Brazil police chief faces backlash over Supreme Court reports - Valor International
Brazil’s Federal Police is expected to submit revised reports to the Supreme Court on Wednesday (18), detailing references to at least six justices found in messages extracted from the phone of former Banco Master banker Daniel Vorcaro. The documents could determine whether the court’s full bench is asked to authorize investigations involving any of its own members.
Chief Justice Edson Fachin will decide how to handle the findings after police leadership ordered an earlier set of reports rewritten, triggering an internal dispute over investigative independence and the authority of the Federal Police director general. News website UOL first reported the information, and Valor confirmed it.
In a letter sent to the Justice Ministry on Friday (13), Federal Police Director General Andrei Rodrigues said the initial reports prepared by the agency had apparently “gone beyond a merely descriptive account.” He also cited a “breakdown in the relationship of mutual trust that must exist between directly and hierarchically connected management positions.” According to Rodrigues, the investigators had failed to follow instructions to prepare reports covering every reference to Supreme Court justices, “without exception.”
The Federal Police is expected to submit reports on at least six justices whose names appeared in exchanges between Vorcaro and his contacts. Some of the material includes conversations involving the justices’ relatives.
Under the procedure described by the authorities, investigations involving members of the Supreme Court can only proceed with authorization from the court’s full bench.
In early November, the Federal Police prepared an initial version of the documents containing information only about Justices Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli and Kassio Nunes Marques.
Police leadership, however, concluded that the reports had not followed the guidelines agreed upon with Fachin. The documents were therefore ordered rewritten to include every justice mentioned in the material extracted from Vorcaro’s phone. The revised reports are expected to include references to Justices Gilmar Mendes, Luiz Fux and André Mendonça.
In his letter, Rodrigues also explained that he had instructed the Federal Police’s Directorate for Investigations and Combating Organized Crime and Corruption to extract information potentially relevant to criminal proceedings involving Supreme Court justices from material seized during Operation Compliance Zero.
He stressed, however, that the work was to be carried out without conducting any investigative steps or making judgments about the justices’ conduct.
The Justice Ministry requested the explanation after Federal Police leadership removed two senior investigators, Daniel Mostardeiro Cola and Wedson Cajé Lopes, from their positions overseeing investigations involving Banco Master and Brazil’s national pension agency. Both had prepared the original reports.
In the letter to the ministry, Rodrigues said the personnel changes had been made on grounds of “administrative convenience and discretion.”
He maintained that there had been “no assumption of control over or interference in a criminal investigation,” describing the decision instead as an administrative measure intended to ensure strict compliance with a judicial order and applicable law.
The removal of the two investigators prompted the National Association of Federal Police Investigators, which represents officers who lead criminal investigations, to issue a statement condemning the decision as “interference.”
The dispute strained relations between Rodrigues and the association, prompting the Federal Police chief to resign his membership after more than two decades.
Nevertheless, at a ceremony marking Federal Police Day at the agency’s headquarters on Monday (16), Rodrigues denied that the institution was experiencing a crisis. He said it was unacceptable for “isolated voices” to consider themselves more important than the Federal Police itself.
He made the remarks alongside Justice and Public Security Minister Wellington César Lima e Silva.
“There is no crisis, no internal split, much less any loss of autonomy within the Federal Police. We have more than 16,000 employees, Minister Wellington, working in more than 100 Federal Police units, all pursuing a common purpose. We cannot allow isolated voices to believe they are bigger than the Federal Police itself. It must be understood once and for all that the Federal Police is on only one side: that of serious, professional and impartial work.”
In his speech, the director general also said that he and his family had been attacked and that he would not yield to intimidation.
“No matter how much they attack the institution, me and my family directly, they will not intimidate us, because we know what lies behind all this: greed, strategic positions and control of our institution,” he said.
Rodrigues continued: “I will not retreat a single inch from my uncompromising defense of the Constitution and the law, or from defending the prerogatives of every position and function within this institution, including that of director general.” He also said hierarchy and discipline were indispensable principles of the Federal Police.
“As are technical autonomy and professional accountability. Indeed, one cannot function without the other. Otherwise, they give rise to the abuses and harmful practices we experienced not so many years ago, with disastrous consequences for the criminal justice system and the country.”
In a statement released last week, the investigators’ association said the removal of the two officers responsible for the initial reports on Supreme Court justices in the Banco Master case reflected “a recurring approach by the current Federal Police leadership, marked by actions that run counter to principles historically observed by the institution.”
These principles, the association said, included respect for the authority of investigators leading criminal inquiries and the need for management to maintain an appropriate distance from criminal investigative work.
During Monday’s ceremony, Rodrigues used a metaphor to respond indirectly to the investigators’ criticism: “I will never hesitate to defend our institution vigorously and at all times. Everyone knows that under this administration, as the saying goes, the tail does not wag the dog,” he said.
Federal Police anti-corruption director Dennis Cali, who oversees the department that prepared the Banco Master reports and ordered them rewritten, did not attend the ceremony. However, other senior police officials were present. Valor learned that Cali was on an assignment outside Brasília.
The justice minister, who had demanded an explanation from Rodrigues over the removal of the two investigators, arrived at the event alongside the Federal Police chief. The two spoke and appeared to be on cordial terms.
At the beginning of his speech, Rodrigues also praised the associations representing Federal Police agents and forensic experts, while making no mention of the investigators’ association from which he had resigned. According to Rodrigues, the organizations representing those two groups had acted “responsibly,” even without aligning themselves with his administration.
This article was translated from Valor Econômico using an artificial intelligence tool under the supervision of the Valor International editorial team to ensure accuracy, clarity, and adherence to our editorial standards. Read our Editorial Principles.

