 9/11, the Icelandic volcano and the Covid pandemic. He is known as “the man who pays his way” because he doesn’t accept free transport or accommodation from the travel trade. He also broadcasts widely for national television and radio. Simon also shares travel tips and advice on Instagram @simon_calder
Had the EU deliberately set out on a tourism reduction strategy, it could hardly have done better than the Entry-Exit System (EES), which I characterise as European frontier roulette.
The much-delayed digital borders scheme for the Schengen area finally started registering the ins and outs of “third-country nationals” such as the British in October last year. Only in April 2026, though, did EES go 100 per cent across Europe. From the Norwegian-Russian border deep in the Arctic to Canary Islands airports off the coast of Africa, every frontier post is supposed to be digitally connected to a central database located in the French city of Strasbourg, with a backup in Austria.
The rules as issued by Brussels are clear. Every third-country national must be registered on the EES database the first time they cross a Schengen frontier. The personal data from their passport are stored, along with both a facial biometric and prints from the four fingers of the right hand.
The Entry-Exit System (EES) collects facial biometrics and fingerprints of non-EU nationals Credit: AFP/Justin Tallis On subsequent crossings, only one biometric is required – usually the face. All stamping of passports will end, I was assured by European Commission officials just days before the implementation.
Yet each of the 29 Schengen area member states is responsible for implementing the system (Gibraltar is a 30th territory covered by EES, with Spanish officials checking arrivals and departures). They have interpreted the instructions in their own way, and in some cases added or subtracted procedures.
Within a week of Europe going “100 per cent EES”, Greece boldly announced it would not take the biometrics of British visitors. But some frontier officials in Italy have been demanding full biometrics on entry and exit – leading in the early stages to missed flights from airports serving Milan, with British passengers left behind because they could not get through the checks in time to reach the gate.
In April, Max Hume from Leeds and his family arrived at the city’s Linate Airport three hours before departure. After standing in line for passport control, they watched their easyJet flight depart without them – along with more than 100 others. The family had to spend over £1,600 on replacement flights.
Michael O’Leary, chief executive of Europe’s biggest budget airline, Ryanair, told The Travel Expert podcast that flight crew would not wait for delayed passengers. He and other travel industry leaders have lobbied intensively for the biometric checks to be suspended until the system is working smoothly.
Problems with the EES caused massive delays in airports across Europe over the summer Credit: Alamy Stock Photo/Hugh Williamson Brussels allows for some flexibility – which is just as well, given that the main departure points for motorists from the UK to France are still offline. Checks for ferry and Eurotunnel travellers are “juxtaposed”, with French officials staffing the borders in Kent and their British counterparts on duty in Calais and Dunkirk.
Both the Port of Dover and the Eurotunnel terminal at Folkestone invested many tens of millions of pounds in facilities for collecting the biometrics of drivers and their passengers. But because of French IT problems, the kit is still not connected to the national system in Paris. Instead, Police aux Frontières (PAF) swipe the “machine readable” code on UK passports to register on the Entry-Exit System.
The opening Saturday of May half-term was the first time British families leaving faced the full force of EES. At the entrance to the Port of Dover, I watched as the PAF, fully staffed for the event, simply could not process travellers fast enough to avoid gridlock. Some motorists queued for three hours. But shortly after 9am, the head of the French operation told staff to cease registering passport details. As if by magic, the logjam vanished.
The beneficiaries of the temporary suspension found themselves in the odd position of not having officially entered the Schengen area. A key aim of EES is to police the strict limit of 90 days in any 180 days for British and other visitors to Europe. For those travellers leaving Dover, the clock that is supposed to count the days spent in the zone did not start. That posed a small problem for frontier staff when they came to leave, since they had never officially arrived. But a much bigger problem for British travellers has since arisen – when border officials have failed to register their departure from the Schengen area.
The worst case I have seen involved Paula Pugh from Norfolk, who in September was deported from Italy – where she had just arrived on a holiday to celebrate her husband’s 60th birthday. She had spent just 22 days in the previous six months within the Schengen area. But the flawed EES database had failed to record a previous departure from the zone.
In September, Paula Pugh was deported from Italy after an EES malfunction while visiting with husband Andrew The fact that she had just stepped off a plane from London Stansted to Reggio Calabria in southern Italy should have indicated to the Polizia di frontiera that she had not, in fact, been in the EU for months. Nonetheless they decided to drive her to the nearest airport with flights the same day back to the UK (Lamezia Terme, 80 miles north), and provide a three-officer police escort onto the Ryanair plane to ensure she left Italy.
Mrs Pugh’s case was, thankfully, an outlier. Much more common is that travellers check their status with the European Commission’s online EES tool and discover that the system believes they are still in the Schengen area.
“I returned from France on June 27, but according to EES I’m apparently still there,” says Neil Tungate of New Milton in Hampshire. “Despite months of correspondence with the French authorities, nobody has corrected the record.”
Mr Tungate has scrupulously followed the European Commission’s advice to travellers concerned about their EES record: “Contact the competent authorities of the Member State where you last entered or exited the Schengen area”. In the case of France, the responsible body is the Directorate General for Foreigners in France (DGEF).
But the local councillor from Hampshire says: “Despite providing documentary evidence, including confirmation of my ferry check-in, I have received no acknowledgement or response to repeated requests for correction sent to the DGEF. I eventually complained to the French data-protection regulator, which has now referred my case to the appropriate department for investigation.”
Neil Tungate of New Milton, Hampshire, says EES believes he is still in France despite him returning to England in June Yet more than four months after returning home, the error on the part of French frontier officials remains unresolved.
“As a retired software engineer and regular traveller to Europe, I understand that complex computer systems can fail,” Mr Tungate says. “What concerns me far more is the apparent lack of an effective procedure for correcting errors when they occur.”
Many other readers of The Telegraph echo this experience. The obvious solution to a problem created by a Europe-wide system would be a central point of contact where travellers can challenge the record. But that is simply not possible due to data privacy rules, according to Dr Nick Brown. He is a “data sleuth” who has studied the theory and practice of EES in great detail.
“This is an interesting example of how, in many areas, the EU has less power than many people think,” says Dr Brown. “The member states have always retained complete sovereignty over the entry of third-country nationals. EES is only there to help the member states collectively enforce the Schengen-wide 90-day limit on visits.
“Moreover, the EU has very strict rules about privacy and data protection, meaning that there are severe limits on who is allowed to see and modify EES data.” The only way that the data can be changed is in the presence of the traveller at a port of entry or exit or under the supervision of national data protection officials. Mostly, officials who identify a discrepancy will sort it out at the border; following the approved European Commission route is likely to be a thankless task.
People for whom the computer says “no days left” are in a difficult position – but there is every likelihood that the problem will be solved on arrival. Airlines do not have access to the EES system to check your status, so you will be allowed on the plane. At the desk, you can produce print-outs of tickets and boarding passes – as well as bank statements that can indicate you were using your debit or credit card was being used regularly in the UK during the period in question.
The only issue I have encountered was a fairly common one: having more than one account with my name and passport details. The issue was identified when I was leaving Basel Airport in Switzerland in July, and the diligent frontier official sorted it out in a few minutes.
The EES system is now in use throughout the EU, but travellers still face problems at the border Credit: Alamy Stock Photo/Avpics What about, though, the threat of a €10,000 fine and a two-year ban from the EU, which the author Jojo Moyes was warned about by French officials – after her departure from Portugal was not registered?
Don’t fret, advises Dr Brown – those penalties are aimed at serial over-stayers who are suspected of working. “There is no ‘automatic ban’ or ‘automatic fine’ for apparent overstays. An indication from the EES computer that somebody has potentially overstayed is just one of many items of information that the border officials – who, again, are acting on behalf of a member state, not the EU – will evaluate when determining whether to allow someone to enter.
“For example, if the record appears to show that you have not left the Schengen area, but you are standing in front of a desk having just arrived on a plane from the UK, the official ought to be able to work out that something isn’t quite correct. And in order to fine or ban you, they have to be satisfied that you have really overstayed.”
A spokesperson for the European Commission told The Telegraph: “If overstay data recorded in the EES are found to be inaccurate, it is the responsibility of the member states to rectify, complete or erase those data. The Commission is in close contact with member states on this matter and has been calling on member states to correctly use the EES and register all border crossings as a matter of priority, underlying the potential impact on travellers.”
In other words: individual countries are causing these problems, and it is up to them to solve them.
